Monsoon mayhem: No easy fix to urban flooding
Ultimately, it has to be a combination of solutions. “The CSE study in Sangam Vihar –– Delhi’s largest unauthorised settlement, housing an estimated one million people, confirmed the need for a blend of grey and green-blue infrastructure under a decentralised water supply, wastewater and stormwater management. If we want to address equity and justice, then we must prioritise the deficits in our dense unplanned settlements,” insisted Kapur, who authored the study in his previous role at the Centre for Science and Environment. Parts of Bengaluru were knee-deep in rainwater during the pre-monsoon downpour in mid-May. The rains hit Mumbai a week earlier than scheduled, and flooded its new metro station, and halted the train service. Since the season’s onset, Delhi’s waterlogged roads have led to perpetual traffic snarls and sewage backflows. Gurugram has lived up to the moniker #Gurujam, offering spectacles of marooned gated communities and inspiring comparisons with Venice on social media. However shocking, these scenes now evoke a feeling of déjà vu. In the last two decades since the Mumbai flood, caused by a 100-year-high rainfall and killing more than 1,000 people in 2005, there has been no respite for Indian cities from inundation, monsoon after monsoon. Experts say there is no quick fix for flooding triggered by short bouts of intense rain due to climate change. While such events will continue to overwhelm the civic infrastructure, which has its physical limits and capacities, there is little excuse for not doing the basics right, which go a long way in monsoon preparedness. Predicting an uncertain climate future is often challenging, but looking back at how we have planned, designed, and maintained our cities can offer vital cues for course correction. Lessons from urban ‘development’ When the British decided to move the imperial capital from Calcutta (Now Kolkata) to Delhi, the architects were reluctant to go with the earmarked Coronation Park site in Burari because it was too close to the floodplain. Ultimately, the higher ground on Raisina Hill was selected. Ironically, much of the urbanisation post-Independence has happened in the floodplain, which naturally attracts floodwaters. Chennai, which is frequently inundated — its worst floods were reported in 2015 — does relatively better in the planned old town, where the drains are still functional, said Balaji Narasimhan, a hydrologist at the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Madras. The hotspots are low-lying areas developed on paddy fields where the soil is clayey, water cannot percolate freely, and drainage by gravity is limited due to topographical constraints and encroachment of drainage pathways. In Mumbai, the land reclamation areas, including parts of Island City and Bandra Kurla Complex, are more prone to waterlogging. “These low-lying areas are challenging to deal with. If high tide is coupled with high-intensity rainfall, water takes more than normal time to recede and accumulate,” said Abhijit Bangar, deputy municipal commissioner (projects) at Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC). Rainwater is meant to take its natural course, flowing from upstream to downstream and falling into a lake, river, or sea or sinking back into the earth. However, when linear infrastructure such as rail tracks, roads, or buildings intercept this natural flow or concrete surfaces prevent absorption, flooding occurs. Delhi, for example, has raised pillars of elevated roads and the Metro inside its natural channels that once facilitated rainwater drainage to the Yamuna. Previously, cities would flood from swollen rivers. Now we see “in-situ flooding”, said Depinder Kapur, the head of the Climate Centre for Cities at the National Institute of Urban Affairs. “During heavy rains last year, the water levels in the Yamuna did not rise, yet south and central Delhi were inundated. Even Bengaluru, located on a plateau with no major river, suffers from frequent in-situ flooding. Increased precipitation plays a big part here, but this also highlights significant issues in urban planning.” Obsessive overbuilding Across cities, there has been a mindless tendency to overbuild. Using high-resolution satellite imagery, WRI-India found that between 2000 and 2015, the built-up area in the ten most populous Indian cities increased on average by 47% and 134% within 0–20km of the city centre and 20–50km periphery, respectively. Simultaneously, the blue cover (water bodies) decreased by 15%. The study also found that 44% of this new development is located in zones with high or very high recharge potential, and an estimated 300 billion litres of water per year are now diverted away from underground aquifers. A US-specific study indicates that even a 1% increase in built-up areas results in a 7% increase in the extent of flooding. In India, this is partly because of market pressure to get the maximum value from the land, said Sahana Goswami, senior programme manager at WRI-India, one of the authors of the 10-cities study. There is also the desire to have good views — such as lakeside and riverside apartments — where development occurs at the expense of green and blue spaces. Regulations on land use need to be implemented, added Nitin Bassi, who leads the sustainable water team at Council on Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW), a non-profit policy research institute. In-built inadequacies Many cities have common channels for stormwater and sewers. In Bengaluru, nullahs are losing their natural slope because stormwater channels are used as sewer drains throughout the year. With siltation, the water stagnates, receding the slope gradient. Also, culverts with their pillars reduce the width of the drain, said Rajarshi Das Bhowmik, assistant professor at the Indian Institute of Science (IISc) Bangalore. In extreme cases of flooding, roads are also supposed to serve as conduits for water. But if roads are not milled to the bottom when relaid, it artificially changes the road profile as compared to the adjacent lands, and causes localised flooding, said Narasihman. Indian cities don’t have a separate utility duct to put water supply lines, power lines, data fibres, etc. They use the storm drain as an easy conduit, he added. If the older cities suffer from legacy drainage issues, the newer towns have grown without the basics. Gurugram rose from agricultural lands sold to builders who developed private gated communities on a level higher than the surrounding roads, said Bassi. these gated complexes set up decentralised wastewater management without factoring in the high runoff volumes they would release to the streets during storm events, he added. The newer areas of Bengaluru have similar problems. Wastewater is often dumped outside the gated society, which remains flood-free, but the road outside is inundated, said Bhowmik. Multiple jurisdictions of drains compound the problem. In Delhi, nine agencies are involved in drain management. “If the flood and irrigation department drains are not clean, the water from the public works department will backflow. When the PWD drains are blocked, the MCD drains backflow,” said a retired official at the Delhi Municipal Corporation. Seasonal mess Indian cities prepare for the monsoon mess throughout the year by dumping tonnes of garbage, construction waste, and domestic sewage into stormwater channels. Before the monsoon, the road-owning agencies clean these choked drains, leaving them on the roadside. The first shower, and the muck is back in the drains. On average, about one million metric tonnes of silt is removed from the drains annually in Delhi, but there is no dedicated disposal space. Landfills are saturated. “It is anybody’s guess where the silt goes,” said the retired official. While silt removed from the nullah is supposed to be carried for disposal, there is a reason desilted muck is left lying in the open for at least 48 hours. “It is to dehydrate it. Wet silt can’t be carried immediately, as it leads to problems of leachate leakage from the transport vehicles. Wet silt also adds to the weight-to-volume ratio and can lead to excessive payments to contractor payments,” explained Bangar. But can desilting alone ensure that rainwater won’t flood our cities? Not really, said Goswami. “We assume the drains have 100% coverage. Also, many parts of our cities have combined sewers, or what was originally a storm drain now carries sewage anyway. This high volume of mixed silt accumulating daily must be removed to ensure effective storm drains.” In Gurugram, even if the drains are there, they are inadequate to take care of the road runoff. Then there is additional water from the flyovers, which finds no way to evacuate and cascades like a waterfall to the road below, said Bassi. Municipal officials feel that too much accountability has been placed on agencies without adequate support. “They talk about geo-tagging the desilted sites, but during the three months we do the job, there is a shortage of machinery, trucks, loaders, etc, which nobody talks about. The plans to mechanise the work are still on paper,” said the former MCD official. Bassi concurs: “Municipalities manage too many things simultaneously, but their finances are poor. Municipal services — water supply, free solid waste collection, park maintenance — cannot be free anymore. They need to be priced to generate enough resources for the municipalities to work as required.” Nature-based solutions (NBS) Goswami said we can preserve excess water as a resource; only what can’t be absorbed should go downstream. So, efforts are being made to revive many natural water bodies surrounding Bengaluru. In Chennai, the marshland that used to absorb floodwater is being rehabilitated. But, NBS is not without its limitations, said Narasihman. “The sponge park might only work in two-year or five-year floods. If the flooding exceeds that, the city will still be inundated.” But, NBS has other co-benefits of reducing urban heat island, and helping groundwater recharge and biodiversity, he added. NBS are also not maintenance-free, as natural drains require dredging and sponge parks must be revegetated. Most importantly, agencies in charge must ensure that rainwater polluted with sewage, garbage, and road runoff doesn’t land in these water bodies and green spaces without proper treatment. The efficacy of runoff absorption also depends on the water table and may not work where the groundwater levels are high, warned Bhowmik. Bangar said that in cities like Mumbai, where every square inch of land is extremely valuable, there is no space for NBS apart from government land, forest land, the national park, and salt pans. “This has prompted us to design NBS considering existing gardens and grounds. Mangroves and salt pans can also act as great detention and retention areas for flood water,” he said. Unpaving the paved Many people who live in low-lying areas are from disadvantaged communities. They have built their lives around these locations. Goswami looked at this as a political problem: “Instead, why don’t we consider the interim retrofit solutions and make them equitable? Flooding often occurs in urban areas because stormwater flows across the city. This water needs to be absorbed locally, ideally in greenbelts or parks, but that is not possible if these areas are heavily walled off. In a 2010 survey, municipal officials identified at least 300 neighbourhoods that did not have issues with sewage discharge, which could have been used for recharging water in local parks. However, according to the MCD official, no action was taken. Ultimately, it has to be a combination of solutions. “The CSE study in Sangam Vihar –– Delhi’s largest unauthorised settlement, housing an estimated one million people, confirmed the need for a blend of grey and green-blue infrastructure under a decentralised water supply, wastewater and stormwater management. If we want to address equity and justice, then we must prioritise the deficits in our dense unplanned settlements,” insisted Kapur, who authored the study in his previous role at the Centre for Science and Environment.
