Fact Check: CSE Report Warning Of Cancer Risk From Bread Dates Back To 2016, Misleadingly Shared As Recent
A 2016 news bulletin based on CSE’s study is being shared with a misleading claim, claiming it to be recent. The CSE report from 2016 stated that 84% of tested samples contained harmful chemicals like potassium bromate and iodate, which are classified as potential cancer-causing agents. A video clip from Hindi news channel Aaj Tak’s bulletin is being widely shared across social media platforms. In this clip, Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) is cited as stating that 84% of tested samples failed quality checks, revealing the presence of harmful chemicals like potassium bromate and iodate, both linked to serious diseases, such as cancer. The video clip’s continuous circulation in recent days has led many to believe it is a recent report. In its investigation, Vishvas News found this claim to be misleading. The viral video is not recent but dates back to 2016, when CSE published a report stating that traces of potassium bromate/iodate were found in the bread sold in Delhi. The report classified potassium bromate as a category 2B carcinogen (potentially cancer-causing), which is banned in many countries. However, it is still used in India. What is viral? Social media user ‘GK Bohra Parthasarathy‘ shared the viral video clip with the caption, “The bread which is sold in the name of pav roti, double roti is so dangerous, please be careful.” Many other users across different social media platforms have also shared this video clip with similar claims. Investigation A keyword search led us to the original report, published on Aaj Tak’s official YouTube channel in 2016. This report, dated May 24, 2016, is based on a study by the CSE, which claimed that traces of potassium bromate, potassium iodate or both were found in 84% of bread and bakery samples collected from Delhi. According to the report, potassium iodate can lead to thyroid issues, increasing the risk of autoimmune thyroiditis and elevating the risk of cancer. Following this report, the government ordered an investigation. The then Health Minister JP Nadda acknowledged the report and urged the people not to panic. He directed the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) to take necessary to take appropriate action. The report also includes a statement from Chandra Bhushan, the then head of CSE, but is no longer associated with CSE. According to a Hindustan Times news report dated September 20, 2019, he resigned after 22 years from CSE. According to his LinkedIn profile, Chandra Bhushan is currently the Chief Executive Officer of the International Forum for Environment Sustainability and Technology (iFOREST). During our investigation, we found the original study report on the CSE website, published on May 23, 2016. Based on this report, many news organisations covered its findings at that time. You can find the related news reports here. On May 26, 2016, The Times of India reported that the then All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) director, MC Mishra, addressed concerns over the presence of potassium bromate and potassium iodate in bread. He stated, “There may be some risk in it, but nobody eats a whole packet of bread every day…most people eat one or two loaves of bread every day, so there is no need to worry about it in the long run, as FSSAI has also said.” We contacted India Today Fact Check’s Executive Editor Bal Krishna regarding the viral video clip. He confirmed that this report dates back to 2016. Additionally, an analysis of the profile that shared the viral video suggests that the content aligns with a specific ideology. Conclusion: A 2016 news bulletin based on CSE’s study is being shared with a misleading claim, claiming it to be recent. The CSE report from 2016 stated that 84% of tested samples contained harmful chemicals like potassium bromate and iodate, which are classified as potential cancer-causing agents.
