The latest Indaba text: bad for the developing world | Centre for Science and Environment

Friday, December 9, 2011 - 22:52
Friday, December 9, 2011 - 22:52

The latest Indaba text: bad for the developing world

Chandra Bhushan

Durban, December 9: Today morning at 8.00 am the Indaba Text, which is a proposal of the CoP Chair on the major outcomes from the Durban conference, was released. The text has the following elements which could eventually form the basis of a Durban declaration or agreement:

Amendments to the Kyoto Protocol (KP) for the second commitment period that does not lead to a gap between the first and the second commitment periods -- this means that some Kyoto Parties will take a legally binding second commitment under KP, and the second commitment period will start on January 1, 2013. There is no mention of what will be the targets for Annex 1 countries. EU has not put its commitment on the table. It will only declare its quantified emissions target next year. Considering that it will take at least one year to convert targets in to QUELROS, the question to be asked is why is EU not announcing its targets now here in Durban.   

Making the Cancun Agreement operational. 

One-year extension to the Ad Hoc Working Group on Long-term Cooperative Action (AWG-LCA) to complete the process of the Bali Action Plan (BAP). Does this mean all the pillars of BAP – mitigation, adaptation, technology transfer and finance – will be successfully negotiated, or does it imply a new process will start to discuss the same things? 

Launch a new process to develop a new legal framework applicable to all countries after 2020. 

To do this, a new subsidiary body (a new Ad Hoc Working Group or AWG) under the convention to be established next year in Qatar. 

This Ad Hoc Working Group will start its work immediately and will complete its work in 2015. In 2015, parties will adopt the new legal treaty.

The new Ad Hoc Working Group will also work on mitigation, adaptation, finance, technology development and transfer and capacity building. AWG-LCA is working on the same issues!

The review of mitigation targets will happen during 2013-2015. Based on the review, the 5th assessment report of the IPCC and the work of the Subsidiary Bodies, countries will increase the ambition of their mitigation targets -- which they committed under the Cancun Agreement -- in 2015.

This big picture does not make any sense. The world has been negotiating for the last four years under the Bali Action Plan. Under AWG-LCA, the world had to arrive at an agreed outcome on mitigation, adaptation, finance, technology development and transfer and capacity building. AWG-LCA will finish next year. The issue is, will we have an agreed and comprehensive outcome on all the Bali Action Plan pillars or will it be just the end of the process. This is important to understand because according to this Indaba text, a new AWG will start work on the same issues for a new “legally binding treaty” for all -- which will be applicable from 2020. Why set up another AWG so soon when the implementation of the first has not happened? Why sign a treaty in 2015 which will be implemented five years later? 

This Indaba text has nothing on equity. It does not mention that the new legal framework applicable to all countries will be based on the principles of equity and common but differentiated responsibility and respective capability (CBDR). 

Our analysis is that this text is bad for developing countries and bad for the world. It only allows developed countries to continue polluting and shift the burden of mitigation to the developing countries – it should be roundly rejected by developing countries. 


India's environment minister Jayanthi Natarajan speaks during a break of Indaba, the final negotiation process of the CoP17 at Durban
NGO's flash protest - NGO's from around the world protest inside the convention center sneaking passed the UN security
Do no support companies that burn waste, said the Global Alliance of Waste Pickers at a protest demonstration during the COP17 at Durban
To boot out or not to boot out the USA: A debate between LDC & The EU

DTE Cover Story

Press Releases

Wednesday, December 7, 2011 - 10:44
India's environment minister says "equity is central to any debate on climate change" | Comments

Makes her first public address in Durban at a side event organised by CSE in association with the ministry

  Contact us
  Durban: Delhi:
  Chandra Bhushan Papia Samajdar
  Email: Email:
  Phone: +27 732335697 Phone: +91 9811906977
  Skype ID: csechandra  
  Souparno Banerjee  
  Phone: +27 71 023 3222  


Tuesday, December 6, 2011 - 11:46
India's Intervention at the LCA Plenary

Intervention of India in the LCA stocktaking plenary 10:00-11:30 AM; 5th December 2011

Wednesday, November 30, 2011 - 16:55
Cancun Agreements

Report of the Conference of the Parties on its sixteenth session, held in Cancun from 29 November to 10 December 2010

Download pdf


Tuesday, December 6, 2011 - 18:06
The imperative of equity for an effective climate agreement | Comments

By Sunita Narain, director-general, CSE

Download pdf

Tuesday, December 6, 2011 - 18:06
Equity and the transition to a low carbon economy | Comments

By Chandra Bhushan, deputy director, CSE

Download pdf

Tuesday, December 6, 2011 - 18:06
Furthering Climate Justice : Protecting the Vulnerable, Compensation for Impacts | Comments

By Ambuj Sagar, Vipula and Mahesh Chaturvedi Professor of Policy Studies Indian Institute of Technology Delhi

Download pdf