Pollution is an airshed issue and govts’ inability to work together stalls action
SC panel EPCA’s long stint, with Sunita Narain and Bhure Lal at helm, has come to an end with the constitution of a commission for air quality management in NCR. Jasjeev Gandhiok & Priyangi Agarwal speak to them about what was achieved in 22 years, inadequacies of the system and what remains to be done So, India’s air is filthy, says Donald Trump, and our hackles go up? Earlier, airlines have cancelled flights to Delhi because of the smog. Years later, nothing much has changed. Do you think we are condemned to live with this? SN It is a bit unfair to say that. Overall, there is a sense of despair all around and we are a highly cynical people, but I think things have changed. We need to be clear that we are taking steps to clean up our air. That is more than I can say for Mr Trump, whose country’s emissions have actually increased in the past few years. The 2019 greenhouse gas emissions of the US are higher than they were in 2016. The US is not going to meet even its extremely meagre commitments under the Paris Accord. So, let’s not allow Mr Trump to determine how good or bad we are because it’s like the pot calling the kettle black. The air pollution agenda has moved ahead in three ways. Firstly, now we have huge public anguish about air pollution. Bhure Lal ji and I have struggled to make pollution a big issue as it was not central to policy or politics or in the minds of people. Today, there is anguish all around that there is pollution and that is pushing policy and politics. Secondly, through our efforts and efforts of the governments, there has been huge work to build a public information system on air quality in the region. We have a very dense network of monitors and we have built a health index so that you know and I know what’s the quality of air and how it impacts your health. Thirdly, a lot of efforts have been made over the past few years which I believe are beginning to show up other than in those two critical months whether it is BS VI fuel, bypasses or the RFID system. The moot point is, we need far more drastic action if we want clean air. You speak of the need for drastic action. What is required to bring about a change in the long term? SN You cannot deal with air pollution through knee-jerk and short-term measures. There is a difference between the two existing instruments of policy. Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP) is an emergency action plan. If there is fire, you do not talk about building a new fire station. You put out the fire. Then there is the Comprehensive Action Plan (CAP). Why did we see clean air during the lockdown? Because two critical sources of air pollution vanished – vehicles went off the road and no trucks were entering the city. Second, no industrial combustion was taking place. We still had dust, we still had garbage burning. If you are looking at an action plan for the future, then two big steps need to be taken. We have to get rid of pet coke and furnace oil in the region but it gets replaced by coal. In Delhi, coal has been banned but it is being used illegally in many areas. So, the biggest challenge today is to usher in the next CNG revolution. If you remember, EPCA started its journey by asking for a transformation in the fuel use in vehicles. We called it a leapfrog. We said, don’t just clean up diesel but move to CNG. We believe very strongly that we need a similar gas revolution in all of NCR, where natural gas or electricity must replace coal. You also need to reduce the number of vehicles on the road.
