Cse In News

World’s record heat is worsening air pollution and health in Global South

n fact, 2023 and 2024 may well be the hottest years in 100,000 years, with all indicators pointing to it getting hotter, bringing ever-worsening global impacts. “The temperature-related extreme events witnessed [last Norther Hemisphere] summer will only become more intense,” warned Samantha Burgess, deputy director of the Copernicus Climate Change Service. In 2024, extreme heat enveloped whole regions of the world for weeks on end, with severe unprecedented consequences. A deadly heat wave killed at least 1,300 people during the annual Hajj pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia, while the worst drought in a century gripped Southern Africa, leaving 21 million children malnourished. Record drought also devastated South America, reducing Amazon rivers to their lowest levels ever recorded. North America wasn’t spared either. Heat domes — stalled high pressure systems that retain and intensify temperatures — blanketed vast parts of the U.S. and killed more than 100 people in Mexico. But less noticed, and harder to track, is the way in which oppressive heat helps degrade air quality, making people sick. While air pollution sources are typically local or regional, the invisible hand of climate change is further deteriorating air quality around the planet. Stubbornly persistent heat waves, record wildfires, and drastically changing wind and precipitation patterns all “alter the formation, duration and dispersion of air pollution,” notes a World Meteorological Organization bulletin, highlighting the synergistic health effects of global warming. The Global South, an epicenter of poor air quality, is being especially hard hit. A toxic soup of air pollutants — automotive exhaust fumes over urban India, choking dust clouds blowing across Nigeria, and suffocating wildfire smoke blanketing Brazil — are being made even deadlier by a rapidly destabilizing climate. 2024 was the first year in history seeing an average global temperature rising 1.5° Celsius (2.7° Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial levels. Ozone over New Delhi The summer of 2024 in India’s capital, New Delhi, was more brutal than any Kunal Kumar can remember. The city was trapped under the longest heat wave in 13 years. Things were so bad that Kumar, a gig worker who makes food deliveries, was forced some days to give up his outdoor income. “Better to lose my wages and stay at home than die of a heatstroke,” he said. Delhi, a sprawling city in northern India, is nestled in the country’s Indo-Gangetic Plain where summer daytime temperatures average 32°C (90°F). But a series of persistent anticyclonic wind circulation events over the northern Indian Ocean, coupled with the fading El Niño, caused clockwise wind gusts to sink over the city, creating a persistent high-pressure heat dome that pushed 2024 temperatures to relentless highs. For weeks, brutal daytime temperatures stayed above 40°C (104°F), with little respite by night. The city’s solar heat-absorbing built environment made conditions even more miserable and dangerous. For Kumar, who spends 12 to 15 hours a day on the road making deliveries, the heat was life-threatening — as it was for the rest of the city’s 33.8 million people, many of whom work outside or lack air-conditioning. In Kumar’s cramped South Delhi neighborhood, heat radiated off the walls and street day and night in a textbook example of the urban heat island effect. He was dehydrated and irritable most days. “Everywhere you look there’s a traffic jam in this city. Stuck in jams, under the hot sun with hot air blowing on your body; it was unbearable,” Kumar remembers. Normally, air pollution is perceived as a winter problem in Delhi, when a thick blanket of low-altitude smog gets trapped by cool air hanging above the metropolis. That smog is mostly composed of toxic PM2.5 particulates — very tiny particles that lodge in the lungs and can cause cardiovascular and respiratory disease. Every winter, PM2.5 levels peak due to seasonal crop burning and the exploding of fireworks during the Diwali festival, turning Delhi into one of the world’s most polluted places. But now, as global warming and urban development bring higher temperatures over the city in summer, the co-occurring impacts of intense heat and air pollution compound in less obvious but seriously unhealthful ways. In hot summer months, the traffic jams Kumar and thousands of gig workers are stalled in every day become hotspots for toxins that include PM2.5 particulates and ground-level ozone. High up in the stratosphere, ozone plays a vital beneficial role, absorbing the sun’s harmful ultraviolet rays. But close to Earth’s surface, it’s a potent air pollutant whose insidious health impacts accrue in the body. Ground-level ozone is formed when nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), emitted from vehicle exhausts and other combustion sources such as factories, react with sunlight. A recent analysis by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), a Delhi-based think tank, found that new hotspots for ground-level ozone emerged across the city over the summer. Between April and July 2024, Delhi recorded ground-level ozone readings in excess of safe limits on 102 days, often for more than 13 hours at a stretch, the analysis said. Annual PM2.5 background levels have also risen steadily, driven predominantly by an increase in transportation emissions — traffic that now worsens air pollution in winter and drives ground-level ozone in summer. Epidemiologist Poornima Prabhakaran, director of the Centre for Health Analytics Research and Trends at Ashoka University, calls the increasing ground-level ozone trend worrying. India has the highest death burden of any nation from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, attributable to ground-level ozone levels, according to the “State of Global Air” report published annually by U.S.-based Health Effects Institute in partnership with UNICEF; ozone killed 238,000 people in India in 2019. People also continue breathing other toxic contaminants released from tailpipes and smokestacks. But “The impacts of [these] secondary pollutants have not been given as much attention compared to the impacts of smog and PM2.5, probably because of lack of awareness,” Prabhakaran said. Prabhakaran is working with scientists internationally, developing databases to track the impacts of air pollution (including PM2.5 and ozone) on a variety of outcomes, such as respiratory and cognitive health functions. “We’re trying to analyze, with data, every health outcome that we can get our hands on,” Prabhakaran said, adding, “Intermediate risk factors like hypertension, high blood pressure, fasting glucose, high lipid levels — all of those cardiovascular outcomes — are known to worsen with even chronic, low-dose [air pollution] exposure.” Clean air programs have largely failed to improve air quality in India because they’ve been incentivized for dust control, rather than reducing transport and industrial combustion — the biggest sources of contaminants year round. “Our programs need to become more multipollutant-focused, which means taking a whole basket of pollutants [into consideration] like PM2.5, nitrous oxides, and ozone, to track improvements in air quality. Not just the level of dust in the air,” said Anumita Roychowdhary, CSE’s executive director of research and advocacy. Outdoor workers like Kumar remain very vulnerable to impacts due to their extensive exposure. The Indian government views the booming gig economy positively as an employment generator, at a time when unemployment rates have reached record highs. But those jobs often come at a considerable cost to workers’ long-term health. “I try not to take days off, even when I’m sick, because it slashes my earnings,” said Kumar. But breathing Delhi’s toxic soup day in and day out could bring on disease and early death. There’s also an economic cost. Gig workers are often primary family breadwinners, laboring without insurance or paid medical leave. A survey of 10,384 app-based workers across India conducted by the People’s Association in Grassroots Action and Movements and the University of Pennsylvania found that nearly 100% of respondents said they suffered physical and mental health issues due to gig work. Around 43% earned less than 500 rupees ($5.80) a day, and a similar proportion said they took no days off. “Companies hiring us should be more humane with benefits, wages and time off,” said Kumar, adding, “We work through the rain, through the heat.” It’s heat that scientists say will only intensify in coming years. Last year, Ewésh Yawalapiti Waurá says he watched helplessly as drought shrank away the life-giving waters of the river near his native village in Xingu Indigenous Park. Flowing through Brazil’s Amazon Rainforest, the Xingu River and its tributaries are vital to the territory’s 16 Indigenous groups. But drought wasn’t the only challenge faced by residents in 2024: As the river receded below, thick plumes of choking smoke hung overhead, the result of raging wildfires described as the worst the region has seen in recent years. Xingu Indigenous Park is located where the Amazon Rainforest biome transitions to the tropical Cerrado savanna biome in the central Brazilian state of Mato Grosso. The park, a protected area, was created in 1961 to preserve Indigenous culture and natural biodiversity. Waurá is the executive director of the Xingu Indigenous Land Association (ATIX), a group formed in 1994 to defend the rights of Indigenous peoples living in the Xingu region. But how, does one protect the people from deadly wildfire smoke? In the past, “it was easy to control the fire[s]. Today any fire gets out of control, spreads out; it’s difficult to control,” Waurá told Mongabay in a video interview. More than 200 firefighters from IBAMA, Brazil’s environmental agency, were sent to douse fires in the Xingu territory last year, with more volunteers joining them in “full force.” But the blazes remained “really out of control,” Waurá said. The local landscape has changed dramatically in recent years, Waurá added. Climate change and deforestation for agribusiness expansion have combined to dry out the region, destroying the remaining rainforest’s ability to resist fire. Dust over Nigeria’s Kano In the commercial city of Kano, Nigeria, dust is a daily part of life. “Kano is very hot. Even when there is power and the fan is running, we find it very difficult to sleep in the room [at night] due to the heat, especially during the dry season,” Zahara Usaini, a small-scale trader and 32-year-old mother of three, told Mongabay. Located in the arid, northern part of Nigeria, Kano’s surrounding landscape is dominated by savanna grasslands. In the past, temperatures there typically rose only as high as 33°C (91°F). But last year, they reached new records — hitting 39°C (102°F), and even 41°C (106°F) in places. A prolonged heat wave, made 10 times more likely due to the effects of climate change, swept the region in 2024. “The hotness of every dry season is increasing each year. I think it’s from God,” Usaini said. She felt anxious as she waited at Khalifa Sheikh Isyaku Rabiu Pediatric Hospital, where her youngest child, Hauwa, had been admitted. Hauwa, just 3 years old, had developed a fever that the family initially mistook as a malaria symptom. But when she didn’t respond to treatment by a local hospital, and started to convulse and lose consciousness, Hauwa was transferred to Khalifa and given the correct diagnosis: meningitis.

ग्रीन स्कूलों की श्रेणी में सोलन ने फिर मारी बाजी, शिमला दूसरे और जिला बिलासपुर रहा तीसरे स्थान पर

प्रदेश भर में सोलन ने फिर एक बार ग्रीन स्कूल में पहला स्थान प्राप्त किया है। शिमला दूसरे और बिलासपुर तीसरे स्थान पर रहा है। विज्ञान एवं पर्यावरण केंद्र (सेंटर फॉर साइंस एंड एनवायरमेंट) नई दिल्ली की ओर से वर्ष 2024-25 के लिए यह प्रमाणिता जारी की है। सोलन 11 स्कूल ग्रीन श्रेणी में प्रमाणित किए गए हैं। प्रदेश भर से 1,322 स्कूलों ने ग्रीन स्कूल के लिए अपना पंजीकरण किया था। Himachal : ग्रीन स्कूलों की श्रेणी में सोलन ने फिर मारी बाजी, शिमला दूसरे और जिला बिलासपुर रहा तीसरे स्थान पर संवाद न्यूज एजेंसी, सोलन। Published by: अंकेश डोगरा Updated Fri, 17 Jan 2025 02:00 AM IST सार 37289 Followers शिमला विज्ञान एवं पर्यावरण केंद्र की ओर से पर्यावरण ऑडिट के आधार पर सोलन के 11 और शिमला के 6 स्कूलों को ग्रीन श्रेणी में प्रमाणित किया गया है। Himachal Solan again won in the category of green schools Shimla second and district Bilaspur third सांकेतिक तस्वीर। - फोटो : अमर उजाला नेटवर्क Reactions 1 विस्तार Follow Us प्रदेश भर में सोलन ने फिर एक बार ग्रीन स्कूल में पहला स्थान प्राप्त किया है। शिमला दूसरे और बिलासपुर तीसरे स्थान पर रहा है। विज्ञान एवं पर्यावरण केंद्र (सेंटर फॉर साइंस एंड एनवायरमेंट) नई दिल्ली की ओर से वर्ष 2024-25 के लिए यह प्रमाणिता जारी की है। सोलन 11 स्कूल ग्रीन श्रेणी में प्रमाणित किए गए हैं। प्रदेश भर से 1,322 स्कूलों ने ग्रीन स्कूल के लिए अपना पंजीकरण किया था। Trending Videos Advertisement: 0:11 Close Player उपनिदेशक प्रारंभिक शिक्षा सोलन मोहिंद्र चंद पिरटा ने बताया कि सोलन से 300 स्कूलों ने ग्रीन स्कूल के पंजीकरण किया था। जबकि 101 स्कूलों ने जीएसपी वेबसाइट पर अपलोड किए गए थे। इसमें से विज्ञान एवं पर्यावरण केंद्र की ओर से पर्यावरण ऑडिट के आधार पर सोलन के 11 और शिमला के 6 स्कूलों को ग्रीन श्रेणी में प्रमाणित किया गया है। राजकीय छात्र वरिष्ठ माध्यमिक पाठशाला नालागढ़, राजकीय वरिष्ठ माध्यमिक पाठशाला मंझोली, बघेरी, भाटिया, बोहली, राजकीय उच्च विद्यालय कनाह, केंद्रीय विद्यालय एयर फोर्स स्टेशन कसौली, पाइनग्रोव स्कूल धर्मपुर, इंटरनेशनल स्कूल कसौली, शिवालिक वैली स्कूल नालागढ़ और राजकीय प्राथमिक पाठशाला जलाणा ग्रीन श्रेणी में शामिल किए गए हैं। ग्रीन श्रेणी में सम्मिलित स्कूलों के प्रधानाचार्य, मुख्याध्यापक, अध्यापक और दो स्कूली बच्चों को 4 फरवरी को इंडिया हैबिटेट सेंटर लोधी रोड में सम्मानित किया जाएगा। दिसंबर में प्रदेश के सभी स्कूलों का विवरण दिया गया था जिसमें जिला सोलन से 101 स्कूलों की रिपोर्ट अपलोड की गई थी। ग्रीन श्रेणी चयन के लिए इन स्कूलों के प्रोजेक्टों को बेहतर काम करने के आधार पर ऑरेंज, येलो और ग्रीन प्रमाण दिए जाते हैं। उप निदेशक उच्च शिक्षा गोपाल चौहान, उप जिला शिक्षा अधिकारी राज कुमार पराशर और जिला विज्ञान पर्यवेक्षक अमरीश शर्मा ने ग्रीन श्रेणी में चयनित स्कूलों को बधाई दी। ग्रीन स्कूल के लिए प्रदेश भर से 1322 स्कूलों ने ऑनलाइन पंजीकरण किया था, लेकिन इसमें सिर्फ 291 स्कूलों ने ही अपने प्रोजेक्ट को अपलोड किया है। जिसके आधार पर स्कूलों का ऑडिट किया गया है।

Stop Blaming Punjab And Haryana Farmersfor Delhi’s Strangulating Toxic Air Levels

Forseveral years now, farmers from the north western region of the country -- Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and parts of western Uttar Pradesh -- have been continuously battered for chocking Delhi’s air. As if farm fires were the real reason behind the capitals toxic air in the months of October and November, when the period of still air over New Delhi coincides with the harvesting of paddy crop, no effort was spared to iron out the menace, rue farmers. Every paddy harvest season, with the media shrill rising in crescendo as harvesting progressed, farmers were on the receiving end for pollution Delhi’s already toxic air. In a magnificent cover-up for its own undoing over the years, simply to absolve itself of any responsibility, New Delhi found it very convenient to shift the blame on farmers – painting them as the true villain of the story. But on June 4, media reports say that in a presentation before the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) had a different story to tell. Quoting a January 2023 report of The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI), the PM’s Advisor Tarun Kapoor was told that burning of agricultural residues had contributed only one per cent to PM 2.5 to PM 10 air pollution levels in Delhi. In an era where transparency and accountability are the hallmark of governance, if what was said is true, and I see no reason for not believing in what has been put on record, the best that New Delhi can do is to stand up, accept the fault and apologise to the farmers. The bureaucracy, numerous expert committees, and the national media (both print and electronic) too must accept responsibility for spreading misinformation. After all, these institutions had collectively defamed the farming community for no fault of theirs as is now clearly evident. When I say ‘no fault of theirs’, I am not trying to defend the harmful practice of stubble burning. The disadvantages of stubble burning and its effect on the environment and human health are well acknowledged. All efforts should surely be made, and that includes creating wider awareness and providing affordable solutions, to turn stubble burning into history. But what is simply not acceptable is that in the search of a scapegoat, farmers, who being unorganised, come in handy for repeated bashing. Farmers provide a smokescreen to hide New Delhi’s glaring contribution to polluting its own air. Shifting the needle of suspicion to farmers therefore became the most effective deflector. This had helped in building an army of abusive trolls on social media, who not only excelled in casting aspersions on farmers, but went to the extent of accusing them for deriving sadistic pleasure so as to pollute Delhi’s ‘clean’ air. Because of continuous farmer bashing, the Supreme Court came down heavily against the ‘erring’ farmers. As a result, by October 21, 2024, Punjab had registered 874 FIRs, 471 daily dairy reports (DDR), red entries were made in the revenue records of 394 farmers and penalties to the tune of Rs. 10.55-lakh were imposed on 371 farmers. In Haryana, by the same date, 400 farmers were blacklisted barring them for selling their crops in mandis for two years, while 18 were arrested in Kaithal district in just two days. In November, another 32 farmers were arrested in Yamunanagar. Such draconian measures were termed as ‘Tughlaki firman’ by the opposition parties. Interestingly, it is the same CAQM on whose reports the apex court had directed the police in Punjab and Haryana to initiate criminal prosecution against farmers who indulge in farm fires, now acknowledges that farmers in north-west parts of the country had contributed only one per cent to Delhi’s air. This is what had prompted, as per media reports, the well-known Haryana bureaucrat, Ashok Khemka, a 1991 batch IAS officer, to write to the Haryana Chief Minister urging him to declare that given what was presented before PMO by the CAQM Chairman the other day, it is quite clear that farmers in Punjab and Haryana are not responsible for adding to Delhi’s air pollution. The Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) had also shown that despite a significant drop by 71.2 per cent in stubble fires during October-December 2024, Delhi’s PM 2.5 levels had risen for the second consecutive year in 2024. And given the fact that farm fires had practically no role to play, New Delhi cannot any more hide behind Punjab fires. Further it is important to know that while the number of farm fires in Punjab and Haryana have come down as evident from the CSE study, stubble burning incidents on the other hand have multiplied in Madhya Pradesh and are even spreading to Chhattisgarh. Everyone loves to heap blame on farmers. In one of my earlier columns (SUVs and not farmers responsible for the scary air pollution levels, in Bizz Buzz, Oct 25, 2024) my argument was that given that every fourth car on the street being an SUV, and with their numbers continuously rising, these monster cars spew 20 per cent more carbon emissions than a mid-size car. It is time to clamp down on the SUVs but the problem is that every member of the elite society wants to flaunt his newly-acquired SUV as a status symbol. Yes, it is true that air pollution levels are different from carbon emissions (says an AI search), but they are closely linked. Being two sides of the same coin, air pollution also includes greenhouse gases like carbon dioxide, as well as other pollutants like methane, nitrous oxide and others. Coming back to stubble burning, the time has come to stop blaming Punjab and Haryana farmers for Delhi’s strangulating toxic air levels and instead shift the focus on managing its own air quality norms. While I don’t deny that some measures have been taken over the years but a lot more certainly needs to be done, including some tough decisions. This can only happen if Delhi residents are first made to realise that they themselves are responsible for the worsening air levels they are living with.

Sunita Narain: “Reality and Perseverance in India: Pollution, Poverty, and Policy”

It is an unfortunate reality that the countries least responsible for the climate and ecological crises we face are often the ones most vulnerable to their effects today and in the future. India – with its population of 1.4 billion, rapidly rising temperatures, and limited resources compared to many developed nations – finds itself at the crossroads of these challenges. What do India’s leading scientists and advocates have to say about coping with these extreme pressures? In this episode, Nate is joined by environmentalist and policy advocate Sunita Narain to discuss the intricate relationship between environmental issues and development, emphasizing the need for economically inclusive solutions. She highlights India’s challenges with sanitation, urban mobility, and climate change, while pushing for wiser approaches to governance and community planning. How can the moral and cultural history of India combine with science and innovation to guide policy making decisions? Why does ‘sustainable development’ need to go beyond environmental considerations to include the economic availability for each nation’s poorest citizens? And perhaps most importantly, how could today’s challenges position India as a global leader in creating an economic system that prioritizes the health and well-being of all life on Earth? About Sunita Narain Sunita Narain has worked at the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), a research and advocacy centre based in New Delhi, since 1982. She is currently Executive Director of the Centre, Treasurer of the Society for Environmental Communications and Editor of the bi-monthly magazine Down To Earth. She is a writer and environmentalist who uses knowledge for change. In 2005, she was awarded the Padma Shri, the fourth-highest civilian award of the Republic of India. She has also received the World Water Prize for her work on rainwater harvesting and for her political influence in developing paradigms for community water management. In 2005, she also chaired the Tiger Task Force, at the request of the Prime Minister, to develop a conservation action plan for the country after the loss of the tigers in Sariska. Sunita Narain was a member of the Prime Minister’s Council on Climate Change as well as the National Ganga River Basin Authority.

How are ‘heat domes’ hurting our health?

Humanity achieved a fateful milestone last year. The European Union’s Copernicus Climate Change Service has officially declared 2024 the hottest year on record, and the first year in history with an average global temperature rising 1.5° Celsius (2.7° Fahrenheit) above the pre-industrial period — significantly increasing dangerous climate risks. In fact, 2023 and 2024 may well be the hottest years in 100,000 years, with all indicators pointing to it getting hotter, bringing ever-worsening global impacts. “The temperature-related extreme events witnessed [last Norther Hemisphere] summer will only become more intense,” warned Samantha Burgess, deputy director of the Copernicus Climate Change Service. In 2024, extreme heat enveloped whole regions of the world for weeks on end, with severe unprecedented consequences. A deadly heat wave killed at least 1,300 people during the annual Hajj pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia, while the worst drought in a century gripped Southern Africa, leaving 21 million children malnourished. Record drought also devastated South America, reducing Amazon rivers to their lowest levels ever recorded. North America wasn’t spared either. Heat domes — stalled high pressure systems that retain and intensify temperatures — blanketed vast parts of the U.S. and killed more than 100 people in Mexico. But less noticed, and harder to track, is the way in which oppressive heat helps degrade air quality, making people sick. While air pollution sources are typically local or regional, the invisible hand of climate change is further deteriorating air quality around the planet. Stubbornly persistent heat waves, record wildfires, and drastically changing wind and precipitation patterns all “alter the formation, duration and dispersion of air pollution,” notes a World Meteorological Organization bulletin, highlighting the synergistic health effects of global warming. The Global South, an epicenter of poor air quality, is being especially hard hit. A toxic soup of air pollutants — automotive exhaust fumes over urban India, choking dust clouds blowing across Nigeria, and suffocating wildfire smoke blanketing Brazil — are being made even deadlier by a rapidly destabilizing climate. 2024 was the first year in history seeing an average global temperature rising 1.5° Celsius (2.7° Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial levels, as confirmed by the European Union’s Copernicus Climate Change Service, the United Nations World Meteorological Organization, and the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Data courtesy of ERAS Copernicus. Ozone over New Delhi The summer of 2024 in India’s capital, New Delhi, was more brutal than any Kunal Kumar can remember. The city was trapped under the longest heat wave in 13 years. Things were so bad that Kumar, a gig worker who makes food deliveries, was forced some days to give up his outdoor income. “Better to lose my wages and stay at home than die of a heatstroke,” he told Mongabay. Delhi, a sprawling city in northern India, is nestled in the country’s Indo-Gangetic Plain where summer daytime temperatures average 32°C (90°F). But a series of persistent anticyclonic wind circulation events over the northern Indian Ocean, coupled with the fading El Niño, caused clockwise wind gusts to sink over the city, creating a persistent high-pressure heat dome that pushed 2024 temperatures to relentless highs. For weeks, brutal daytime temperatures stayed above 40°C (104°F), with little respite by night. The city’s solar heat-absorbing built environment made conditions even more miserable and dangerous. For Kumar, who spends 12 to 15 hours a day on the road making deliveries, the heat was life-threatening — as it was for the rest of the city’s 33.8 million people, many of whom work outside or lack air-conditioning. In Kumar’s cramped South Delhi neighborhood, heat radiated off the walls and street day and night in a textbook example of the urban heat island effect. He was dehydrated and irritable most days. “Everywhere you look there’s a traffic jam in this city. Stuck in jams, under the hot sun with hot air blowing on your body; it was unbearable,” Kumar remembers. Normally, air pollution is perceived as a winter problem in Delhi, when a thick blanket of low-altitude smog gets trapped by cool air hanging above the metropolis. That smog is mostly composed of toxic PM2.5 particulates — very tiny particles that lodge in the lungs and can cause cardiovascular and respiratory disease. Every winter, PM2.5 levels peak due to seasonal crop burning and the exploding of fireworks during the Diwali festival, turning Delhi into one of the world’s most polluted places. But now, as global warming and urban development bring higher temperatures over the city in summer, the co-occurring impacts of intense heat and air pollution compound in less obvious but seriously unhealthful ways. In hot summer months, the traffic jams Kumar and thousands of gig workers are stalled in every day become hotspots for toxins that include PM2.5 particulates and ground-level ozone. High up in the stratosphere, ozone plays a vital beneficial role, absorbing the sun’s harmful ultraviolet rays. But close to Earth’s surface, it’s a potent air pollutant whose insidious health impacts accrue in the body. Ground-level ozone is formed when nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), emitted from vehicle exhausts and other combustion sources such as factories, react with sunlight. A recent analysis by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), a Delhi-based think tank, found that new hotspots for ground-level ozone emerged across the city over the summer. Between April and July 2024, Delhi recorded ground-level ozone readings in excess of safe limits on 102 days, often for more than 13 hours at a stretch, the analysis said. Annual PM2.5 background levels have also risen steadily, driven predominantly by an increase in transportation emissions — traffic that now worsens air pollution in winter and drives ground-level ozone in summer.

Reality and Perseverance in India: Pollution, Poverty, and Policy

It is an unfortunate reality that the countries least responsible for the climate and ecological crises we face are often the ones most vulnerable to their effects today and in the future. India – with its population of 1.4 billion, rapidly rising temperatures, and limited resources compared to many developed nations – finds itself at the crossroads of these challenges. What do India’s leading scientists and advocates have to say about coping with these extreme pressures? In this episode, I’m joined by environmentalist and policy advocate Sunita Narain to discuss the intricate relationship between environmental issues and development, emphasizing the need for economically inclusive solutions. She highlights India’s challenges with sanitation, urban mobility, and climate change, while pushing for wiser approaches to governance and community planning. How can the moral and cultural history of India combine with science and innovation to guide policy making decisions? Why does ‘sustainable development’ need to go beyond environmental considerations to include the economic availability for each nation’s poorest citizens? And perhaps most importantly, how could today’s challenges position India as a global leader in creating an economic system that prioritizes the health and well-being of all life on Earth? https://youtu.be/i_peHBbM7eo

What's making Delhi air deadlier

New Delhi: Delhi’s skies have donned a grim shade of grey. Emissions from vehicles, fumes from industries and smoke from local fires have shrouded the air, choking residents all season. But experts are worried about a bigger problem—the pollutants in Delhi’s air are getting finer and deadlier. The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), the apex air quality monitoring body in India, assesses a city’s pollution levels on the basis of three primary parameters—air quality index or AQI (a 24-hour average of major pollutants), PM10 (coarse particulate matter usually comprising dust), and PM2.5 (ultrafine particles typically released through combustion). However, these might not be providing an accurate picture of how dangerous the city’s air is. Research studies and environmentalists warn that while sources of pollution in Delhi-NCR have largely remained the same over the last few years—stubble fires, vehicular emissions, waste burning and industrial emissions—pollution particles are reducing in size.

World’s record heat is worsening air pollution and health in Global South

Humanity achieved a fateful milestone last year. The European Union’s Copernicus Climate Change Service has officially declared 2024 the hottest year on record, and the first year in history with an average global temperature rising 1.5° Celsius (2.7° Fahrenheit) above the pre-industrial period — significantly increasing dangerous climate risks. In fact, 2023 and 2024 may well be the hottest years in 100,000 years, with all indicators pointing to it getting hotter, bringing ever-worsening global impacts. “The temperature-related extreme events witnessed [last Norther Hemisphere] summer will only become more intense,” warned Samantha Burgess, deputy director of the Copernicus Climate Change Service. In 2024, extreme heat enveloped whole regions of the world for weeks on end, with severe unprecedented consequences. A deadly heat wave killed at least 1,300 people during the annual Hajj pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia, while the worst drought in a century gripped Southern Africa, leaving 21 million children malnourished. Record drought also devastated South America, reducing Amazon rivers to their lowest levels ever recorded. North America wasn’t spared either. Heat domes — stalled high pressure systems that retain and intensify temperatures — blanketed vast parts of the U.S. and killed more than 100 people in Mexico. But less noticed, and harder to track, is the way in which oppressive heat helps degrade air quality, making people sick. While air pollution sources are typically local or regional, the invisible hand of climate change is further deteriorating air quality around the planet. Stubbornly persistent heat waves, record wildfires, and drastically changing wind and precipitation patterns all “alter the formation, duration and dispersion of air pollution,” notes a World Meteorological Organization bulletin, highlighting the synergistic health effects of global warming. The Global South, an epicenter of poor air quality, is being especially hard hit. A toxic soup of air pollutants — automotive exhaust fumes over urban India, choking dust clouds blowing across Nigeria, and suffocating wildfire smoke blanketing Brazil — are being made even deadlier by a rapidly destabilizing climate. Ozone over New Delhi The summer of 2024 in India’s capital, New Delhi, was more brutal than any Kunal Kumar can remember. The city was trapped under the longest heat wave in 13 years. Things were so bad that Kumar, a gig worker who makes food deliveries, was forced some days to give up his outdoor income. “Better to lose my wages and stay at home than die of a heatstroke,” he told Mongabay. Delhi, a sprawling city in northern India, is nestled in the country’s Indo-Gangetic Plain where summer daytime temperatures average 32°C (90°F). But a series of persistent anticyclonic wind circulation events over the northern Indian Ocean, coupled with the fading El Niño, caused clockwise wind gusts to sink over the city, creating a persistent high-pressure heat dome that pushed 2024 temperatures to relentless highs. For weeks, brutal daytime temperatures stayed above 40°C (104°F), with little respite by night. The city’s solar heat-absorbing built environment made conditions even more miserable and dangerous. For Kumar, who spends 12 to 15 hours a day on the road making deliveries, the heat was life-threatening — as it was for the rest of the city’s 33.8 million people, many of whom work outside or lack air-conditioning. In Kumar’s cramped South Delhi neighborhood, heat radiated off the walls and street day and night in a textbook example of the urban heat island effect. He was dehydrated and irritable most days. “Everywhere you look there’s a traffic jam in this city. Stuck in jams, under the hot sun with hot air blowing on your body; it was unbearable,” Kumar remembers. Normally, air pollution is perceived as a winter problem in Delhi, when a thick blanket of low-altitude smog gets trapped by cool air hanging above the metropolis. That smog is mostly composed of toxic PM2.5 particulates — very tiny particles that lodge in the lungs and can cause cardiovascular and respiratory disease. Every winter, PM2.5 levels peak due to seasonal crop burning and the exploding of fireworks during the Diwali festival, turning Delhi into one of the world’s most polluted places. But now, as global warming and urban development bring higher temperatures over the city in summer, the co-occurring impacts of intense heat and air pollution compound in less obvious but seriously unhealthful ways. In hot summer months, the traffic jams Kumar and thousands of gig workers are stalled in every day become hotspots for toxins that include PM2.5 particulates and ground-level ozone. High up in the stratosphere, ozone plays a vital beneficial role, absorbing the sun’s harmful ultraviolet rays. But close to Earth’s surface, it’s a potent air pollutant whose insidious health impacts accrue in the body. Ground-level ozone is formed when nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), emitted from vehicle exhausts and other combustion sources such as factories, react with sunlight. A recent analysis by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), a Delhi-based think tank, found that new hotspots for ground-level ozone emerged across the city over the summer. Between April and July 2024, Delhi recorded ground-level ozone readings in excess of safe limits on 102 days, often for more than 13 hours at a stretch, the analysis said. Annual PM2.5 background levels have also risen steadily, driven predominantly by an increase in transportation emissions — traffic that now worsens air pollution in winter and drives ground-level ozone in summer. Epidemiologist Poornima Prabhakaran, director of the Centre for Health Analytics Research and Trends at Ashoka University, calls the increasing ground-level ozone trend worrying. India has the highest death burden of any nation from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, attributable to ground-level ozone levels, according to the “State of Global Air” report published annually by U.S.-based Health Effects Institute in partnership with UNICEF; ozone killed 238,000 people in India in 2019. People also continue breathing other toxic contaminants released from tailpipes and smokestacks. But “The impacts of [these] secondary pollutants have not been given as much attention compared to the impacts of smog and PM2.5, probably because of lack of awareness,” Prabhakaran said. Prabhakaran is working with scientists internationally, developing databases to track the impacts of air pollution (including PM2.5 and ozone) on a variety of outcomes, such as respiratory and cognitive health functions. “We’re trying to analyze, with data, every health outcome that we can get our hands on,” Prabhakaran said, adding, “Intermediate risk factors like hypertension, high blood pressure, fasting glucose, high lipid levels — all of those cardiovascular outcomes — are known to worsen with even chronic, low-dose [air pollution] exposure.”

Unfair to blame Haryana & Punjab farmers for Delhi’s severe pollution: Ashok Khemka

Additional chief secretary Ashok Khemka has defended farmers in a note to CM Nayab Singh Saini and chief secretary Vivek Joshi, saying that while burning ‘parali' (paddy residue) negatively affects air quality and should be stopped, it is unfair to hold crop growers of Punjab and Haryana responsible for Delhi's severe air pollution. The senior IAS officer, who is ACS transport, referred to a video conference of Jan 4 under the chairmanship of the PM's advisor, Tarun Kapoor, in which the chairman of Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) made a presentation on the subject. The presentation was based on a Jan 2023 report by The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI), which said agricultural residue burning contributes 1% to PM 2.5 and PM10 levels in Delhi. This finding was displayed in a slide labeled ‘Sectoral Contribution of Sources of NCR to Particulate Matter'. Khemka's note, titled ‘Management of Air Pollution in NCR', was sent on Jan 10. According to the TERI report Khemka referred to, road dust contributes 42% to PM10 levels in Delhi annually while transport contributes 25%. Transport accounts for 47% of PM 2.5 emissions and road dust 20%. There is a higher contribution of dust sources to PM10 in summer (38-42%) compared to winter (23-31%). It's the same for PM 2.5 (31-34% in summer to 15% in winter). Why annual data doesn't give a clear picture However, while the ACS stresses the importance of having a strategy to contain vehicular pollution, farm fire emissions cannot be compared to vehicular or any other pollution source that is an all-year phenomenon. Farm fires are seasonal, happening within a window between Sept 1 and Nov 30. So, their share in an annual metric will always be small. Besides, during the peak season for farm fires, their share in the capital's pollution levels are much, much higher than 1%. According to the Decision Support System (DSS) for air quality management in Delhi, which has been used to monitor the contribution of farm fires to the capital's PM 2.5 levels, stubble burning's contribution touched 35% on Nov 1 last year. Every winter, air quality in Delhi-NCR plummets to hazardous levels as the airshed fills up with toxic haze which is triggered by a combination of pollutants, fog, lack of winds and other meteorological factors. Farm fires, commonly seen in north India's agricultural belt to clear tracts of land for another round of sowing after the paddy harvest, become a major compounding factor when added to local sources. Shubhansh Tiwari, research associate at Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), told TOI: "Agricultural residue burning's overall contribution is small compared to other sources as it occurs for a limited period. The issue needs to be addressed because, during the 45 days when farmers clear their fields, meteorological conditions carry the smoke into NCR. Nevertheless, road dust and vehicular emissions remain primary contributors to particulate matter in Delhi-NCR and effective management of these sources, especially during the summer months when dust levels are higher, is crucial for improving air quality. So what we need is a holistic approach that addresses all significant pollution sources."

Air pollution may contribute to almost a quarter of deaths in India

Particulate pollution is killing millions more people in India every year than previously thought, a new study reveals. This type of pollution could potentially be responsible for almost a quarter of deaths in the country. The research focuses on the health effects of particles smaller than 2.5µm in diameter – PM2.5. The researchers examined the link between PM2.5 particles and mortality between 2009 and 2019 in 655 out of 787 districts of India and found every person in the country was exposed to high levels of this type of pollution. The study highlights that the entire population of India is currently exposed to PM2.5 levels that exceed those recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO). According to the WHO, the annual average PM 2.5 concentration should not exceed 5µg/m3 and the 24-hour average exposure should not exceed 15µg/m3. In several Indian regions annual average PM2.5 levels reached 119µg/m3 – much higher than both Indian and WHO recommended safe limits. The international team of researchers found that every 10µg/m3 increase in annual average PM2.5 led to an 8.6% increase in mortality. The results show that around 3.8 million deaths, amounting to 5% of total mortality over the period, can be linked to air pollution levels above India’s own PM2.5 guidelines of 40µg/m3, which are themselves eight times higher than the WHO’s. When compared with the much more stringent WHO guidelines of 5µg/m3, 16.6 million deaths annually could be attributed to air pollution – almost 25% of all mortality during the study period. In contrast, a comprehensive global study of disease burden in 2019 attributed just under 1 million deaths to air pollution in India. ‘The results show that current guidelines in India are not sufficient to protect health. Stricter regulations and measures to reduce emissions are of utmost importance,’ said Petter Ljungman, co-author and researcher at the Institute of Environmental Medicine at the Karolinska Institute. ‘Our study provides evidence that can be used to create better air quality policies, both in India and globally.’ The Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) in India recently released its annual assessment and reported that ‘the annual PM2.5 concentration [in Delhi] has increased to 104.7µg/m³ in 2024 – a 3.4% rise from 2023 and this is more than twice the national ambient air quality standard of 40µg/m³’. The citywide winter air pollution peak for 2024 soared to 732μg/m³, 26% higher than last year’s peak of 580μg/m³. ‘This cannot be seen as an annual aberration due to meteorological factors and the consistent rise indicates the impact of growing pollution in the region,’ says Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director, research and advocacy at CSE. Traditionally, burning of farm stubble residues has been blamed for PM2.5 pollution in north India but the CSE analysis indicates that there has been a very significant decline in stubble fires in recent years. In 2024, the total annual fire counts in Delhi, Punjab and Haryana declined 37.5%. Punjab, a significant contributor to fire events, recorded a substantial 75% decline during October–December 2024. The trends show much deeper systemic change is required to cut year round emissions from traffic, industry, burning of waste and biomass, construction, solid fuels for cooking and dust sources in Delhi and the surrounding region, says the CSE.

A gentle giant

Our association was uncommon — even unusual. Dr Manmohan Singh, India’s economist prime minister who passed away recently, was cut from the conventional cloth of market economics. Anil Agarwal was a dyed-in-the-wool environmentalist. In 1991, when Manmohan Singh brought India into the liberalised world of de-regulation and opened borders for trade, we were not part of the cheering brigade. For us, the issue was what liberalisation would mean for the environment — our regulatory institutions were fragile and so, would this opening of the economy lead to pollution and degradation? But interestingly, we were not dismissed by Singh, and this is what made him different from his ilk. He engaged with us. This is not to say that he accepted what we said. But he understood that this was a world that he had not considered. He wanted to know more; wanted to understand what could be done to strengthen the systems so that a balance could be found. ‘Balance’ was the operative word. In the mid-1990s, when Anil started the first environmental rating programme for industry, Manmohan Singh agreed to chair the advisory committee. This was our effort, not just to benchmark performance but also to use measuring indicators to push, prod towards business unusual. He did not fuss or flinch at our effort to demand more from industry than meeting regulatory standards. He understood the need for transformative action in a country like India, where natural resources needed for economic growth are scarce and pollution adds to costs that the poor cannot afford. In 2004 when Singh took over as India’s Prime Minister, Anil had tragically passed away and I was now heading the Centre for Science and Environment. I was much younger, much less experienced. But not once did Singh make me feel inadequate. He let me visit him in the Prime Minister’s office — he heard what I had to say on issues ranging from water conservation to climate change. He not only listened but egged me to provide solutions. “What needs to be done” — this was his focus. In 2005, he asked me to chair the committee to review tiger conservation. I was overwhelmed by his trust in me, given that the other committee members were doyens in the field or connected to the powerful conservation lobby of the country. It was a tough time as well. On the one hand, India had lost all tigers in the Sariska Tiger Reserve. So what should be done to repair the conservation agenda? On the other hand, this was also the time when the Forest Rights Act (FRA) was being discussed to restore the historical injustice to tribals so that they would get tenure over the land they inhabited. But this land was forests – and in some cases, also land under national parks and sanctuaries where tiger and other animals roamed. It was a clash of agenda; it was also a class war — conservation versus tribals. Singh, frankly, was caught in between: he respected both sides and did not want to choose one or the other. The balance of both interests is what he sought. I presented the report to Manmohan Singh a few days before the official presentation. I wanted him to understand the agenda for action – particularly the need for an inclusive paradigm of conservation. He understood the stakes and the resistance and asked if I was certain this could be done and if key stakeholders were on board. I told him that it was difficult but not impossible. My request was that the report, called Joining the Dots should be made public as this would build awareness about the agenda and also drive policy change. My fear was that it would be shelved — as is often the fate of many reports. It is to his credit that much action happened for the conservation of tigers; numbers are up and most importantly, we have better counting methods so that it is not pugmarks, but tigers that are being counted. Later, he made me a member of the Prime Minister’s Council on Climate Change and on cleaning Ganga. In all cases, I was never made to believe that I should not express my views, however different from the others in the room. In fact, my positions — as always to push the envelope — were encouraged by him, but with the caveat that the solutions had to be feasible. This is why Manmohan Singh and his particular brand of politics and persona will be missed in our world of extremes. Today, we live in bubbles where we read and hear only the opinions of people we agree with. We have no time for another’s view because it is not in consonance with our position and so irrelevant. Or because it does not fit into the formula of actions that we have been taught will work — the established book of rules. Dr Manmohan Singh also had his pre-proposed ideas; what was in the textbook or his experience. But he opened doors; because he had an openness of thought, driven by his commitment to change. He was a gentle giant that made power good. He used great power for great good. DTE The writer is the Director-General of CSE and editor of DownToEarth. Views expressed are personal

Planners Need to Keep Pace with Changes: Sarada Muraleedharan

In a scenario where changes are happening so fast civic planners need to be agile and keep pace with the changes and come out with sustainable solutions to address multiple challenges, said Sarada Muraleedharan, Chief Secretary, Government of Kerala, here today. She was addressing the valedictory session of the 73rd National Town and Country Planners Conference, organised by the Institute of Town Planners, India (ITPI), with the support of the Local Self Government Department here. The idea of planning needs to move beyond concepts to come to grip with real issues and formulate responses that work on the ground, she said, referring to multiple issues being faced by Kerala society including the waste management. While there is no dearth of master plans that seek to address each critical issue their real test is how effective they are on the ground, she said. Sarada Muraleedharan also distributed the National Best Thesis awards instituted by ITPI for post-graduate, under graduate and female students on the occasion. ITPI president N K Patel, Rajesh PN, Chairman ITPI, Kerala Regional Chapter, Pradeep Kapoor, Coordinator (Techno Admin) ITPI, and Anoop Kumar Srivastava, Vice President ITPI also spoke. The meet, whose focal theme was “Intelligent, Digital Spatial Planning and Governance’, covered a range of live topics relating to urban and country development including technological advancements. Meanwhile, in a technical session on ‘Blue-Green Economy for Resilient Future,’ experts noted that extreme heat affects productivity imposes stress on urban infrastructure and they called for adopting a climate-sensitive urban design for the country and ramping up the heat management policy. Rajneesh Sareen, Programme Director, Sustainable Habitat Programme, CSE, New Delhi, said Indian cities should adopt heat-resilient urban planning and design, integrating green-blue infrastructure and nature-based solutions. Anumita Roychowdhury, Executive Director, CSE, New Delhi; Dr Banhi, Chakraborty, Ex-Faculty, Dept. of Architecture and Planning, IIT Kharagpur; and Dr Reshma Vilasan, Assistant Professor, Nitte School of Architecture, Planning & Design, Bengaluru, also spoke. In another session on ‘Techno-Urbanism,’ VK Paul, Director, School of Planning and Architecture, said it’s the responsibility of the planners to use all the spatial data available to rejuvenate public spaces through designs that comply with human sensibilities. N Sridharan, Former Director, School of Planning and Architecture, Bhopal, planners should address the issue of digital divide across socio economic classes, ages, sex and region while designing spatial governance. KV Abdul Malik, Chief Town planner (Vigilance), Kerala, said data analysis is important for planning. VK Phatak, Former Principal Chief, (Planning Division), MMRDA and Dean Faculty of Planning, CEPT, also attended. In a session on ‘Local Democracy and Spatial Planning in Kerala,’ S M Vijayanand, Former Chief Secretary and Chairperson, Sixth State Finance Commission, Govt. of Kerala, said it is important to strive for a spatial planning where every citizen has the ‘right to city’. Shiji E Chandran, Chief Town Planner, LSGD (Planning), Govt. of Kerala; Jacob Easow, Former Additional Chief Town Planner, Kerala; Dr Ajith Kaliyath, Urban Chair Professor, KILA; Dr Mohammed Firoz, Associate Professor, NIT Calicut; Baiju K, Senior Town Planner (Retd.), Kerala; and Uday Chander, Dy Director, MSRDC, Mumbai, also spoke. ITPI is the premier institution of qualified urban planners in the country, promoting dynamic, inclusive and integrated town and country planning practice, education, research and institutional mechanism for vibrant, sustainable and resilient spatio-economic development of towns, cities and regions.

Time to recalibrate PM-Kusum scheme

The success of Central or State government scheme is judged by their results. Stories of Devki Devi and Sunita Devi, now known as “Solar Didis” from Bihar, are examples. But, it also a reflection of the State’s political economy as well as Centre-State relations. The Pradhan Mantri Kisan Urja Suraksha Evam Utthaan Mahabhiyan (PM-Kusum) Scheme was launched in March 2019 and scaled up last in September 2023 to provide affordable and accessible power to the farmers throughout the country. The main objectives of the scheme was to wean the farm sector from diesel, to provide energy and water security to farmers, enhance their income, and reduce environmental pollution. The scheme has three components: Component ‘A’: Setting up of 10,000 MW of decentralised ground/stilt mounted grid connected solar or other renewable energy based power plants by the farmers on their land; Component ‘B’: Installation of 14 lakh standalone off-grid solar water pumps; Component ‘C’: ‘Solarisation’ of 35 lakh existing grid-connected agriculture pumps and through feeder level solarization (FLS). All three components of the scheme aim to add solar capacity of about 34,800 MW by March 2026 with the total Central financial support of ₹34,422 crore. The story of Solar Didis is what Component C is all about. But, Deviki Devi and Sunita Devi have been beneficiaries of Aga Khan Rural Support Programme (India) and the local government programme, as Bihar didn’t adopt the PM-Kusum Scheme. The State did not want to provide individual solar irrigation projects, and started to solarise the electric grid. Another reason for Bihar not adopting it was that earlier the parties that ruled the State and Centre were not allies. But now things may change. Implementation challenges ‘Implementation Challenges of the PM-Kusum Scheme: Case Studies from selected Indian States’, a report brought out by The Centre for Science and Environment in 2024, pointed out the challenges of the PM-Kusum Scheme and the reason for its slow progress. According to the report, while Component B of the Scheme has seen significant progress, particularly in Haryana, Rajasthan, Maharashtra and Uttar Pradesh, Components A and C have been falling behind. Most implementation efforts have focused on replacing diesel pumps with solar variants, which has brought substantial benefits to farmers. The report had pointed out that a major hurdle was availability of cheap electricity for the farmers which waters down the incentive to switch to solar pumps. It also pointed towards centralisation of the implementing model. It called for decentralisation of the scheme’s implementation; simply put, making use of the field knowledge of local implementing agencies. The report also recommended offering farmers payment options as well as increase in Central assistance. According to the report, the Scheme holds the potential to reduce carbon emissions by 5.2 million tonnes, making its successful implementation crucial for India’s climate action efforts. The data available at the PM-Kusum portal show that as on September 30, 2024, under Component A, total sanctioned Solar Capacity was 9,110 MW and the total installed Solar Capacity was 298.83 MW. Under Component B as on September 30, 2024, total sanctioned standalone pumps were 13,42,327, and total installed standalone pumps were 4,99,319. For Component C as on September 30, 2024, total pump sanctioned for individual pump Solar were 1,71,640, total pump solarised under installed Individual pump solar were 4,759. Total pumps sanctioned for feeder level solar were 33,85,494 and total pumps solarised under feeder level solar were 32,512. Tardy progress Clearly the progress has not been up to the mark and to meet the target some rethinking is required. “For A the progress has been minimal mainly since most of the RE nodal agencies have not promulgated bidding guidelines, there is also no subsidy available under this, the RE agencies which have released guidelines quote feed in tariffs in ₹3-3.30/kwh, which is low without subsidy,” said Arvind Poswal, Programme Officer, Renewable Energy, Centre for Science and Environment. Component B has seen most success since the Central Financial Assistance is almost 60 per cent, also states/regions with concerns on ground water use, irrigation related challenges have witnessed deployment, he said adding that the decentralized approach undertaken by some States has also improved deployment, e.g. Rajasthan where the horticulture department is nodal agency for it. “Wide awareness campaigns by the nodal agencies etc has worked. However, there have been concerns regarding the quality of pumpsets etc,” he added. Under component C, States such as Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan have released guidelines and witnessed traction in deployment. “Since for PM-Kusum we also must examine political economy issues such as subsidies given to the farm sector and the need to offset them via day time solar based power. In other States the progress has been slow. Since the Ministry for New and Renewable Energy has published several implementation guidelines, States must come forward to identify their roadblocks and fasttrack deployment based on their unique individual constraints and see this as an opportunity towards reduction of subsidies for irrigation related electricity subsidies,” he said. The scheme must be seen as an extension towards developing the farm/agriculture sector, the Component A and C can be leveraged towards creating solar based electricity generation via models such as Agro-PV which utilise energy generation and farming in a dual use model, Poswal added. To make it a success and achieve its objectives both the Centre and the States have to work in sync while recalibrating the process of implementation.

Stubble Burning: दिल्ली के वायु प्रदूषण में पराली का योगदान सिर्फ एक फीसदी, अफसर ने कहा दोषी नहीं किसान

आमतौर पर हर साल धान की कटाई के दौरान दिल्ली-एनसीआर इलाके में वायु प्रदुषण एक गंभीर समस्या का रूप लेता है। इस बार भी ऐसा हुआ सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने परली जलने की घटनाओं को रोकने के लिए राज्य सरकारों को आदेश दिए। वहीं, राज्य सरकारों ने परली नहीं जलने के लिए किसानों पर जुर्माने से लेकर पराली नहीं जलने पर प्रोत्साहन योजनाएं भी लांच की थी। लेकिन, वायु गुणवत्ता प्रबंधन आयोग ने प्रधानमंत्री कार्यालय को बताया है कि दिल्ली के प्रदुषण स्तर में पराली जलाने की घटनाएं केवल 1 फीसदी का योगदान देती हैं। इस पर हरियाणा के अतिरिक्त मुख्य सचिव (परिवहन) अशोक खेमका ने कहा कि राजधानी दिल्ली में बिगड़ती वायु गुणवत्ता के लिए पंजाब और हरियाणा के किसानों को जिम्मेदार नहीं ठहराया जा सकता है। नोट में सीएक्यूएम के अध्यक्ष द्वारा ऊर्जा और संसाधन संस्थान (टेरी) की जनवरी 2023 की रिपोर्ट पर भरोसा करने का हवाला दिया गया, जिसमें कहा गया था कि दिल्ली में पीएम 2.5 और पीएम 10 के स्तर में कृषि अवशेष जलाने से केवल 1% का योगदान है। खेमका ने कहा कि पराली जलाना स्थानीय वायु गुणवत्ता के लिए हानिकारक है और इसे रोका जाना चाहिए, लेकिन पंजाब और हरियाणा के किसानों को दिल्ली में खराब होती वायु गुणवत्ता के लिए दोषी नहीं ठहराया जा सकता। TERI की इस रिपोर्ट का हवाला देते हुए अधिकारियों ने बताया कि सड़क और खुले क्षेत्र की धूल खराब वायु गुणवत्ता में महत्वपूर्ण योगदान देती है। गर्मियों में PM10 में धूल का योगदान 38 से 42 फीसदी और सर्दियों में 23 से 31 फीसदी होता है, जबकि PM 2.5 में इसका योगदान गर्मियों में 31 से 34 फीसदी और सर्दियों में 15 फीसदी होता है। वहीं, गर्मी के सीजन में शुष्क मौसम इस समस्या को और बढ़ा देती हैं। कृषि विशेषज्ञ देविंदर शर्मा ने भारतीय उष्णकटिबंधीय मौसम विज्ञान संस्थान, पुणे के एक अध्ययन का हवाला दिया, जिसमें पाया गया था कि दिल्ली के प्रदूषण में पराली जलाने की भूमिका मात्र 1.3 फीसदी है। वहीं, वाहनों का योगदान प्रदुषण में 14.2 फीसदी प्रदूषण होता है, उसके बाद निर्माण गतिविधि और धूल का स्थान प्रदुषण के कारक बनते हैं। पराली जलाने में कमी आने के बाद दिल्ली का सालाना PM2.5 स्तर 2024 में लगातार दूसरे वर्ष बढ़ा। सेंटर फॉर साइंस एंड एनवायरनमेंट (CSE) की रिपोर्ट के अनुसार, दिल्ली का वार्षिक PM2.5 स्तर 3.4 फीसदी बढ़कर 104.7 माइक्रोग्राम प्रति क्यूबिक मीटर हो गया। प्रदुषण का यह स्तर स्वीकार्य राष्ट्रीय वार्षिक मानक से दोगुना से भी अधिक है। यह बढ़ोतरी अक्तूबर से दिसंबर 2024 के दौरान पंजाब, हरियाणा और दिल्ली में पराली जलाने की घटनाओं में 71.2 फीसदी की गिरावट के बावजूद हुई। हरियाणा के कृषि और किसान कल्याण मंत्री श्याम सिंह राणा ने कहा कि सरकार पराली जलाने से दूरी बनाने वाले किसानों के लिए प्रोत्साहन योजना बना रही है। वर्तमान में। वर्तमान में हरियाणा परली के प्रबंधन के लिए प्रति एकड़ एक हजार रुपये देता है। अधिकारियों का मानना है कि इस पहल की वजह से 2023 की तुलना में पराली जलाने की घटनाओं में 47 फीसदी की कमी आई है

Real-world impact of master plans vital

Thiruvananthapuram: In today's rapidly evolving landscape, civic planners must remain agile, adapt to changes, and devise sustainable solutions to address multiple challenges, said Sarada Muraleedharan, chief secretary. She was speaking at the valedictory session of the 73rd National Town and Country Planners Conference, organized by the Institute of Town Planners, India (ITPI), with the support of the local self-govt department. Sarada stressed the need for planning to move beyond theoretical concepts and tackle real-world issues with actionable solutions. Referring to challenges like waste management, she pointed out that while numerous master plans aim to address critical issues, their true test lies in how effectively they perform on the ground. As part of the event, Sarada presented the National Best Thesis Awards, instituted by ITPI, to post-graduate, undergraduate, and female students. The conference, which focused on the theme "Intelligent, Digital Spatial Planning and Governance," discussed a variety of topics related to urban and rural development, including the integration of technological advancements. During a technical session on "Blue-Green Economy for a Resilient Future," experts noted the impact of extreme heat on productivity and urban infrastructure. They called for climate-sensitive urban design and improved heat management policies. Rajneesh Sareen, programme director of the Sustainable Habitat Programme at CSE, New Delhi, urged Indian cities to adopt heat-resilient urban planning by integrating green-blue infrastructure and nature-based solutions.

Sunita Narain interview: ‘Trump’s victory poses a threat to the environment’

Environmentalist Sunita Narain on her book, The Rise of the Neo-Locals, the end of globalisation, climate change, and why new forms of localisation are not undesirable Leading environmentalist and Director-General Centre for Science and Environment, Sunita Narain’s latest nonction book, The Rise of the Neo-Locals: A Generational Reversal of Globalisation (CSE) is thought-provoking and an essential read for our times. With the question of whether globalisation is dead dominating discussions over the last few years —especially amid the rise of centre-right politics — Narain explores this topic against the backdrop of global challenges. She explores how the climate emergency, ongoing wars — Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the genocide in Gaza — the marginalisation of the poor and even the anger of the rich are shaping global futures. Narain interweaves her personal journey — as an activist, researcher and writer — of being witness to both the rise of globalisation and its fall in post-colonial times. She observes that we are currently experiencing the birth of deglobalisation and re-globalisation, where countries will chart their own course. The book is written in a style that resonates with every kind of reader, but in particular for youth seeking to understand global movements and declared that the 1960s would be the Decade of Development. John F Kennedy said: “To those people in the huts and villages of half the globe struggling to break the bonds of mass misery, we pledge our best efforts to help them help themselves” and that most of these ‘huts’ and ‘villages’ were in India, which had already experienced the consequences of globalisation and capitalism during the colonial era; they became places of tension between localisation and globalisation. Then came the Liberalisation of the 1990s; the setting up of the World Trade Organization (WTO), ushered in an era of free trade. In this conversation with The Federal, Narain talks about the reasons behind writing the book, what lies ahead for global politics and economics, what should be anticipated with Donald Trump coming to power, and what is being done at the local level to counter climate change: Edited excerpts from the interview: What were the motivations behind writing this book? The book is a compilation of some of my writings of my experiences of the many years of being an activist and researcher. It is a subject I keep coming back to: The tensions between insular tendencies of society and the broader consequences of globalisation. I am a child of de-globalisation. I have seen the world move from deglobalisation to an era dominated by free trade. Over time, I have seen how this shift has impacted the world.