Cse In News

Open Green Shift 2026: Mapping a Sustainable Future

Delhi’s own numbers tell a more com­plicated story than Kant’s global arithme­tic. Anumita Roychowdhury, Executive Director of CSE, told the panel ‘Can India Breathe Better?’ that the city’s pollution has actually fallen nearly 40 per cent over eight to nine years, which was a genuinely good thing. The catch is that the city still larger than just seasonal, and the toll on the health and wellbeing of Indians is im­mense. The problems are not singular, nor can they be fixed by simple changes either. Dr Anant Mohan, Head of Pulmonology at AIIMS, and environmentalist Sumaira Abdulali between them underscored just how varied the damage is, from lung disease to noise. The seasonality of Delhi’s pollution should not change how seriously people take it either, and for Mohan, an air purifier alone isn’t enough to fix the problem. He pushed back on the idea that a few clear-sky days mean the danger has passed. “A few better days doesn’t change the fact that exposure and its health effects are a contin­uous, ongoing process, not an occasional one,” he said. “You cannot stay indoors and air-purified all the time; over a day, whether exposure is one hour or 10, both intensity and duration of exposure matter.”

GSIDC organises conference on Goa’s architecture, sustainability

The Goa State Infrastructure Development Corporation (GSIDC) organised the National Conference on Goan Architecture & Sustainability at The Leela Palace in the national capital. The event brought together policymakers, renowned architects, urban planners, sustainability experts, industry leaders as well as international representatives to deliberate on the future of sustainable development and heritage-led growth, read a statement. The conference was inaugurated by Goa Chief Minister Dr Pramod Sawant, Union Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, Rajya Sabha MP Sadanand Shet Tanavade and distinguished guests from across India and abroad. The inaugural session featured ceremonial lamp lighting followed by keynote addresses highlighting Goa’s commitment to sustainable infrastructure and responsible urban development. “Goa’s architectural heritage is a living legacy that continues to shape our future. As we pursue rapid development, we remain committed to creating world-class, resilient and inclusive infrastructure rooted in sustainability, environmental responsibility and respect for our unique cultural identity. Our vision is to ensure that progress strengthens, rather than diminishes, the character that makes Goa truly distinctive,” Pramod Sawant said. He noted that the National Conference on Goan Architecture & Sustainability serves as a “valuable platform for architects, planners, policymakers and experts to exchange ideas and advance innovative, climate-resilient and heritage-sensitive solutions.” He added, “Through collaboration, green technologies and the conservation of our architectural legacy, we can ensure that development and preservation move forward together, building a prosperous and environmentally responsible Goa for generations to come.”History During the event, experts took part in four thematic panel discussions covering Goan Architecture & Contextual Design, Heritage Conservation & Sustainable Habitat, Energy Efficiency & Green Building Certification, and Climate-Smart Materials & Sustainable Construction Practices, the statement said. The sessions featured eminent speakers from leading institutions including TERI, Charles Correa Foundation, INTACH, GRIHA Council, World Bank, IFC, Centre for Science and Environment, Auroville Earth Institute, the European Union, the Royal Danish Embassy and the Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, among others. Encouraging meaningful dialogue on balancing rapid urbanisation with environmental responsibility, the event explored innovative technologies, policy interventions and collaborative approaches for resilient infrastructure development. Also, the event featured a dedicated exhibition that showcased GoVAN products, providing delegates with an opportunity to experience and appreciate products that reflect Goa’s local innovation, craftsmanship and entrepreneurial ecosystem.

GSIDC hosts conference on Goan architecture and sustainability

The Goa State Infrastructure Development Corporation (GSIDC) organised the National Conference on Goan Architecture & Sustainability at The Leela Palace, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi, bringing together policymakers, architects, urban planners, sustainability experts, industry leaders and international representatives to discuss sustainable infrastructure and heritage-led development. The conference was inaugurated by Dr Pramod Sawant, Chief Minister of Goa, alongside Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, Union Minister of Tourism & Culture, Government of India, Sadanand Shet Tanavade, Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha, and other dignitaries. The inaugural session included keynote addresses focusing on sustainable infrastructure and responsible urban development. Speaking at the conference, Dr Pramod Sawant said, “Goa's architectural heritage is a living legacy that continues to shape our future. As we pursue rapid development, we remain committed to creating world-class, resilient and inclusive infrastructure rooted in sustainability, environmental responsibility and respect for our unique cultural identity. Our vision is to ensure that progress strengthens, rather than diminishes, the character that makes Goa truly distinctive. The National Conference on Goan Architecture & Sustainability serves as a valuable platform for architects, planners, policymakers and experts to exchange ideas and advance innovative, climate-resilient and heritage-sensitive solutions. Through collaboration, green technologies and the conservation of our architectural legacy, we can ensure that development and preservation move forward together, building a prosperous and environmentally responsible Goa for generations to come.” The conference featured four panel discussions on Goan architecture and contextual design, heritage conservation and sustainable habitat, energy efficiency and green building certification, and climate-smart materials and sustainable construction practices. Speakers represented organisations including TERI, Charles Correa Foundation, INTACH, GRIHA Council, World Bank, IFC, Centre for Science and Environment, Auroville Earth Institute, the European Union, the Royal Danish Embassy and the Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands.

Goa showcases sustainable infra vision at national conference

The Goa State Infrastructure Development Corporation (GSIDC) organised the National Conference on Goan Architecture & Sustainability at The Leela Palace, Chanakyapuri, bringing together policymakers, architects, urban planners, sustainability experts, industry leaders & international representatives to discuss sustainable development and heritage-led growth. The conference was inaugurated by Goa Chief Minister Pramod Sawant, Union Tourism and Culture Minister Gajendra Singh Shekhawat, Rajya Sabha MP Sadanand Shet Tanavade and other dignitaries. Addressing the gathering, Sawant said Goa remains committed to building resilient, inclusive and sustainable infrastructure while preserving its rich architectural heritage. He said the conference provided a platform for experts to exchange ideas on climate-resilient, heritage-sensitive solutions & stressed the need to balance development with environmental responsibility and cultural identity. The event featured four panel discussions on Goan architecture & contextual design, heritage conservation, energy-efficient green buildings & climate-smart construction materials. Speakers represented organisations including TERI, the Charles Correa Foundation, INTACH, GRIHA Council, the World Bank, IFC, the Centre for Science & Environment, Auroville Earth Institute, the European Union, the Royal Danish Embassy and the Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands. An exhibition of GoVAN products highlighted Goa’s local innovation, craftsmanship & entrepreneurship. The conference concluded with a valedictory session outlining key recommendations, followed by a networking event for government officials, industry leaders, architects, researchers & policymakers. The conference reinforced Goa’s vision of becoming a leader in sustainable infrastructure, heritage conservation & climate-resilient urban development. Mpost

India’s carbon market sets weak emissions targets, analysis finds

“The initial targets, especially for steel, cement and aluminium are likely to remain limited to driving improvements through energy efficiency and other relatively low-cost operational measures,” explained Parth Kumar, Programme Manager at the Centre for Science and Environment, who was not involved in the CRH analysis. A critical evaluation of emissions reduction targets set under the country’s carbon market framework has deemed the targets “modest and unambitious” — unlikely to drive changes in operations that would reduce emissions substantially. Between October 2025 and January 2026 India notified greenhouse gas reduction targets for nine industries. Under the framework, industries can earn carbon credits if they surpass these reduction targets, with each credit signifying an additional tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent reduced per unit of production (emissions intensity). The industries covered include cement, aluminium, iron and steel, paper and pulp, chlor-alkali, petroleum refinery, petrochemical units, fertilisers, and textiles. The evaluation of the targets by Climate Risk Horizons (CRH), a research organisation, finds that in addition to the targets being “readily achievable,” over the two-year compliance period, the cost of non-compliance is too low to incentivise the kind of systematic operational changes needed to drastically reduce greenhouse gas emissions. India is the world’s third largest greenhouse gas emitter, with emissions from industrial processes and product use accounting for approximately 8% of greenhouse gas emissions. In August 2022, the Indian government pledged to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions intensity by 45% by 2030, compared to 2005 levels. It also pledged to reach net-zero emissions by 2070. According to the CRH analysis, the cost of purchasing credits for major companies in the steel, aluminium, and cement sectors is between 0.6% and 7% of profits, assuming credit prices are $10 per tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent, as indicated by S&P Global, which tracks global energy and commodities markets. “For many high-margin polluters, “paying to pollute” could become a preferred business strategy,” said Anirudh T.R., an author of the report, in a statement.

शहरों का बिगड़ता संतुलन: क्यों हर बारिश और हर गर्मी बन रही है आफत?

क्या आपने कभी सोचा है कि हमारे शहर हर साल एक ही कहानी क्यों दोहराते हैं? गर्मियों में यही शहर तंदूर की तरह तपने लगते हैं और मानसून आते ही कुछ घंटों की बारिश उन्हें तालाब में बदल देती है। सड़कें नदियों जैसी दिखने लगती हैं, गाड़ियां पानी में तैरती नजर आती हैं और पूरा जनजीवन ठहर जाता है। सवाल यह है कि क्या यह सिर्फ मौसम की मार है या फिर हमारी अपनी बनाई हुई शहरी विकास की गलत नीतियों का नतीजा? पिछले कुछ वर्षों में देश के अलग-अलग हिस्सों से आई तस्वीरों ने यह साफ कर दिया है कि शहर अब केवल जलवायु परिवर्तन के शिकार नहीं हैं, बल्कि गलत शहरी नियोजन के भी सबसे बड़े उदाहरण बन चुके हैं। मई और जून में जब तापमान 48 से 50 डिग्री सेल्सियस तक पहुंचता है, तब कंक्रीट और डामर से ढके शहर विशाल ‘हीट ट्रैप’ में बदल जाते हैं। वहीं मानसून की पहली तेज बारिश के साथ ही जलभराव, ट्रैफिक जाम और प्रशासनिक अव्यवस्था आम बात बन जाती है। हर साल प्रशासन जल निकासी, नालों की सफाई और बेहतर तैयारियों के दावे करता है, लेकिन पहली ही बारिश उन दावों की पोल खोल देती है। ऐसे में यह समझना जरूरी है कि समस्या केवल बदलते मौसम की नहीं, बल्कि उस विकास मॉडल की भी है, जिसमें प्रकृति के लिए जगह लगातार कम होती चली गई। शहरों के मास्टर प्लान में पर्यावरण और माइक्रो-क्लाइमेट की अनदेखी बड़ी भूल इस मुद्दे पर लंबे समय से काम कर रहीं सेंटर फॉर साइंस एंड एनवायरनमेंट (सीएसई) की कार्यकारी निदेशक डॉ. अनुमिता रॉयचौधरी भी लगातार चेतावनी देती रही हैं कि शहरों के मास्टर प्लान में पर्यावरण और स्थानीय सूक्ष्म जलवायु (माइक्रो-क्लाइमेट) की अनदेखी सबसे बड़ी भूल साबित हो रही है। उनके अनुसार जब प्राकृतिक जल निकायों और ड्रेनेज नेटवर्क को खत्म कर दिया जाता है, तो शहर बारिश का पानी सोखने की अपनी प्राकृतिक क्षमता खो देते हैं। यही वजह है कि सामान्य बारिश भी कई बार शहरी बाढ़ का रूप ले लेती है। शहरी विशेषज्ञों के अनुसार शहरों में तेजी से बढ़ रहा ‘अर्बन हीट आइलैंड सिंड्रोम’ इस संकट का सबसे बड़ा कारण है। जब किसी शहर का तापमान आसपास के ग्रामीण इलाकों से तीन से छह डिग्री सेल्सियस अधिक हो जाता है, तो इसका मतलब है कि शहर अपनी प्राकृतिक ठंडक खो चुका है।

फीकल स्लज एवं सेप्टेज प्रबंधन पर संभाग स्तरीय प्रशिक्षण

सेंटर फॉर साइंस एंड एनवायरनमेंट और स्वच्छ भारत मिशन (शहरी) स्थानीय निकाय निदेशालय के संयुक्त तत्वावधान में बीकानेर नगर निगम सभागार में फीकल स्लज एवं सेप्टेज मैनेजमेंट पर एक दिवसीय संभाग स्तरीय प्रशिक्षण कार्यक्रम आयोजित...

Why Delhi had its most polluted July in 6 yrs

New Delhi: Despite Delhi recording a rare ‘good’ air quality day two weeks ago, this month has been the most polluted July in six years. The average air quality index (AQI) this July was 119. A higher average July AQI was recorded only thrice since Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) started calculating AQI in 2015: 2019 (134), 2016 (138) and 2015 (146). Though the city experienced two days of heavy rainfall this July, a prolonged dry spell for the rest of the month led to elevated pollution levels, experts said. An analysis of CPCB data shows this July had two consecutive ‘poor’ air days, 15 ‘moderate’ days and 12 ‘satisfactory’ days. In contrast, July 2025 witnessed 29 ‘satisfactory’ days and two ‘moderate’ days. The city recorded the lone ‘good’ air day with an AQI of just 48 this July 9 when heavy rain settled down pollutants. However, a dry spell from July 11 to 19 led to a rise in pollution. There were two ‘poor’ air days on July 12 (261) and July 13 (246) when dust from Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan worsened Delhi’s air quality. Sunil Dahiya, founder of think tank Envirocatalyst, said the fewer number of rainy days meant a reduction in washing down of pollutants. Hence, the PM2.5 levels remained in the same range as in past years. “However, PM10 levels were much higher compared to the last few years, highlighting the impact of dry dust resuspension in the city,” he said. Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director, research and advocacy, Centre for Science and Environment, said, “There is an interplay between monsoon and Delhi’s air quality. While heavy rains cleanse the air dramatically, high humidity coupled with dry breaks causes pollutants to linger and resuspend, keeping the air quality elevated in the ‘moderate’ to ‘poor’ ranges on non-rainy days.“ “While the emission load from transport has dropped over the past years due to the introduction of BS VI-compliant vehicles and tighter regulations on industries in Delhi-NCR, the result of other sources like power plants and new industrial units stepping up their operations has reduced the gains Delhi needs to make in its air quality,” said Dahiya. Aggressive action on emission load reduction at source within the city as well as in the larger airshed is the only solution, he said, adding, “The fact that even monsoons aren’t able to wash down its pollution levels is an urgent alarm for us to start acting fast.” Meanwhile, the mean maximum and minimum temperatures this July were higher than last year. The first was recorded at 35.4 degrees Celsius compared with 34.5°C in July 2025. The mean minimum stood at 27.7°C, up from 26.1°C last July.

Andaman Builds Master Trainers to Improve Solid and Plastic Waste Management Across Islands

Strengthening waste management systems across the Andaman and Nicobar Islands took centre stage on Monday as the Andaman and Nicobar Pollution Control Committee (ANPCC) launched a two-day Union Territory-level capacity-building programme designed to create a network of Master Trainers for the effective implementation of solid and plastic waste management regulations. The initiative seeks to enhance institutional and technical capabilities while supporting coordinated implementation of waste management rules across the islands. The workshop, titled UT-Level Master Trainer Capacity Building Workshop on Operationalising Solid Waste Management and Plastic Waste Management, was inaugurated at the Training Hall of the Directorate of Disaster Management in Sri Vijaya Puram. It is being organised by the ANPCC under the Department of Science and Technology, Andaman and Nicobar Administration, in association with the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), New Delhi. The programme is being conducted under Phase II of the India–Norway Marine Pollution Initiative (INMPI) of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC), Government of India. According to the organisers, the workshop aims to strengthen institutional and technical capacities for the effective implementation of the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2026, and the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016, as amended.

अंडमान ने ठोस और प्लास्टिक अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन को मजबूत करने के लिए केंद्र शासित प्रदेश स्तर पर अभियान शुरू किया

श्री विजयपुरम, 28 जुलाई: अंडमान और निकोबार प्रशासन ने ठोस और प्लास्टिक अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन नियमों के कार्यान्वयन को मजबूत करने के लिए केंद्र शासित प्रदेश स्तर पर क्षमता निर्माण पहल शुरू की है। इस पहल के तहत द्वीपों में अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन के लिए जिम्मेदार अधिकारियों और प्रमुख हितधारकों को प्रशिक्षण दिया जाएगा। श्री विजयपुरम में 28 जुलाई से शुरू होने वाली दो दिवसीय कार्यशाला का उद्देश्य संस्थागत क्षमता का निर्माण करना और केंद्र शासित प्रदेश में टिकाऊ अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन प्रथाओं को बढ़ावा देना है। विज्ञान एवं प्रौद्योगिकी विभाग के अंतर्गत अंडमान एवं निकोबार प्रदूषण नियंत्रण समिति (एएनपीसीसी) 28 और 29 जुलाई को ठोस अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन और प्लास्टिक अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन को क्रियान्वित करने पर केंद्र शासित प्रदेश स्तरीय मास्टर ट्रेनर क्षमता निर्माण कार्यशाला-सह-हैंडहोल्डिंग अभ्यास का आयोजन कर रही है। यह कार्यक्रम विज्ञान एवं पर्यावरण केंद्र (सीएसई), नई दिल्ली के सहयोग से श्री विजयपुरम स्थित आपदा प्रबंधन निदेशालय के प्रशिक्षण हॉल में आयोजित किया जा रहा है। यह कार्यशाला भारत सरकार के पर्यावरण, वन और जलवायु परिवर्तन मंत्रालय (MoEF&CC) की भारत-नॉर्वे समुद्री प्रदूषण पहल (INMPI) के द्वितीय चरण के अंतर्गत आयोजित की जा रही है। आयोजकों के अनुसार, इस पहल का उद्देश्य ठोस अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन नियम, 2026 और प्लास्टिक अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन नियम, 2016 (संशोधित) के प्रभावी कार्यान्वयन के लिए संस्थागत क्षमताओं को सुदृढ़ करना है।

El Niño, Climate Change And India's Monsoon | Why 2026 Matters | Sunita Narain Show

India's monsoon is the country's true pierce brosnan finance minister. It determines food production, water availability, livelihoods and economic growth. north korea In 2026, India faces the combined challenge of a strong El Niño and a warming climate, raising concerns about below average rainfall and increasing weather extremes. As weather systems become more volatile, the need to value every drop of rain and strengthen rainwater harvesting has never been greater. Understanding the monsoon is essential to understanding India's future. Join this channel to get access to perks: Down to Earth is Science and Environment fortnightly published by the Society for Environmental Communication, New Delhi. We ian watkins publish news and analysis on issues that deal with sustainable development, which we scan through the eyes of science and environment.

India should stop adding solar farms. Now

India should stop adding solar farms. Now On 20 July, people in Haryana woke up to yet another “monsoon” day stripped of the scent of fresh rain. Instead, they were subjected to scorching heat and soaring mercury. Angry locals took to the streets in five districts, protesting the ensuing power cuts.  Interestingly, Haryana’s energy shortages have historically been close to zero, and its power-distribution companies are the healthiest in the country.  India’s installed power-generation capacity has also been moving at a clip, largely due to rising solar-power generation. Over the last decade, installed solar-power capacity has jumped 58X to touch 162 GW, as the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy told the... Read more at https://the-ken.com/story/india-should-stop-adding-solar-farms-now/

UT-Level Workshop on Solid and Plastic Waste Management Begins in Sri Vijaya Puram

The Andaman & Nicobar Pollution Control Committee (ANPCC), under the Department of Science & Technology, Andaman & Nicobar Administration, in collaboration with the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), New Delhi, is organising a two-day UT-Level Master Trainer Capacity Building Workshop-cum-Handholding Exercise on Operationalizing Solid Waste Management and Plastic Waste Management on July 28 and 29 at the Training Hall of the Directorate of Disaster Management, Sri Vijaya Puram.

IIT Roorkee trains polytechnic students in wastewater reuse

Twenty-two final-year diploma engineering students from government polytechnics across Uttarakhand underwent a two-day hands-on training programme at IIT Roorkee on sustainable wastewater treatment and reuse. They learnt how treated wastewater can be safely used for irrigation, toilet flushing and industrial applications to reduce pressure on freshwater resources. The participants, pursuing civil and environmental engineering courses at government polytechnics in rural and remote parts of the state, attended the programme organised by IIT Roorkee's Department of Civil Engineering under NTPC's Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) initiative, in collaboration with NAMTECH, Ahmedabad. During the training, the students visited the institute's sewage treatment plant (STP), where they saw treated wastewater being reused for horticulture and toilet flushing across the campus. They also learnt to analyse water quality by testing pH, turbidity, biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), chemical oxygen demand (COD) and faecal coliforms. They also gained an understanding of how technologies such as ultrafiltration and reverse osmosis produce reclaimed water suitable for reuse. The initiative comes at a time when water recycling is emerging as a key solution to India's growing water crisis. According to a recent Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) report, only about 28% of the country's urban wastewater is treated, while the rest flows into rivers and lakes. Experts say expanding wastewater recycling could significantly reduce the demand for freshwater. Prof Absar Ahmed Kazmi, convenor of the programme, said: "Globally, around 42% of domestic wastewater was still not safely treated in 2022, highlighting the urgent need for better treatment and reuse technologies." IIT Roorkee Director Prof KK Pant interacted with the participants during the field visit and stressed the importance of practical learning and innovation in addressing future water and environmental challenges. "This initiative aims to bridge the gap between classroom learning and real-world engineering while promoting a circular water economy," he said. Kartikey Nautiyal, a third-year student at Government Polytechnic, Narendra Nagar, said the training gave participants exposure to technologies and practical applications they may not have experienced at their institutions. "Such programmes should ideally last five to seven days so that students get more indepth classroom learning as well as greater laboratory exposure," he said.

ANPCC in Collaboration with CSE, New Delhi to Organise UT-Level Master Trainer Capacity Building Workshop-cum-Handholding Exercise

The Andaman & Nicobar Pollution Control Committee (ANPCC), Department of Science & Technology, Andaman & Nicobar Administration, in collaboration with the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), New Delhi, is organising a UT-Level Master Trainer Capacity Building Workshop-cum-Handholding Exercise on Operationalizing Solid Waste Management and Plastic Waste Management on 28th and 29th July, 2026 at the Training Hall, Directorate of Disaster Management, Sri Vijaya Puram. The workshop is being conducted under the India-Norway Marine Pollution Initiative (INMPI) Phase-II of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC), Government of India, with the objective of strengthening institutional capacities for the effective implementation of the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2026 and the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016 (as amended). The 2-day programme will bring together officials from Government Departments, Urban and Rural Local Bodies, waste management agencies, bulk waste generators, Self-Help Groups, Non-Governmental Organisations, and other key stakeholders. Technical experts from MoEF&CC’s partnered institution like the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), New Delhi and ANPCC will conduct interactive sessions on source segregation, waste quantification and characterisation, Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs), Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR), plastic waste management, Bulk Waste Generator compliances and other best practices for sustainable waste management in the Island ecosystem. ANPCC has extended invitations to concerned Government Departments and stakeholders to participate actively in the programme, which aims to develop a pool of Master Trainers capable of promoting effective implementation of waste management rules across the Union Territory. The initiative reflects the Administration’s commitment to environmental protection, sustainable waste management, and a cleaner and healthier A&N Island.

Renewable energy expansion, battery storage push key to green transition: Pralhad Joshi

Offering a broader climate perspective, Centre for Science and Environment Director General Sunita Narain said that "there is one extreme weather event a day happening across India," arguing that climate action must go beyond emission reduction to include resilient cities, stronger local environmental governance and sustainable development. Renewable energy minister Pralhad Joshi said India's drive in battery storage systems, along with rapid expansion of wind and solar power would play a key role in pushing the country's clean energy transition. Addressing the Adani Presents Times Network Sustainability Conclave 2026, Joshi said the push towards battery storage, coupled with a strong focus on wind and solar energy, would bring down electricity costs.