Down to Earth
Sign up for newsletter
Down to Earth Facebook Down to Earth Twitter Down to Earth Twitter
 
December 8-14, 2023
 
     
A weekly digest on impacts, politics and science of the climate emergency; from the Global South perspective. Access our extensive coverage on climate. You can find this newsletter in the web here.
Dear readers,

Welcome to the Climate Weekly newsletter by the Centre for Science and Environment’s Climate Change programme and Down to Earth.

We write to you just having returned from COP 28 last week in Dubai, where we spent two weeks observing the negotiations and capturing the conversation.

COP 28 concluded with the adoption of the outcome on the first Global Stocktake (GST), an assessment of progress on the goals of the Paris Agreement. A part of a package of accepted decisions titled ‘The UAE Consensus’, the GST recognises the need for deep, rapid and sustained reductions in greenhouse gas emissions in line with 1.5C pathways. It therefore calls on countries to triple renewable energy capacity globally, phase down unabated coal power, and transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. This recognition of the role played by fossil fuels is historic and is occurring for the first time in over 30 years of climate negotiations. Says Sunita Narain, Director-General of CSE, in our press release: “The inclusion of fossil fuels in the GST is an important starting point for the world to now discuss the road ahead, which must be based on funding and fairness.”

The GST document has its flaws – it has plenty of loopholes that fossil fuel producing entities can exploit to expand production. Many argue that inscribing in text the role of fossil fuels, 30 years after climate negotiations commenced, and when robust science has loudly proclaimed their harm for years, is borderline comical. We do not disagree with those viewpoints. But COP summits are a unique space where climate science and rhetoric meet real geopolitics and complex economic dynamics of a heterogenous set of 200 countries of the world. And the COP is a consensus-based process, where each country has to agree on every word in the final decision text. From that perspective, given the number of developing and developed countries who depend on and profit from fossil fuel revenues, this is a milestone achievement that must be given its due.

COP 28 also saw the operationalisation of the Loss and Damage Fund, a step that we welcomed. It is crucial that the Fund gets replenished periodically with new and additional grant-based finance from developed countries in line with the needs of developing countries, and without conditionalities. There was also agreement on a much overdue Global Goal on Adaptation.

Our delegation from CSE-DTE tracked issues ranging from mitigation, adaptation, loss and damage, and carbon markets, to broader topics such as industrial decarbonization and urban climate action.

Left to right: Joel Michael (DTE), Parth Kumar (CSE), Rohini Krishnamurthy (DTE), Avantika Goswami (CSE), Tamanna Sengupta (CSE), Akshit Sangomla (DTE), Trishant Dev (CSE)
     
  Down To Earth  
     
  We were grateful for the opportunity to listen in on negotiations and observe climate politics play out up close, and will continue the hard work of analysis, commentary, and advocacy on climate policy issues relevant for the Global South through the coming year.  
   
 
Down To Earth
 
By - Avantika Goswami
Climate Change, CSE
 
 
   
 
EXTREME WEATHER TRACKER
 
Arctic Report Card 2023: Wildfires to melting sea ice, warmest summer on record had cascading impacts across Arctic, 14 December 2023
Down To Earth
 
   
 
Down To Earth Climate change: If warming approaches 2°C, a trickle of extinctions will become a flood, 12 December 2023
 
     
 
Up to 2.6 billion people in Asia, Africa could be exposed to heatwaves by 2090: IOM, 08 December 2023
River floods are expected to affect up to 156 million people, with 87% of them projected to live in Asia
 
   
 
COMMENTARIES
Mixed reactions: COP28 focuses on fossil fuel role in climate change but disregards equity, says CSE, 14 December 2023
Inclusion of fossil fuels in Global Stocktake important starting point, rest a mixed bag
 
     
 
New GGA text slightly better, still no equity or finance target, 13 December 2023
A positive change from the previous text is that a timeframe of 2030 has been put into the text for achieving the thematic targets on water security, ecosystems restoration, health
 
   
  CLIMATE NEWS | SCIENCE| IMPACTS| POLITICS  
   
 
Down To Earth
Understanding climate effect on crop yield and associated risks to water security in India is crucial, 14 December 2023
Reassessing policy options requires a better understanding of climate impact on farm water management in India
 
   
 
Down To Earth
Think tanks, civil society caution that ‘fossil fuels’ mention in GST is riddled with loopholes, 14 December 2023
The latest text emphasises the need to transition away from fossil fuels in energy system
 
   
 
Down To Earth
‘Inaction of leaders led me to protest’: 12-year-old Manipuri activist shares her story after COP28 protest, 14 December 2023
Teachers and first-hand experience of facing weather extremes pushed the girl into activism
 
   
 
Down To Earth
No deal on global carbon market, bilateral carbon emissions trading agreements at COP28; civil society hails move, 13 December 2023
It would have put human rights, rights of Indigenous Peoples and ecosystem integrity at risk, say civil society members
 
   
 
Down To Earth
High time to recreate biogas development & training centres to sustain India’s compressed biogas sector, 13 December 2023
Despite significant government support, over 90% of operational CBG plants functioning below intended production capacity
 
   
 
Down To Earth
Fossil fuels’ death-knell sounded at COP28 held in oil-rich UAE; Al Jaber takes credit for keeping 1.5ºC target alive, 13 December 2023
Experts slam final text as weak, inadequate, with loopholes, and not in accordance with science; hail historical first entry of agenda in COP decision
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: Global Stocktake adopted, final text attempts stronger language on fossil fuels, 13 December 2023
Language calling out production of fossil fuels is now missing — a trade off for not making actions optional
 
   
 
Down To Earth
India opposed rapid coal phaseout part in GST text; demanded entire operative part on fossil fuel be modified, 12 December 2023
Target trillions, demanded an Indian negotiator; claimed support of most countries in opposing the text
 
   
 
Down To Earth
US being biggest oil & gas producer should provide finance package for energy transition at COP28: Civil society, 12 December 2023
US cannot call out other countries for not phasing out at the same time as them, say activists from developing countries
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: New Initiative to tackle debt & climate change launched by Kenya, Colombia, France, 12 December 2023
Countries announce coalition of experts to review linkages between debt, nature and climate change
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: African countries put their foot down on GGA on final day, 12 December 2023
A new text is expected to be out by 6 pm on December 12
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: ‘We’ve given you loss & damage fund, do not ask for more’ seems to be unspoken stand of developed countries, 12 December 2023
US and Saudi Arabia termed obstructionist; developed countries have plans for fossil fuel expansion till 2050
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: Additions and deletions make new GGA text a ‘scary’ one, 11 December 2023
This is a developed country tactic that has been used before. It was also used during the negotiations on the Loss and Damage Fund at COP27 last year
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: Fourth Draft of Global Stocktake Text accommodates too many divergent viewpoints, waters down ambition, 11 December 2023
There is a lack of clarity on thorny issues including fossil fuel phaseout and energy sector decarbonisation
 
   
 
Down To Earth
Tensions rise over negotiating text on global carbon market on COP28 penultimate day, 11 December 2023
Objections raised by several blocs over the wording of the text
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: New GST text urges global Net Zero by 2050 with cuts to fossil fuels; proposes rapid phasedown of coal, 11 December 2023
Experts term it a retrograde draft; presidency shifts onus on parties
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: New GGA text lacks teeth and money, 10 December 2023
The text was without strong language on means of implementation, especially adaptation finance gap and target and no resolution of the inclusion of the principle of CBDR-RC
 
   
 
Down To Earth
Controversial, flawed method enters UN carbon market draft text at COP28, 10 December 2023
Decisions on emission avoidance and conservation enhancement activities awaited
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: Article 6 negotiations see late night deliberations striving to find consensus, 10 December 2023
Parties also discussed the definition of cooperative approaches
 
   
 
Down To Earth
There’s rising need for global co-operation to decarbonise industries, 09 December 2023
The initiatives at COP28 send out a clear message for the need of international cooperation to achieve accelerated industrial decarbonisation
 
   
 
Down To Earth
Without adoption of a robust GGA, COP28 would fail: African negotiators, 09 December 2023
Adaptation a key priority for the continent, say AGN representatives; they expect COP28 to result in tangible outcomes which reflect Africa’s aspirations
 
   
 
Down To Earth
UNEP report at COP28 reveals $7 trillion invested globally every year on activities directly harming nature, 09 December 2023
Urgent need to reduce and re-direct finance flows to keep global temperatures below 1.5°C warming
 
   
 
Down To Earth
At COP28, India’s national statement has no direct reference to fossil fuel cuts, 09 December 2023
Indian environment minister showcased country’s achievements and showcased projects flagged by Prime Minister Modi
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: Discussions over fossil fuel phaseout heat up on the Third Draft of Global Stocktake text, 09 December 2023
A new text will be considered after informal consultancies with the Head of Delegations is complete
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: Developed countries owe $500 billion to developing ones under new climate finance goal, finds UNCTAD, 09 December 2023
Some $250 billion of the $500 billion owed should go to mitigation, $100 billion for adaptation and $150 billion for loss and damage
 
   
 
Down To Earth
Less than 8% of India’s coal power plants can control SO2 emissions, a new analysis finds, 09 December 2023
The thermal sector holds a predominant position within India’s overall installed capacity
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: India had fourth best ranking in climate performance among countries during 2022, says report, 08 December 2023
Preachers are not performing, underlined the report; US, UK sliding down in performance
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28: GGA talks stall, ministers take over, 08 December 2023
If the GGA is not adopted at COP28, it would mean that one of the mandated outcomes for the Dubai meet would not come to fruition
 
   
 
Down To Earth
COP28 side-event on carbon capture technologies in cement sector highlights key barriers and successes, 08 December 2023
Electricity demand, CO2 leakage risks to drinking water and high costs among key issues
 
   
   
 
Videos    
     
Down To Earth
 
Down To Earth
 
 
     
     
     
Down To Earth
 
Down To Earth
 
 
     
Simply Put:
COP28 ends
  Simply Put:
Head in the Dubai sand
     
Down To Earth
 
Down To Earth
 
     
This Weekly Newsletter is published by Down to Earth and the Centre for Science and Environment, a Delhi-based global think tank advocating on global south developmment issues.
We would love your feedback on this newsletter. To speak to our experts for quotes and comments on the above stories. Please email to vikas@cseindia.org
 
Follow us on
spacer facebook spacer Down to Earth video spacer twitter spacer
  If you like our work and would like others to join our climate network and the climate conversation, please forward this to your friends. Interested in Climate weekly? Sign Up here