Cse In News

Climate Colonialism: How the Global South Pays for the North’s Pollution

Sunita Narain, a leading environmentalist from India, in a C2G Talk interview, articulated that climate change is a great equalizer and we have to work together. Floods in Pakistan, heat waves in India, and rising sea levels swallowing Pacific islands are not just natural disasters; they are consequences of a global climate crisis based on centuries of exploitation. The Global North profited from industrialization, but the Global South pays the price. The Global North comprises the world’s wealthier, industrialized countries, predominantly located in North America and Western Europe. The Global South encompasses the developing countries situated throughout Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Pacific Islands. Although these terms are not strictly geographic, they point to significant economic and political inequalities. Climate colonialism has indeed occurred. It is high time that we start discussing the environmental weaponization in geopolitical conflicts because the climate crisis isn't just environmental anymore; it has become political and more. What is Climate Colonialism? Climate colonialism, a term coined by activists and scholars, refers to the way former colonial powers continue to impose environmental and economic burdens on the Global South. It’s not just about emissions. It’s about who suffers, who profits, and who gets to decide what happens next. The Carbon Brief reports that the U.S. accounts for more than 20% of all carbon emissions up until 1850. The European Union adds another 17% to that total. Most at-risk countries from climate change like Bangladesh, Mozambique, and the Philippines have each contributed less than 1% of the total emissions. The Global North's industrialization was based on resource extraction from colonized territories: coal from India, rubber from the Congo, and oil from the Middle East. These raw materials fueled Western development while leaving the colonies impoverished and with polluted environments. Now, as the climate crisis deepens, formerly colonized nations are being told to cut their emissions, usually without financial or technological support to do so. Sunita Narain, a leading environmentalist from India, in a C2G Talk interview, articulated that climate change is a great equalizer and we have to work together. This is one issue on which the rich cannot bully the poor, and it is also one issue on which the poor cannot not cooperate; so we need both sides. She further added, 'If I look at the costs of why nature-based solutions are becoming so prominent in the mitigation options and in net zero, it is because everybody thinks that there is a huge amount of land available in countries of the developing world, whether it is Africa or India, where you can plant trees at negative cost or at minimal cost. You look at the ranges coming out of Europe which say it is going to be so expensive to plant trees there, but you can do that in Africa. But that African land belongs to somebody, it belongs to some community that needs to get livelihood security from the use of that land. They need to benefit from it. So I think, we are not putting our money where our mouth is.'

Meet The Man Who Quit His Job to Clean the Yamuna River

The scale of the challenge is staggering. In Delhi alone, just two percent of the Yamuna’s stretch accounts for 80 percent of its pollution, largely due to heavily contaminated drains like Najafgarh and Shahdara, according to the Centre for Science and Environment. Every Sunday morning, as the city slows down for the weekend, Pankaj Kumar and his team head to the banks of the Yamuna River at Kalindi Kunj Ghat in Delhi. Gloves on, driven by quiet resolve, they begin their weekly ritual — removing heaps of waste, plastic, and debris from one of India’s most polluted rivers. But for them, this isn’t just about cleaning up garbage — it’s about reviving a dying river. A former corporate professional, Pankaj made a bold choice: he quit his job to dedicate himself full-time to cleaning India’s rivers. He founded ‘Earth Warriors’, a volunteer-driven initiative that not only leads clean-up drives but also investigates the systems responsible for river pollution. What fuels their commitment? The numbers speak for themselves. India generates an estimated 73 billion litres of sewage every day — yet only 28 percent of it is treated. The rest flows untreated into rivers like the Yamuna, polluting the very water bodies that sustain our cities and communities. Realising that clean-ups alone wouldn’t solve the crisis, Earth Warriors expanded their mission. They began inspecting sewage treatment plants across 12 states, filing legal complaints, and pushing civic bodies for accountability. They believe in prevention before cure — highlighting the urgent need to fix broken systems that allow untreated waste to choke our rivers. The scale of the challenge is staggering. In Delhi alone, just two percent of the Yamuna’s stretch accounts for 80 percent of its pollution, largely due to heavily contaminated drains like Najafgarh and Shahdara, according to the Centre for Science and Environment. In cities like Gurugram, unchecked industrial waste from dyeing and chemical units continues to pour into water bodies. Even existing sewage treatment plants often fail to meet basic safety standards.

North Chennai residents fight against proposed waste plant in Kodungaiyur

A report by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) in 2018 said that the calorific value of waste in Indian cities ranges from 1,411 kcal/kg to 2,150 kcal/kg, with high moisture content. In contrast, countries such as Sweden, Norway, Germany and the United States have waste with calorific values ranging between 1,900 kcal/kg and 3,800 kcal/kg. Tension is simmering in North Chennai, as the Greater Chennai Corporation refuses to budge on its proposed Waste to Energy plant in Kodungaiyur despite stiff opposition from the residents. This is the first time coordinated protests have taken place against the project, with 8,000 people hitting the streets. The Federation of North Chennai Residents Welfare Association (FNCRWA) has been formed in the backdrop of opposing this project. The residents staged a human chain protest on May 25 against the Greater Chennai Corporation’s (GCC) proposal to build a waste-to-energy plant in Kodungaiyur, a residential area and wetland. The 4.5 km human chain, which stretched from Ezhil Nagar to the Dr Ambedkar Arts College, was organised by civil society organisations, including FNCRWA, Vyasai Thozhargal, Chennai Climate Action Group, and others. The protest also featured GCC councillors from political parties, including the Communist Party of India, Communist Party of India (Marxist), Marumalarchi Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, Congress, and Viduthalai Chiruthaigal Katchi. Prominent citizens such as S Janakarajan, the president of the South Asia Consortium for Interdisciplinary Water Resources Studies, Carnatic musician and activist TM Krishna and others also took part in the protest. The protesters signed a declaration calling on the government to uphold Article 21 of the Constitution (right to life), citing a threat to public health due to toxins, dioxins, and furans that burning waste at the dumpyard will release. Around 352 acres of land is currently being used for dumping waste in Kodungaiyur. The GCC has proposed a waste-to-energy (WTE) plant here, which will burn a total of 2,100 tonnes of waste and produce 300 MT of fly ash, according to the corporation. However, Chythenyen DK, a researcher on WTE incineration projects, told TNM that the facility would generate an estimated 500-800 MT of ash. The release of toxic gases from the plant is another significant concern for the protestors. “The next generation is growing up with breathing issues, skin disease, and heart issues. My father suffers from asthma. At least the next generation should be protected,” said M Selvi, a resident of Kannadasan Nagar in Kodungaiyur. Even though segregation of waste at the source is a mandatory practice as per GCC’s 2019 Solid Waste Management By-Laws and the Solid Waste Management Rules of 2016, the practice is often lax in the city. Over 7,600 tonnes of garbage is produced every day within GCC limits, of which the Kodungaiyur and Perungudi dumpyards see more than 5,300 tonnes. The waste in these yards is a mixture of household, medical, and construction waste. Currently, the project is in its initial stages. The contract for the project has not been awarded yet, but two bidders – Delhi MSW Solutions and Brij Gopal Construction Co. Private Limited – have expressed interest. According to Chythenyen, the lowest bidder has been identified as Delhi MSW Solutions, a subsidiary company of Ramky Enviro Engineers Limited. The company’s WTE plant in Narela had been fined by the Delhi PCB for excess cancer-causing dioxins and other chemical components. Similarly, Chythenyen says a report filed by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) to the National Green Tribunal (NGT) on April 15, 2024, flags violations in the WTE plant set up by Ramky in the Jawahar Nagar dumping yard in Hyderabad. In fact, in 2021, three of the four WTE plants in Delhi had been fined for gross violation of emission norms. There are also questions of practicality in the setting up of the plant. Waste must have a high calorific value and little moisture for it to be suitable for WTE processing. A report by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) in 2018 said that the calorific value of waste in Indian cities ranges from 1,411 kcal/kg to 2,150 kcal/kg, with high moisture content. In contrast, countries such as Sweden, Norway, Germany and the United States have waste with calorific values ranging between 1,900 kcal/kg and 3,800 kcal/kg. An article in the India Development Report (IDR) titled “Waste to energy: Smokescreen or solution?” stated that bottom ash produced as a by-product of the burning could be as high as 30-40% of the total feed of waste burnt. Questions persist regarding the means of disposal of this by-product, as bottom ash often ends up in dump sites, polluting groundwater and soil. Organisations on the ground are well aware of this and have raised the slogan “Kodungaiyur kuppamedum vendam, engale kollum erivilayum vendam.” (We don't want the Kodungaiyur dumpyard or the incinerator.) Why are companies still opening these plants despite such operational difficulties? The IDR report pointed to profit as the main reason. The report said that there are “substantial tipping fees” paid by governments to contractors based on the weight of the waste handled. This means that the companies also prioritise unsegregated waste, which is heavier than segregated waste. “For example, in Indore, the tipping fee is Rs 1,080 per tonne, while in Delhi it is Rs 2,000–2,700. Consider a scenario where a city provides nearly 6,000 tonnes of waste to three private parties daily. Even at Rs 2,000 per tonne per day, this amounts to approximately Rs 1.2 crore. This could be why Delhi, for example, operates four WTE plants, burning close to 5,600 tonnes of waste a day, when only 1,100 tonnes are fit for incineration,” the report observed. An unsegregated waste dump such as Kodungaiyur could well turn out to be lucrative for the contracting companies if the plan goes through. The question of Kodungaiyur is further complicated by its location in a marshland and the waste already dumped there. Sarath, founder of Vyasai Thozhargal, one of the organisations heading the protest, says that the dumpsite was a marshland that lost its characteristics due to 40 years of constant waste dumping. The Captain Cotton Canal, Buckingham Canal, and Otteri Nullah all flow through the region. These water bodies, which join the sea near Ennore, take rainwater away from the city during floods. During high tides, when the sea pushes back, the wetlands take in the water and replenish the groundwater. Therefore, dealing with the dumpyard is a necessity if Chennai is to deal with its flooding problems. “The government is asking us to deal with a ghost by bringing in a bigger demon,” said Sarath. Kodungaiyur is an area with a high flooding probability, and the plan to set up the WTE plant goes against the GCC’s Climate Action Plan directive that waste management facilities are to be set up in low flooding areas. A climate action plan report by the Poovulagin Nanmargal, an environmental civil society organisation, stated that land surface temperatures are the second highest at the waste disposal sites at the Perungudi and Kodungaiyur dump yards after the Chennai airport.

India, a major user of coal power, is making large gains in clean energy adoption. Here is how

The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India's electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. One of the most carbon-polluting countries, India is also making huge efforts to harness the power of the sun, wind and other clean energy sources. Most of the electricity in India, the world's most populous nation, still comes from coal, one of the dirtiest forms of energy. But coal's dominance is dropping, going from 60% of installed power capacity 11 years ago to less than 50% today, according to India's power ministry. At the same time, India had its largest ever addition of clean power in the fiscal year between April 2024 and April of this year, adding 30 gigawatts—enough to power nearly 18 million Indian homes. With a growing middle class and skyrocketing energy needs, how fast India can move away from coal and other fossil fuels, such as gasoline and oil, could have a large impact on global efforts to confront climate change. Here is a snapshot of India's clean energy transition and some of the challenges. Renewable energy is now the most economical option Solar is now half the cost of power from new coal-powered plants. Availability of cheap components and many sunny days each year in India are some reasons experts say installed solar power increased 30 times in the last decade. "Solar power is the cheapest it's ever been," said Ruchita Shah, an energy analyst at climate think-tank Ember. Shah added that dropping costs for energy storage, in the form of batteries, means that renewable power will be the "new normal," even when the sun doesn't shine or the wind doesn't blow. India has nearly 170 gigawatts of renewable energy projects in the pipeline, which are expected to be completed in the next few years. "I have no doubt that India will reach its target of 500 gigawatts by 2030," said Raghav Pachouri, an energy expert at Vasudha Foundation, a New Delhi-based think-tank. Government policies and private investments push renewables Experts say the growth in renewables is being spurred by India's plans to add approximately 50 gigawatts of non-fossil fuel power capacity every year for the next five years and for clean power to provide 50% of the nation's energy by the decade. When burned, fossil fuels let off greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, the main driver of climate change. A 2022 law that made electricity cheaper for companies choosing to buy clean power, the federal government's recommendation that state utilities buy more renewable power and a 2023 government plan to invest $452 million have all catalyzed investments in renewables. India has the fourth highest amount of clean power installed in the world and government officials said $81 billion has been invested in the renewable energy sector in the last decade. Multiple large-scale renewable power projects have begun operations or are under construction, including one of the world's largest wind and solar power farms. "We've seen domestic manufacturing capacity, at least when it comes to modules for solar panels, increasing," said Madhura Joshi, a senior energy analyst at the European think-tank E3G. Still, renewables are underutilized Despite the rapid growth, challenges persist. While non-fossil fuel sources now comprise 45% of India's total installed capacity, their share in actual electricity generation stood at 24% last year. Coal remains the dominant source, accounting for 75% of electricity generation. The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India's electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. Installed capacity is growing, but power generation from renewables needs to be optimized and integrated effectively into the grid, the report found. At a clean energy crossroads A recent report by the nonprofit clean energy think-tank, RMI, found that electricity demand is expected to triple by 2050—driven by more electric vehicles, air conditioners and industrial growth. Acquiring land for clean energy projects remains a challenge. India also needs to rapidly build robust electricity transmission infrastructure and energy storage facilities to continue increasing clean power capacity. "India is expected to become the world's third-largest economy in a few years, and I think we will need to adopt renewable energy to do this. There is no option for us because fossil fuels can't keep pace" with energy needs, said Deepak Thakur, chief executive officer of Mumbai-based renewable energy company, Mahindra Susten.

India, a major user of coal power, is making large gains in clean energy adoption. Here is how

The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India’s electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. One of the most carbon-polluting countries, India is also making huge efforts to harness the power of the sun, wind and other clean energy sources. Most of the electricity in India, the world’s most populous nation, still comes from coal, one of the dirtiest forms of energy. But coal’s dominance is dropping, going from 60% of installed power capacity 11 years ago to less than 50% today, according to India’s power ministry. At the same time, India had its largest ever addition of clean power in the fiscal year between April 2024 and April of this year, adding 30 gigawatts — enough to power nearly 18 million Indian homes. With a growing middle class and skyrocketing energy needs, how fast India can move away from coal and other fossil fuels, such as gasoline and oil, could have a large impact on global efforts to confront climate change. Here is a snapshot of India’s clean energy transition and some of the challenges. Renewable energy is now the most economical option Employees work on a wind turbine blade at the Adani New Industries Limited in the port town of Mundra in Western India’s Gujarat state, India, Sept. 20, 2023. (AP Photo/Rafiq Maqbool, File) Solar is now half the cost of power from new coal-powered plants. Availability of cheap components and many sunny days each year in India are some reasons experts say installed solar power increased 30 times in the last decade. “Solar power is the cheapest it’s ever been,” said Ruchita Shah, an energy analyst at climate think-tank Ember. Shah added that dropping costs for energy storage, in the form of batteries, means that renewable power will be the “new normal,” even when the sun doesn’t shine or the wind doesn’t blow. Stay up to date with similar stories by signing up to our WhatsApp channel. India has nearly 170 gigawatts of renewable energy projects in the pipeline, which are expected to be completed in the next few years. “I have no doubt that India will reach its target of 500 gigawatts by 2030,” said Raghav Pachouri, an energy expert at Vasudha Foundation, a New Delhi-based think-tank. Government policies and private investments push renewables A car gets charged at an electric vehicle charging station at a residential building parking area in Mumbai, India, July 23, 2024. (AP Photo/Rajanish Kakade, File) Experts say the growth in renewables is being spurred by India’s plans to add approximately 50 gigawatts of non-fossil fuel power capacity every year for the next five years and for clean power to provide 50% of the nation’s energy by the decade. When burned, fossil fuels let off greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, the main driver of climate change. A 2022 law that made electricity cheaper for companies choosing to buy clean power, the federal government’s recommendation that state utilities buy more renewable power and a 2023 government plan to invest $452 million have all catalyzed investments in renewables. India has the fourth highest amount of clean power installed in the world and government officials said $81 billion has been invested in the renewable energy sector in the last decade. Multiple large-scale renewable power projects have begun operations or are under construction, including one of the world’s largest wind and solar power farms. “We’ve seen domestic manufacturing capacity, at least when it comes to modules for solar panels, increasing,” said Madhura Joshi, a senior energy analyst at the European think-tank E3G. Still, renewables are underutilized Workers of Solar Square carry a panel on the rooftop of a residence in Gurugram on the outskirts of New Delhi, India, Feb. 20, 2024. (AP Photo/Manish Swarup, File) Despite the rapid growth, challenges persist. While non-fossil fuel sources now comprise 45% of India’s total installed capacity, their share in actual electricity generation stood at 24% last year. Coal remains the dominant source, accounting for 75% of electricity generation. The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India’s electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. Installed capacity is growing, but power generation from renewables needs to be optimized and integrated effectively into the grid, the report found. At a clean energy crossroads A recent report by the nonprofit clean energy think-tank, RMI, found that electricity demand is expected to triple by 2050 — driven by more electric vehicles, air conditioners and industrial growth. Acquiring land for clean energy projects remains a challenge. India also needs to rapidly build robust electricity transmission infrastructure and energy storage facilities to continue increasing clean power capacity. “India is expected to become the world’s third-largest economy in a few years, and I think we will need to adopt renewable energy to do this. There is no option for us because fossil fuels can’t keep pace” with energy needs, said Deepak Thakur, chief executive officer of Mumbai-based renewable energy company, Mahindra Susten.

India, a major user of coal power, is making large gains in clean energy adoption. Here is how

The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India’s electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. One of the most carbon-polluting countries, India is also making huge efforts to harness the power of the sun, wind and other clean energy sources. Most of the electricity in India, the world’s most populous nation, still comes from coal, one of the dirtiest forms of energy. But coal’s dominance is dropping, going from 60% of installed power capacity 11 years ago to less than 50% today, according to India’s power ministry. At the same time, India had its largest ever addition of clean power in the fiscal year between April 2024 and April of this year, adding 30 gigawatts — enough to power nearly 18 million Indian homes. With a growing middle class and skyrocketing energy needs, how fast India can move away from coal and other fossil fuels, such as gasoline and oil, could have a large impact on global efforts to confront climate change. Here is a snapshot of India’s clean energy transition and some of the challenges. Solar power is the cheapest it’s ever been,” said Ruchita Shah, an energy analyst at climate think-tank Ember. Shah added that dropping costs for energy storage, in the form of batteries, means that renewable power will be the “new normal,” even when the sun doesn’t shine or the wind doesn’t blow. India has nearly 170 gigawatts of renewable energy projects in the pipeline, which are expected to be completed in the next few years. “I have no doubt that India will reach its target of 500 gigawatts by 2030,” said Raghav Pachouri, an energy expert at Vasudha Foundation, a New Delhi-based think-tank. Experts say the growth in renewables is being spurred by India’s plans to add approximately 50 gigawatts of non-fossil fuel power capacity every year for the next five years and for clean power to provide 50% of the nation’s energy by the decade. When burned, fossil fuels let off greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, the main driver of climate change. A 2022 law that made electricity cheaper for companies choosing to buy clean power, the federal government’s recommendation that state utilities buy more renewable power and a 2023 government plan to invest $452 million have all catalyzed investments in renewables. India has the fourth highest amount of clean power installed in the world and government officials said $81 billion has been invested in the renewable energy sector in the last decade. Multiple large-scale renewable power projects have begun operations or are under construction, including one of the world’s largest wind and solar power farms. “We’ve seen domestic manufacturing capacity, at least when it comes to modules for solar panels, increasing,” said Madhura Joshi, a senior energy analyst at the European think-tank E3G. The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India’s electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment.

India, a major user of coal power, is making large gains in clean energy adoption. Here is how

India — One of the most carbon-polluting countries, India is also making huge efforts to harness the power of the sun, wind and other clean energy sources. Most of the electricity in India, the world’s most populous nation, still comes from coal , one of the dirtiest forms of energy. But coal’s dominance is dropping, going from 60% of installed power capacity 11 years ago to less than 50% today, according to India’s power ministry.

India, a major user of coal power, is making large gains in clean energy adoption. Here is how

The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India's electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. One of the most carbon-polluting countries, India is also making huge efforts to harness the power of the sun, wind and other clean energy sources. Most of the electricity in India, the world's most populous nation, still comes from coal, one of the dirtiest forms of energy. But coal's dominance is dropping, going from 60% of installed power capacity 11 years ago to less than 50% today, according to India's power ministry.

62% cut in PM2.5 needed to meet national standards

Delhi requires another 62% cut in PM2.5 levels to meet the national clean air standards, reveals a new report by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) released on Thursday. The air quality trend since 2018, when most of the monitoring stations were set up, shows that the average annual PM2.5 levels (based on 38 stations) show a 10% increase since 2018 overall. However, after the pandemic year of 2020–21, the levels increased, stayed elevated, and the curve turned upward in 2023–24. "The maximum values in 2024 were the highest in the past few years. Delhi requires as much as a 62% reduction in its annual PM2.5 average level to meet the national ambient air quality standard," the report says. Anumita Roychowdhury, CSE's executive director, said: "What is needed here is more aggressive upscaling of mobility strategies, zero-emission vehicle transition, robust waste management, action on unregulated industry and the use of solid fuels in households, and regional airshed level interventions." The report highlighted that though Delhi has a large number of air quality monitoring stations, these are not well distributed to cover the population in all land uses, and there are still some "shadow zones" with low station density. "Currently, the monitoring stations in Delhi are mainly centred in and around the southern and central parts of Delhi. The southwest and northwest peripheries have minimal monitoring stations, leading to gaps in air quality monitoring. The stretch between Mundka, Bawana and Narela should have more monitoring stations as these are the areas that record some of the highest PM2.5 levels," the report said. CSE, which analysed the data of the Decision Support System (DSS), which is the dynamic forecasting of IITM, identified the top concerns among local sources as vehicles, industries in Delhi and its periphery, construction, waste burning and residential fuel. "Post crop burning season, the share of crop fire is less than 1%, the share of NCR and other districts is 64%, and the contribution of local pollution sources in Delhi increases further to 36.54%. At 30%, the contribution of local sources is significant, especially when it is considered that the city needs to reduce PM2.5 levels by 62% from a very high annual level of 105 micrograms per cubic metre," the report said. CSE said that between 2019–20 and 2024–25 financial years, Delhi received Rs 42.69 crore under the NCAP programme of the ministry of environment, forests and climate change (MoEFCC), out of which Rs 13.94 crore or 32.64% was spent.

Valmik Thapar, wildlife conservationist and author, passes away at 73

In 2005, Thapar was appointed a member of the Tiger Task Force, set up by the UPA government to review the management of tiger reserves following the disappearance of tigers from Sariska Tiger Reserve. When the task force, chaired by environmentalist Sunita Narain, concluded its report, Thapar submitted a dissent note. Valmik Thapar, one of India’s most eminent wildlife conservationists and authors, died at his residence in New Delhi on Saturday (May 31, 2025) morning. He was 73. Born in New Delhi in 1952, Thapar dedicated his life to the study and conservation of wild tigers, especially in Rajasthan’s Ranthambore National Park. He co-founded the Ranthambhore Foundation in 1988, a non-governmental organisation focused on community-based conservation efforts. Congress leader Jairam Ramesh termed his death a great loss. “Today’s Ranthambore, particularly, is a testimony to his deep commitment and indefatigable zeal. He was uncommonly knowledgeable on a variety of issues relating to biodiversity, and not a day passed during my Ministerial tenure without our talking to each other, with me almost always at the receiving end,” Mr. Ramesh posted on X. He said that during his tenure as chairman of the Standing Committee, Thapar was a constant source of valuable suggestions and advice. Family and early years Thapar’s father, Romesh Thapar, was a well-known journalist. His aunt is historian Romila Thapar, and his cousin, journalist Karan Thapar. He studied at The Doon School and later graduated with a gold medal in sociology from St Stephen’s College, Delhi University. Thapar married theatre artist Sanjana Kapoor, daughter of actor Shashi Kapoor, and they have a son. Thapar was mentored by Fateh Singh Rathore, a legendary figure in Indian conservation and a key member of the original Project Tiger team. Tiger Task Force Over his five-decade-long career, Thapar strongly lobbied for tougher anti-poaching rules and efforts to protect tiger habitats. He was part of more than 150 government panels and task forces, including the National Board for Wildlife, which is led by the prime minister. In 2005, Thapar was appointed a member of the Tiger Task Force, set up by the UPA government to review the management of tiger reserves following the disappearance of tigers from Sariska Tiger Reserve. When the task force, chaired by environmentalist Sunita Narain, concluded its report, Thapar submitted a dissent note. He expressed concern that the report was overly optimistic about the coexistence of tigers and humans. Thapar argued that for tigers to survive in the long run, certain areas needed to be kept free from human interference. He said that a minimum area should be managed exclusively in its natural form for a tiger.

ସିଏସ୍‌ଇର ଜାତୀୟ ସମ୍ମିଳନୀ : ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ ଜୀବମଣ୍ଡଳର ଆତ୍ମା, ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ ଏହାକୁ ପ୍ରତି ମୁହୂର୍ତ୍ତରେ କ୍ଷତବିକ୍ଷତ କରୁଛି

ନୂଆଦିଲ୍ଲୀ : ସାମ୍ପ୍ରତିକ ପରିସ୍ଥିତିରେ ବାୟୁ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ ଏକ ସାଂଘାତିକ ସମସ୍ୟା ଭାବରେ ଉଭା ହୋଇଛି । କେନ୍ଦ୍ର ସରକାରଙ୍କ ଦ୍ୱାରା ପ୍ରଚଳିତ ଜାତୀୟ ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ କାର୍ଯ୍ୟକ୍ରମ (ଏନ୍‌ସିଏପି) ୫ ବର୍ଷ ପୂରଣ କରିଛି । ଏହି ଅବସରରେ ସେଣ୍ଟର ଫର ସାଇନ୍ସ ଏଣ୍ଡ ଏନ୍‌ଭୟରମେଣ୍ଟ (ସିଏସ୍‌ଇ) ପକ୍ଷରୁ ଦେଶର ପ୍ରମୁଖ ସହରଗୁଡ଼ିକର ବାୟୁ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣକୁ ନେଇ ଏକ ସମୀକ୍ଷା ରିପୋର୍ଟ ପ୍ରକାଶ କରାଯାଇଛି । ମଇ ୨୯ ତାରିଖରେ ଏକ ଜାତୀୟ ସମ୍ମିଳନୀରେ ଏହି ରିପୋର୍ଟକୁ ସିଏସ୍‌ଇର ମହାନିର୍ଦ୍ଦେଶକ ସୁନୀତା ନାରାୟଣ, କାର୍ଯ୍ୟନିର୍ବାହୀ ନିର୍ଦ୍ଦେଶକ ଅନୁମିତା ରାୟ ଚୌଧୁରୀ ଉନ୍ମୋଚନ କରିଛନ୍ତି । ସାରା ଦେଶର ବିଭିନ୍ନ ସହରରେ ଅସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ହୋଇ ପଡ଼ୁଥିବା ବାୟୁ ଉପରେ ସିଏସ୍‌ଇ ପକ୍ଷରୁ କରାଯାଇଥିବା ଅଧ୍ୟୟନକୁ ବିସ୍ତୃତ ଭାବରେ ରିପୋର୍ଟରେ ପ୍ରକାଶ କରାଯାଇଛି। ଦିଲ୍ଲୀ, କୋଲକାତା, ନୋଏଡା, ସୁରଟ, କୋଚି,ଇଣ୍ଡୋର, ଶ୍ରୀନଗର, ବେଙ୍ଗାଲୁର ଓ ଭୁବନେଶ୍ୱର ଆଦି ସହରକୁ ଏଥିରେ ସାମିଲ କରାଯାଇଛି। ତତ୍‌କାଳୀନ ସରକାରଙ୍କ ଦ୍ୱାରା ଭୁବନେଶ୍ୱରରେ ପ୍ରଚଳନ କରାଯାଇଥିବା ସହରାଞ୍ଚଳ ପରିବହନ ବ୍ୟବସ୍ଥା କିପରି ବାୟୁ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ ରୋକିବାରେ ମହତ୍ୱପୂର୍ଣ୍ଣ ପରିବର୍ତ୍ତନ ଆଣି ପାରିଛି ତାହା ଉପରେ ସମୀକ୍ଷା ରିପୋର୍ଟରେ ଆଲୋକପାତ କରାଯାଇଛି । ପ୍ରାରମ୍ଭିକ ଅଧିବେଶନରେ ସିଏସ୍‌ଇର ମହାନିର୍ଦ୍ଦେଶକ ସୁନିତା ନାରାୟଣ କାର୍ଯ୍ୟକ୍ରମରେ ଯୋଗ ଦେଇ କହିଛନ୍ତି ଯେ ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ ମଣିଷର ଆତ୍ମା । ମାତ୍ର ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ ଆମର ଆତ୍ମାକୁ ପ୍ରତି ମୁହୂର୍ତ୍ତରେ କ୍ଷତବିକ୍ଷତ କରୁଛି । ଏଥିପାଇଁ ପ୍ରତିସ୍ତରରେ ଓ ପ୍ରତି କ୍ଷେତ୍ରରେ ସତର୍କରହିବାର ଆବଶ୍ୟତା ରହିଛି । ପରିବର୍ତ୍ତନମୂଳକ ପଦକ୍ଷେପ ବିନା ଏହା ସମ୍ଭବ ନୁହେଁ । ସମ୍ପ୍ରତି ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ ନିମନ୍ତେ ଯେତିକି ପଦକ୍ଷେପ ଗ୍ରହଣ କରାଯାଇଛି, ତାହା ପର୍ଯ୍ୟାପ୍ତ ନୁହେଁ । ଏହା ଉପରେ ଅଧିକ ଚିନ୍ତନ ଓ ଅଧିକ କଠୋର ନିଷ୍ପତ୍ତି ନେବାର ଆବଶ୍ୟକତା ରହିଛି । ଏହା ଏକମାତ୍ର ବିକଳ୍ପ ଓ ଏଥିରେ କୌଣସି ସାଲିସ ସମଗ୍ର ମାନବ ସମାଜର ଭବିଷ୍ୟତ ପାଇଁ କ୍ଷତିକାରକ ସାବ୍ୟସ୍ତ ହେବ ବୋଲି ସେ ମତପ୍ରକାଶ କରିଛନ୍ତି । ଏନ୍‌ସିଏପି ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ ଓ ଗୁଣବତ୍ତା ପରିଚାଳନାର ଢ଼ାଞ୍ଚା ପ୍ରତିଷ୍ଠାରେ ଯଦିଓ ସହାୟକ ହୋଇଛି, ତାହା ପର୍ଯ୍ୟାପ୍ତ ନୁହେଁ । ସହରଗୁଡ଼ିକରେ ବାୟୁ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ ନିମନ୍ତେ ଯେଉଁ ପ୍ରମୁଖ କ୍ଷେତ୍ରଗୁଡ଼ିକ ରହିଛି ସେଥିରେ ଯାନବାହନ ଚଳାଚଳ, ନିର୍ମାଣ ବର୍ଜ୍ୟର ଉପଯୁକ୍ତ ପରିଚାଳନାର ଅଭାବ ପ୍ରମୁଖ ଭୂମିକା ଗ୍ରହଣ କରିଛି । ତେଣୁ ଏହାକୁ ନେଇ ଦେଶର ବିଭିନ୍ନ ସହରଗୁଡ଼ିକରେ ଯେଉଁ କେସ ଷ୍ଟଡ଼ି ଗ୍ରହଣ କରାଯାଇଛି ତାହାର ସମୀକ୍ଷା ଓ ସମାଧାନ ଏକାନ୍ତ ଅପରିହାର୍ଯ୍ୟ । ସିଏସ୍‌ଇ ଭଲ ପଦକ୍ଷେପ ଓ ଖରାପ କାର୍ଯ୍ୟଗୁଡ଼ିକୁ ଅତ୍ୟନ୍ତ ନିରପେକ୍ଷ ଭାବରେ ବିଶ୍ଲେଷଣ କରି ଏହି ରିପୋର୍ଟ ପ୍ରକାଶ କରିଛି । କୋଚି ସହରରେ ମେଟ୍ରୋ ରେଳ ପ୍ରଚଳନ ଓ ନବୀକୃତ ସୌର ଶକ୍ତିରେ ଏହାର ପରିବହନ ବ୍ୟବସ୍ଥା ପ୍ରଚଳନ ସହରର ବାୟୁ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣକୁ ରୋକିବାରେ ସକ୍ଷମ ହୋଇଛି। ଶ୍ରୀନଗର ଏହାର ପରିବହନ ଏବଂ ଗତିଶୀଳତା ବ୍ୟବସ୍ଥାକୁ ଅପଗ୍ରେଡ୍‌ ଏବଂ ଉନ୍ନତ କରିବା ପାଇଁ ଏହାର ସ୍ମାର୍ଟ ସିଟି କାର୍ଯ୍ୟକ୍ରମ ପାଣ୍ଠି ବ୍ୟବହାର କରିଛି ଓ ସହର ସାରା ପଦଯାତ୍ରା ଭିତ୍ତିଭୂମିକୁ ବିକଶିତ କରି ନୂତନ ଉଦାହରଣ ସୃଷ୍ଟି କରିଛି । ଉଦୀୟମାନ ସହର ମଧ୍ୟରେ ଭୁବନେଶ୍ୱର ଏକ ଅନନ୍ୟ ଉଦାହରଣ ସୃଷ୍ଟି କରିଛି । ସହରର ଏକ ନୂତନ ବସ୍‌ ପ୍ରଚଳନ ବ୍ୟବସ୍ଥା ସହରୀ ଜୀବନ ଓ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ କ୍ଷେତ୍ରରେ ଉଲ୍ଲେଖନୀୟ ପରିବର୍ତ୍ତନ ଆଣି ପାରିଛି। ଅନୁରୂପ ଭାବରେ ଚେନ୍ନାଇରେ ପଦଚାରୀଙ୍କ ପାଇଁ ଶୃଙ୍ଖଳିତ ବ୍ୟବସ୍ଥା ଓ ସାଇକେଲିଂ ଭିତ୍ତିଭୂମିକୁ ବିକଶିତ କରାଯାଇ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣକୁ ହ୍ରାସ କରାଯାଇ ପାରିଛି । କୋଲକାତାରେ ନିର୍ମାଣ ବର୍ଜ୍ୟର ଉପଯୁକ୍ତ ପରିଚାଳନା ସହରରେ ବର୍ଦ୍ଧିତ ବାୟୁର ଅସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛତାକୁ ରୋକିବାକୁ ସମର୍ଥ ହୋଇଛି । ଅନ୍ୟପକ୍ଷରେ ଶିଳ୍ପ ବାୟୁ ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ ରୋକାଯିବା ପ୍ରମୁଖ ସହର ପାଇଁ ଆହ୍ୱାନପୂର୍ଣ୍ଣ ହୋଇଛି । ଅଧିକାଂଶ ଶିଳ୍ପ ସହର କ୍ଷେତ୍ର ବାହାରେ ହୋଇଥିଲେ ହେଁ ଏହାର ବାୟୁ ସହର ପାଇଁ ବିପଦ ପାଲଟିଛି। ପୁନଶ୍ଚ ସହରାଞ୍ଚଳରେ କଠିନ ବର୍ଜ୍ୟ ଅର୍ଥାତ୍‌ ନିର୍ମାଣ ବର୍ଜ୍ୟ ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ ପାଇଁ ବିପଦ ସୃଷ୍ଟି କରିଛି । ଏହି ସ୍ଥିତିରେ କଠିନ ବର୍ଜ୍ୟବସ୍ତୁ ପରିଚାଳନା କ୍ଷେତ୍ରରେ ହାଇଦ୍ରାବାଦ ବିକେନ୍ଦ୍ରୀକରଣ ପରିଚାଳନାର ଏକ ଅନନ୍ୟ ମଡେଲ ଗ୍ରହଣ କରିଛି, ଯେଉଁଠାରେ ସାର୍ବଜନୀନ-ଘରୋଇ ସହଭାଗୀତା ମଡେଲ ଅଧୀନରେ ଚାରୋଟି ପ୍ଲାଣ୍ଟ ସହରାଞ୍ଚଳରେ ସ୍ଥାପନ କରାଯାଇଛି। ଏହି ରିସାଇକ୍ଲିଂ ପ୍ଲାଣ୍ଟଗୁଡ଼ିକ ସହରର ନିର୍ମାଣ ବର୍ଜ୍ୟକୁ ପୁନଃବ୍ୟବହାରକ୍ଷମ ସାମଗ୍ରୀରେ ପରିବର୍ତ୍ତନ କରି ସହରକୁ ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ ପ୍ରଦାନରେ ସହାୟକ ହୋଇଛି । ଏହି ପରିପ୍ରେକ୍ଷୀରେ ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛ ବାୟୁ ନିମନ୍ତେ ସ୍ମାର୍ଟ ସିଟି ମିଶନ, ବୈଦ୍ୟୁତିକ ଯାନବାହନ ପାଇଁ ଜାତୀୟ ଚାହିଦା ପ୍ରୋତ୍ସାହନ କାର୍ଯ୍ୟକ୍ରମ, ଅନ୍ୟାନ୍ୟ ସମାନ୍ତରାଳ କ୍ଷେତ୍ରୀୟ କାର୍ଯ୍ୟକ୍ରମ ଅଧୀନରେ ଅଧିକ ପ୍ରୟୋଗତ୍ମକ ପଦକ୍ଷେପ ଗ୍ରହଣ ଜରୁରୀ ହୋଇ ପଡ଼ିଛି ବୋଲି ସମୀକ୍ଷା ରିପୋର୍ଟରେ ପ୍ରକାଶ କରାଯାଇଛି । ଏହି ଅବସରରେ ଦିବସବ୍ୟାପୀ ବିଭିନ୍ନ ପ୍ୟାନେଲ ଆଲୋଚନା ଅନୁଷ୍ଠିତ ହୋଇଥିଲା । ଏଥିରେ କେନ୍ଦ୍ର ସରକାରଙ୍କ ବାୟୁ ଗୁଣବତ୍ତା ପରିଚାଳନା ବିଭାଗର ସଦସ୍ୟ ସଚିବ ଅରବିନ୍ଦ ନୌଟିଆଲ, ସ୍ୱଚ୍ଛଭାରତ ମିଶନର ଜାତୀୟ ନିର୍ଦ୍ଦେଶକ ବିନୟ କୁମାର ଝା, ବିଶ୍ୱବ୍ୟାଙ୍କ ପରିବେଶ ବିଶେଷଜ୍ଞ ସାୟନ୍ତନ ସରକାର, କେନ୍ଦ୍ର ପ୍ରଦୂଷଣ ନିୟନ୍ତ୍ରଣ ବୋଡର଼୍ର ବୈଜ୍ଞାନିକ ଅନାମିକା ସାଗର ଓ ବିନୟ ପ୍ରଭାକର, ଇଣ୍ଡିଆନ ଫେଡେ଼ରେସନ୍‌ ଅଫ୍‌ ଗ୍ରୀନ୍‌ ଏନର୍ଜିର ମହାନିର୍ଦ୍ଦେଶକ ସଞ୍ଜୟ ଗଞ୍ଜୋ, ଆସୋଚାମ୍‌ର ବରିଷ୍ଠ ପରାମର୍ଶଦାତା ପିନାକୀ ଦାସଗୁପ୍ତାଙ୍କ ସହ କୋଚି ମେଟ୍ରୋ, ଶ୍ରୀନଗର ସ୍ମାର୍ଟ ସିଟି, ବୃହନ୍ମୁମ୍ବାଇ ବୈଦୁତିକ ପରିବହନ ସଂସ୍ଥା, ଚେନ୍ନାଇ ସ୍ମାର୍ଟ ସିଟି, ଦିଲ୍ଲୀ ମହାନଗର ନିଗମ, ହାଇଦ୍ରାବାଦ ଏସ୍‌ଏସ୍‌ଆର୍‌ସି, ଚଣ୍ଡୀଗଡ଼ ମହାନଗର ନିଗମ, ଜୟପୁରର ଏମ୍‌ଏନ୍‌ଆଇଟିର ବରିଷ୍ଠ ଅଧିକାରୀମାନେ ଅଂଶଗ୍ରହଣ କରିଥିଲେ।

CSE releases nation-wide review of good practice in clean air action

India’s National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) has completed five years. A new nation-wide review of the Programme by Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) has shown that it has notched up hits as well as misses. The review report – titled Driving Clean Air Action under NCAP – was released here today at a national conference. The CSE review focuses on selected case studies from across India that showcase emerging good practices in clean air action in four different sectors: vehicles, industries, solid waste and construction and demolition (C&D) waste. But it also lays bare some of the systemic drawbacks that have kept the Programme from reaching its full potential. The urban centres which the review has covered include Delhi, Kolkata, Noida, Surat, Kochi, Indore, Srinagar and Bengaluru, among others. Speaking at the conference, CSE director general Sunita Narain said: “Clean air action needs to be taken sector by sector and within a sector we need game changers. Incremental action will not solve the pollution problem. We need transformational measures.” Releasing the study report, CSE’s executive director Anumita Roychowdhury said: “Our review shows that while NCAP has helped establish the national air quality management framework with clean air targets, identified the non-attainment cities and adopted the first-ever performance-linked funding strategy, its interventions have been largely confined to road dust control, especially in the Indo-Gangetic Plains. Funding that is available under the Programme is not equitably spread across priority measures in the combustion sectors.” Roychowdhury emphasises: “This review is not a report card on what all cities have done and how they have progressed under NCAP. This is simply an assessment of some – not all — of the good practices to cut toxic emissions that are being initiated and followed in a few cities across the country.” The criteria for selection of the case studies, say CSE researchers, has considered alignment with national policies, guidelines, regulations and standards, service-level benchmarks, targets and mandates. It has also recognised innovation in approaches, technology adoption, institutional reforms, fiscal strategy, process changes and system development.

India, a major user of coal power, is making large gains in clean energy adoption. Here is how

The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India's electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. One of the most carbon-polluting countries, India is also making huge efforts to harness the power of the sun, wind and other clean energy sources. Most of the electricity in India, the world's most populous nation, still comes from coal , one of the dirtiest forms of energy. But coal's dominance is dropping, going from 60% of installed power capacity 11 years ago to less than 50% today, according to India's power ministry. At the same time, India had its largest ever addition of clean power in the fiscal year between April 2024 and April of this year, adding 30 gigawatts — enough to power nearly 18 million Indian homes. With a growing middle class and skyrocketing energy needs, how fast India can move away from coal and other fossil fuels, such as gasoline and oil, could have a large impact on global efforts to confront climate change. Here is a snapshot of India's clean energy transition and some of the challenges. Renewable energy is now the most economical option Solar is now half the cost of power from new coal-powered plants. Availability of cheap components and many sunny days each year in India are some reasons experts say installed solar power increased 30 times in the last decade. “Solar power is the cheapest it's ever been,” said Ruchita Shah, an energy analyst at climate think-tank Ember. Shah added that dropping costs for energy storage, in the form of batteries, means that renewable power will be the “new normal," even when the sun doesn't shine or the wind doesn't blow. India has nearly 170 gigawatts of renewable energy projects in the pipeline, which are expected to be completed in the next few years. “I have no doubt that India will reach its target of 500 gigawatts by 2030,” said Raghav Pachouri, an energy expert at Vasudha Foundation, a New Delhi-based think-tank. Government policies and private investments push renewables Experts say the growth in renewables is being spurred by India's plans to add approximately 50 gigawatts of non-fossil fuel power capacity every year for the next five years and for clean power to provide 50% of the nation’s energy by the decade. When burned, fossil fuels let off greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, the main driver of climate change. A 2022 law that made electricity cheaper for companies choosing to buy clean power, the federal government's recommendation that state utilities buy more renewable power and a 2023 government plan to invest $452 million have all catalyzed investments in renewables. India has the fourth highest amount of clean power installed in the world and government officials said $81 billion has been invested in the renewable energy sector in the last decade. Multiple large-scale renewable power projects have begun operations or are under construction, including one of the world’s largest wind and solar power farms. “We’ve seen domestic manufacturing capacity, at least when it comes to modules for solar panels, increasing,” said Madhura Joshi, a senior energy analyst at the European think-tank E3G. Still, renewables are underutilized Despite the rapid growth, challenges persist. While non-fossil fuel sources now comprise 45% of India’s total installed capacity, their share in actual electricity generation stood at 24% last year. Coal remains the dominant source, accounting for 75% of electricity generation. The share of solar, wind, small hydro power and biomass in India's electricity generation mix stood at 12%, double what it was in 2014 but still lower than expectations by this time, according to a report by New Delhi-based think-tank, the Centre for Science and Environment. Installed capacity is growing, but power generation from renewables needs to be optimized and integrated effectively into the grid, the report found. At a clean energy crossroads A recent report by the nonprofit clean energy think-tank, RMI, found that electricity demand is expected to triple by 2050 — driven by more electric vehicles, air conditioners and industrial growth. Acquiring land for clean energy projects remains a challenge. India also needs to rapidly build robust electricity transmission infrastructure and energy storage facilities to continue increasing clean power capacity. “India is expected to become the world's third-largest economy in a few years, and I think we will need to adopt renewable energy to do this. There is no option for us because fossil fuels can’t keep pace" with energy needs, said Deepak Thakur, chief executive officer of Mumbai-based renewable energy company, Mahindra Susten.

Backstory: The Disappearance of Media Stories on the Disappeared Points to a Cruel Future

Anil Agrawal and Sunita Narain from the Centre for Science and Environment Delhi observed: “Can we really equate the CO2 contributions of gas-guzzling automobiles in Europe and North America or, for that matter, anywhere in the Third World with the methane emissions of draught cattle and rice fields of subsistence farmers in West Bengal or Thailand? Do these people not have a right to live? But no effort has been made in WRI’s report to separate out the ‘survival emissions’ of the poor, from the ‘luxury emissions’ of the rich.” Earlier this year, the sight of Indians deemed “illegal” by the US government under President Donald Trump and peremptorily sent back in a US military aircraft to India, manacled and shackled, created widespread outrage in the country. Headlines like ‘Indian Illegal Migrants Deported From US Tell Their Tales Of Abuse’ marked the accompanying flood of media coverage. In sharp contrast, the Indian government’s renewed attempts to push out Rohingya and Bangladeshis who have fled to India, into the shadow lands and waters bordering neighbouring countries, have been met by a conspicuous media silence. So rarely has there been any incisive, or even just plain, reportage on the issue, that when the Indian Express carried a front page report on May 20, headlined ‘In last 6 months, at least 770 from Delhi alone deported to Bangladesh as part of crackdown’, it came as a shock. While there may have been unconfirmed information floating around that a few individuals deemed to be Bangladeshi or Rohingya have been pushed across the Bangladesh or Myanmar borders, nobody knew that there was an actual “crackdown”, and nobody suspected that the number of those so deported had touched “at least 770”. The forced evacuation of such a large cohort is alarming in a democratic country. It signals a breakdown of moral and ethical codes that had at one point in its history marked the country’s response to those seeking shelter within its shores for their survival. There are five reasons why such developments do not capture empathetic media attention and why stories of the disappeared are literally disappeared from media coverage. First is the confusion of semantics, which in turn has clouded public understanding of who exactly constitute this unusually variegated group. India, after all, has not signed the Refugee Convention of 1951, so what is the legal framework by which to perceive a bewildering range of people who could be deemed as foreigners, refugees, the internally displaced, economic migrants, or even environmental refugees? Secondly, precisely because of this lack of a legal framework, they can be framed in dark shades as criminals or illegals, depending on political expediency. The use of terms like ‘infiltrators’, ‘terrorists’, ‘militants’ and even ‘termites’ (as the home minister once characterised them), only serves to dehumanise them further and invest them with an unverifiable patina of diabolism. Thirdly, what has made the confusion worse is the prism of communalism through which these communities have come to be viewed, particularly after the enactment of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019. While those regarded as “our migrants” enjoy fast-tracked citizenship, particularly harsh treatment is meted out to “their migrants”, which includes police repression, vigilante persecution and summary expulsion. Also read | ‘Thrown Into the Sea’: How India Allegedly Deported 38 Rohingya Refugees Without Due Process Fourthly, over a period of time, this amalgam of untenable formulations, hate speech for electoral purposes and systematic stigmatisation has led to sections of the Indian population and media professionals left incapable of adopting a more rational approach to the issue. Some have even become convinced that the undocumented pose an imminent threat to their own security and that of the state – again without offering a shred of proof. When a few thousand Rohingya settled in Jammu came under the scanner, the cry went out that their crimes would need to be publicised. The long and elaborate compilation exercise that followed revealed no evidence of any major crime or security threat perpetrated by the frightened community. Big power projections comprise the fifth factor. Israel’s deliberate and strategic take-no-prisoners approach in Gaza, which could lead to the near annihilation of an entire population, has unfortunately come to be seen by many within the Indian media, not as the genocide it is but as the template that India needs to adopt to emerge as a “strong state”. In the process, the capacity to accommodate, assimilate and absorb diversity and difference to a level unparalleled anywhere in the world, which had made India what it is today, is in danger of being lost forever. The centuries’ old belief, atithi devo bhava(guest is akin to god), is now robbed of any meaning and remains an empty shibboleth to be mouthed at the international summits that India hosts, and forgotten thereafter. Today, as a result, we have a media that is willing to stomach extraordinary levels of state-driven cruelty meted out to helpless communities of stateless people in the name of national interest. The legacy media may even get reliable information about atrocities being committed against them, but they will do nothing about it. Once in a way, a newspaper like the Indian Express may flash stories of this kind on its front page, but for hundreds of news channels and thousands of “large” newspapers, this is not what makes news. In early May, when 38 Rohingya men, women and children were allegedly detained by the Delhi police on the pretext of getting their biometrics done; herded into a holding centre; taken to Port Blair; transferred to an Indian naval vessel; beaten; given life jackets and then pushed into the sea fringing Myanmar, with no legal process being followed whatsoever and in violation of international and national law, the stray reports that surfaced were only on social media. When a petition on this case was taken before the justices of the Supreme Court, they termed it a ‘fanciful idea’ and dismissed it out of hand. Such plausible deniability would not have been possible if the media had taken such information with the seriousness it demanded. What does this mean for the future? The process of othering is unlikely to stop at the hapless stateless. The persecutors and prosecutors will find new communities to target, new ways to make those who are “insiders” today into “outsiders” tomorrow, with the media willingly playing the role of accessory to the crime. It is a cruel future that awaits us. § Thoughts on World Environment Day Today, the impacts of environmental destruction are widely known, partly because there is far greater media coverage of issues like climate change and ecological destruction than was the case earlier. But it has been a long, bumpy journey. The first international conference hosted by the United Nations, the Stockholm Conference on the Human Environment, was held in 1972 and it proclaimed to the world that “Man is both creature and moulder of his environment, which gives him physical sustenance and affords him the opportunity for intellectual, moral, social and spiritual growth.” There was that ring of anachronism interlacing those words in the way it privileged the male gender, but even more conspicuous was the misplaced optimism that they evoked: “through the rapid acceleration of science and technology, man has acquired the power to transform his environment in countless ways and on an unprecedented scale.” The fear amongst the countries in the South at that juncture was that an agenda of “conservation”, the buzz word of the era, would be at the cost of “development”, or the attempts of the poorer parts of the globe, labelled unambiguously as the “underdeveloped world”, to improve its prospects. Two decades later, another international conference on the environment, this time at Rio, saw the North-South divide get even more pronounced and its articulation more sophisticated. When emissions of cattle and the methane generated by rice fields were cited in a report from the Washington-based World Resources Institute as a major contributor to pollution, Indian environmentalists pushed back. Also read: Yes, Environment Ministry Took ‘Many Steps’ Under Modi – But They Came At the Cost of Environment Itself Anil Agrawal and Sunita Narain from the Centre for Science and Environment Delhi observed: “Can we really equate the CO2 contributions of gas-guzzling automobiles in Europe and North America or, for that matter, anywhere in the Third World with the methane emissions of draught cattle and rice fields of subsistence farmers in West Bengal or Thailand? Do these people not have a right to live? But no effort has been made in WRI’s report to separate out the ‘survival emissions’ of the poor, from the ‘luxury emissions’ of the rich.” This observation did not of course take into adequate consideration the ‘luxury emissions’ of the rich in the poorer countries, or the emissions of “poorer countries” seeking to achieve First World arsenals. Ultimately, there was no getting away from the fact that everyone on the planet, whether from the North or the South, whether from the developed world or the developing world, needed to get more aware of just what was happening to their environment at the national and international levels. It was this spirit that egged a group of concerned scientists, environmentalists and journalists to come together in 1982 to produce a citizens’ report, edited by Anil Agarwal, Ravi Chopra and Kalpana Sharma on the ‘The State of India’s Environment’. What was striking about this volume – dedicated to the women of Chamoli – was how far ahead of its times it was, not just by being the first publication of its kind brought out by concerned citizens under the banner of the Centre for Science and Environment, but the effort it took to put across complex issues in a readable, usable style through quality design and the wide use of data, infographics and illustrations. There was also a liberal sprinkling of “not-so-fun facts” (“70 per cent of all the available water in India is polluted. About 73 million workdays are lost due to water-related diseases”). Many of those associated with the publication are no longer with us. They include Anil Agrawal, the passionate prime mover of this effort; Anupam Mishra, the Gandhian water conservationist; newspaper editor Darryl D’Monte; and Smitu Kothari, ecologist and author. Others went on to achieve personal milestones, many in the environmental field. Today, as we mark yet another World Environment Day (on June 5), it may be worth our while to revisit a paragraph in the introduction to this volume: “Most of us come to know of environmental problems and effects in a piecemeal manner. But when we read this overview of the state of the nation’s rivers, dams, forests, air, soil, plants, animals, towns, village, health and energy problems, the impact is certainly overwhelming.” It comes as a reminder that our journalism on the environment also cannot exist in silos and needs to keep the larger backdrop of climate change within its sights. As Sanjay Asthana recalled in the elegant environmental portal, Mongabay, the efforts made by students and environmentalists to protect the priceless 400-acre forest of Kancha Gachibowli adjoining Hyderabad University were invaluable. The courts woke up to the destruction too late. He recalled how that patch of forest had educated him on the local biophysical sphere as a young PhD scholar. Ecological destruction is happening in plain sight and if we don’t have the information and words to push back against the onslaught, posterity will never forgive us.