Cse In News

As Delhi turns gas chamber, what should we ban today?

On November 13, a day after the Supreme Court suggested a year-round cracker ban, Delhi woke up to one of its worst bad-air days. Diwali was celebrated on October 31, and 14 days is a period long enough for crackers smoke to clear. That is what brings us to the question -- what should we ban today? The question is pertinent because Delhi saw 61 'good' and 'satisfactory' air days last year. Bad air is a perennial problem and helps Delhi top the ignominious chart of world's most-polluted cities. November 13 saw the worst air quality as the Air Quality Index (AQI) spiked to 429. The Delhi and NCR areas plummeted to the 'severe' category for the first time this season. Delhiites and judges of the Supreme Court, by sheer fortune that it is based in Delhi, get to breathe toxic year all round the year, but come November, everyone realises how bad things have become. DIWALI AND PARALI BLAMED, BUT POLLUTION ALL-YEAR ROUND But come November, there's the need for a fall guy. And there are two -- Diwali and parali (stubble). So, why look beyond? It is a coming together of several factors that make Delhi a gas chamber in November. A November 5 report by the Hindustan Times, quoting data from the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), shows Delhi had just 201 days this year when the AQI was 200 or less. In 2023, Delhi had one 'good', 60 'satisfactory' and 145 'moderate' air days, with a total of 206 clean-air days, according to the report. Spending close to half the year breathing toxic air, there is definitely the need to look for a long-term solution, but the fixation on Diwali and parali might be reducing the visibility. On November 12, the Supreme Court questioned why there wasn't a permanent, nationwide ban on firecrackers, and restrictions were applied only during specific months in Delhi. It rightly pointed out that air pollution remains a year-round issue in the national capital. CORRECT DIAGNOSIS BUT BETTER TREATMENT NEEDED Though the diagnosis is correct, there seems to be a problem in pinpointing the source of the ailment. "We are of the view that no religion encourages any activity which creates pollution. If firecrackers are burnt in this fashion, it also affects the fundamental right to health of the citizens," the Supreme Court observed as it heard a case on air pollution in Delhi. Air Quality Index (AQI) data for a week around Diwali in Delhi shows firecrackers have no visible impact. The research on the impact of Diwali on pollution also does not show a long-lasting impact. The research paper titled, 'Estimates of air pollution in Delhi from the burning of firecrackers during the festival of Diwali' by Dhananjay Ghei and Renuka Sane didn't find conclusive evidence on the impact of Diwali fireworks on air quality. Even stubble-burning does not contribute as much to Delhi's pollution as is commonly believed. A new study by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), a Delhi-based environmental think tank, states that stubble burning is responsible for only 8 percent of Delhi's air pollution. What is also concerning is that perceived solutions have become part of the city's problem. The waste-to-energy plants that were first set up under Congress leader Sheila Dikshit have backfired. They are adding to the toxic fumes of Delhi. There is GRAP for a city grappling with pollution woes, but those are emergency measures that kick in when the situation goes from worse to worse. With the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP), Delhi will ban one half of its vehicles and cover up its construction sites. Those are all stop-gap measures. What is the permanent solution, and who is going to come up with it? Those two are the most questions that must be on the minds of gasping Delhiites on November the 13 as the city, once again, turns into a gas chamber. It is time we looked beyond what to ban today.

कागजी प्लान, सिर्फ ऐलान और धुआं-धुआं आसमान... दिल्ली-NCR को क्यों पॉल्यूशन से नहीं मिल पा रही मुक्ति?

देश में मौसम करवट ले रहा है और दिल्ली-एनसीआर में दमघोंटू हवाएं बीमार करने लगी हैं. पूरा शहर फॉग और स्मॉग की चपेट में है. एयर पॉल्यूशन के बीच धुंध और क...

Women Over 50 Are Leading On Climate Action

Sunita Narain, Director of the Centre for Science and Environment Sunita Narain is an influential environmentalist and director of the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE). Since 1982, she has advocated for sustainable development and environmental policies in India. She co-edited the 1985 State of India’s Environment Report and later wrote 'Towards Green Villages.' Sunita led the successful CNG initiative in Delhi to reduce air pollution and raised global awareness on climate change. She was named one of Time’s 100 most influential people in 2016.

Delhi smog explained: Why air turned hazardous and early respite looks bleak

It’s not just Delhi that is under a blanket of the annual early-winter smog, making the city’s air hazardous for its 20 million residents. The entire National Capital Region (NCR), which includes Noida, Gurugram, Faridabad and Ghaziabad, is reeling from the onslaught of very high concentration of particulate matter (PM) in the air. On November 13, Delhi woke up to a layer of thick smog that severely impaired visibility on the roads in the early hours. According to the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), the AQI (air quality index)—a standard benchmark to gauge the severity of pollution—reading hovered at an average 418 (“severe”) over the past 24 hours. CPCB data showed that around 18 per cent of the air pollutants were from stubble-burning by farmers in Punjab and Haryana. Predictably, Gurugram had “very poor” air (an average AQI of 321). Ghaziabad, Greater Noida and Noida too were in the “very poor” range, with average AQI values of 350. AQI readings show the concentration of PM2.5 (very fine particulate matter that poses grave health risks) and the larger PM10 suspended in the air. Haryana’s industrial areas, such as Bahadurgarh and Ballabgarh, too are battling “very poor” air. In Uttar Pradesh, Bulandshahr and Baghpat have reported AQI numbers between 300 and 350. Clearly, the problem extends beyond Delhi, affecting millions across Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and even parts of Rajasthan. Despite many dissuasive efforts, including the threat of financial penalties, many farmers in Delhi’s neighbouring states continue to burn crop stubble, worsening air pollution. Data monitored by the CPCB shows 7,029 stubble-burning instances in Punjab and over 1,000 in Haryana since September 15 this year. As on November 11, stubble-burning contributed about 18 per cent to Delhi’s PM2.5 levels. Though lower than past years, it remains significant and shows the problem’s scale. Punjab’s 7,029 fires since September 15 were 70 per cent fewer than the 23,730 fires reported in the corresponding period in 2023 and 82 per cent fewer than the 40,677 fires in 2022. Haryana reported 1,008 fires since September 15. Last year, the figure was 1,703 fires and 2,880 in 2022. These numbers show some progress in how crop stubble is being managed. Nevertheless, many farmers continue with this way of clearing their fields for sowing the next crop, releasing pollutants into the NCR’s stagnant winter air. The NCR’s main problem is high levels of PM2.5, a pollutant under 2.5 microns in size. For perspective, a single PM2.5 particle is about 1/30th the width of human hair and roughly 40 times smaller than a fine grain of sand. PM2.5 particles can go deep into the lungs, potentially triggering breathing problems, heart trouble, worsening asthma and even causing cancer in the long term. They even reach the bloodstream. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends no more than average 25 µg/m3 (micrograms) of PM2.5 exposure over 24 hours. In Delhi, the exposure is multiple times higher. As winter sets in, the AQI trends in NCR show air quality is rapidly worsening. Delhi invariably has “very poor” to “severe” AQI levels at this time of the year. CPCB records don’t show many “good” air days. In 2023, AQI was already in “very poor” range in November. That remains unchanged this year. What’s worse, weather forecasts in the near future suggest winds not strong enough to dispel the pollutants, which means air quality will stay “very poor”. The not-for-profit Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), in its latest analysis of government data, has found that vehicles continue to be the highest contributor to Delhi’s bad air. “The average PM2.5 concentration has almost stagnated and is the highest in the past five years. Peaks can be highly variable due to the atmospheric conditions. But the increase in average level is a matter of worry,” says Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director (research and advocacy), CSE. There was a 9 per cent increase in average concentration in air pollution in 2023-24 as against 2019-20, the CSE’s analysis found. “This upward trend reflects elevated levels of pollution and the high impact of atmospheric conditions. It needs immediate action,” says Roychowdhury.

Take your breath away: Foul air continues to engulf Punjab despite dip in stubble burning. What’s to blame?

Punjab has been experiencing deteriorating air quality for the last few days despite a drop in crop residue burning cases, raising questions what’s to blame for the conditions. If in previous years when a big part of the leftover crop residue was being burnt in fields that affected the air quality, why under fewer stubble burning cases, such conditions are persisting, asked farmers and agronomists . “Many sections of society, including the judiciary, had been finding fault in stubble burning in worsening of the air quality of the National Capital Region at the onset of winter. Now, when farm fires have drastically decreased, why the authorities are not ready to accept that stubble burning has least contribution to it. Even Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) in its report has stated that stubble burning has a very low contribution to the air quality of Delhi in the initial part of Oct,” said farmer leaders Joginder Singh Ugrahan and Sarvan Singh Pandher. Visibility at various places across Punjab had reached up to zero levels on Tuesday, with even flights getting affected in Amritsar. Questions are being rai sed whether it is smog or fog that is engulfing the region. The issue came to the fore when the plane of the Vice President failed to land at Ludhiana on Tuesday due to low visibility, with smog from stubble burning being blamed for it. Punjab Agricultural University principal agrometeorologist K K Gill said, “Going by the circumstances, it seems a mixture of smog and fog is engulfing the region. Polluting dust and aerosol particles have been hanging in the air since Diwali, leading to smog and hazy conditions”. She added that as the wind speed is minimal, pollutants, including aerosols and dust particles, are in the air, leading to smog. Stubble burning too has a contribution to it apart from firecrackers. Another abnormality is the minimum temperature hovering up to 8°C above normal in Punjab, a rise seen after nearly 54 years. Gill said as sunshine is not reaching the earth’s surface, low wind speed is aggravating the problem, and pollutants are not shifting. “Lower than normal temperatures are required for foggy conditions, but we are witnessing much higher minimum temperatures, especially at nights, which is up to 8°C in certain areas, she added.

At UN climate talks, nations big and small get chance to bear witness to climate change

More than two dozen world leaders are delivering remarks at the United Nations’ annual climate conference Wednesday, with many hard-hit nations detailing their nations’ firsthand experience with the catastrophic weather that has come with climate change. Leader after leader recounted climate disasters, with each one seeming to top the other. Grenada’s prime minister Dickon Mitchell detailed a 15-month drought at the beginning of the year giving way to a Category 5 Hurricane Beryl. “At this very moment, as I stand here yet again, my island has been devastated by flash flooding, landslides and the deluge of excessive rainfall, all in the space of a matter of a couple hours,” Mitchell said. “It may be small island developing states today. It will be Spain tomorrow. It will be Florida the day after. It’s one planet.” Small island nations call for stronger climate action Grenada’s premier wasn’t the only small island nation leader who came with fighting words. Prime minister Philip Edward Davis warned that “it will be our children and grandchildren who bear the burden, their dreams reduced to memories of what could have been.” “We do not — cannot — accept that our survival is merely an option,” Davis said. Gaston Browne, the prime minister of Antigua and Barbuda, highlighted the “inverted morality” of big emitters who aren’t taking responsibility for their impacts on countries who have the most to lose. He said high-polluting nations are “deliberately burning the planet.” Past promises of financial aid went unfulfilled for too long, so small island nations will have to seek justice and compensation in international courts, Browne said. Marshall Islands president Hilda Heine called the climate crisis “the most pressing security threat” her country faces, but said she thinks the Paris Agreement process — where countries agreed to limit warming to 1.5 degrees (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) since pre-industrial times — is resilient. Azerbaijan president Ilham Aliyev took the opportunity to align his country with the predicament of small island developing states in a speech where he called out developed countries, in particular France and the Netherlands, for their colonial histories. He described the harms of colonialism that continue today. Biodiversity loss, rising seas and extreme weather hit communities that are often “ruthlessly suppressed,” he said. The United States also tried to show sympathy to hard-hit places. “Do we secure prosperity for our countries or do we condemn our most vulnerable to unimaginable climate disasters?” United States chief climate envoy John Podesta said. “Vulnerable communities do not just need ambition. They need action.” European leaders recount a year of extreme weather European nations also warned of climate catastrophe on their continent. “Over the past year, catastrophic floods in Spain, Bosnia and Herzegovina as well as in southern Croatia have shown the devastating impact of rising temperatures,” said Croatia’s prime minister, Andrej Plenkovic. “The Mediterranean, one of the most vulnerable regions, calls for urgent action.” Albania Prime Minister Edi Rama said he was dismayed by the lack of political action and political will and leaders of many nations not showing up at climate talks as extreme weather strikes harder and more frequently. Frustrated with other leaders mere talk, Rama decried that “life goes on with old habits” and all these speeches filled with good intent change nothing. “What is happening in Europe and around the world today doesn’t leave much room for optimism, though optimism is the only way of survival,” Rama said. Greek prime minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis said Europe and the world needs to be “more honest” about the trade-offs needed to keep global temperatures down. “We need to ask hard questions about a path that goes very fast, at the expense of our competitiveness, and a path that goes some much slower, but allows our industry to adapt and to thrive,” he said. His nation this summer was hammered by successive heat waves after three years of below-average rainfall. The misery included water shortages, dried-up lakes and the death of wild horses. Ireland environment minister Eamon Ryan channeled some hope, saying that the 2015 Paris climate treaty “still lives” and that countries who drop out will realize they are falling behind as other countries move forward and see benefits to their economies. Negotiators labor on for elusive deal on money Negotiators at the summit are looking to hammer out a deal on how much money, and in what form, developed countries will pledge for adapting to climate change and transitioning to clean energy for developing nations. On Wednesday morning, an early draft of what that final deal will look like was released, but it still contained multiple options that negotiators will wrestle over to reach a consensus by the end of the climate talks. David Waskow, director of international climate action at the World Resources Institute said the latest 34-page draft reflects “all of the options on the table.” “Negotiators now need to work to boil it down to some key decisions” that can be worked on at the second half of the summit. The latest draft “does incorporate some new demands” including an ask for one of the largest negotiating blocs — the G77 plus China — for $1.3 trillion in climate finance, said Avantika Goswami, a climate policy analyst with the New Delhi-based Centre for Science and Environment. “Developing countries have been clear that a provisional goal must be carved out to hold developed country governments to account,” she said. In a veiled reference to China, Germany’s climate envoy Jennifer Morgan said all climate-polluting countries should make contributions to climate funds, one of the most contentious issues being debated at the climate talks in Baku this year. “There are countries that have been successful and prosperous over the last years since 1992, and they also can make a great contribution to getting funds into developing countries,” she said.

Delhi Chokes under "Severe" smog: AQI plummets, visibility vanishes

A dense haze hangs heavy over Delhi, casting an ominous pall over the city as its air quality plunges to alarming levels. For the second consecutive day, Delhiites are grappling with "severe" air pollution, a stark reminder of the persistent environmental challenges facing the national capital. AQI readings paint a grim picture The air quality index (AQI) has soared across various monitoring stations, with some areas recording alarmingly high figures: Anand Vihar: 473 Dwarka: 458 RK Puram: 454 Mundka: 460 Chandni Chowk: 407 These readings, taken by the Central Pollution Control Board, signify that the air is not just unhealthy but poses significant health risks, especially for vulnerable groups like children, the elderly, and those with respiratory conditions. Visibility impairment and health hazards The smog has drastically reduced visibility, with IGI Airport reporting a mere 300 meters of visibility. This poses risks not only for transportation but also for public health. The high concentration of particulate matter, particularly PM2.5, can penetrate deep into the lungs, leading to respiratory problems, cardiovascular diseases, and even cancer. Unprecedented fog and delayed severity While Delhi typically experiences a dip in air quality during winter, the severity this year has been delayed. Experts attribute this to an unusually dense fog that has trapped pollutants close to the ground. However, this doesn't diminish the long-term concerns about air pollution in Delhi. October's "Poor" air quality days Anumita Roychowdhury, an environmental expert, points out that October saw a higher number of "poor" and "very poor" AQI days compared to previous years. While Diwali fireworks usually exacerbate pollution, their impact was less significant this year due to warmer temperatures. However, the underlying issue of excessive annual emissions remains a major concern. Government response and curbing pollution In response to the deteriorating air quality, the Delhi government has implemented emergency measures, including: Construction ban: Halting construction and demolition activities to reduce dust pollution. Vehicle restrictions: Banning BS III petrol and BS IV diesel four-wheelers to control vehicular emissions. These measures aim to mitigate the immediate impact of the pollution crisis. However, long-term solutions require a comprehensive approach to address the root causes of Delhi's air pollution.

दिल्ली में प्रदूषण बढ़ने के बाद GRAP-3 की पाबंदियां लागू, किन चीजों पर लगा प्रतिबंध?

दिल्ली में बढ़ते वायु प्रदूषण के बाद ग्रेडेड रिस्पांस एक्शन प्लान (GRAP) के तीसरे चरण के प्रतिबंध लागू किए जाएंगे। कल (15 नवंबर) की सुबह से ये पाबंदियां लागू हो जाएंगी। दिल्ली में बढ़ते वायु प्रदूषण के बाद ये फैसला लिया गया है। आज सुबह औसतन वायु गुणवत्ता सूचकांक (AQI) 426 दर्ज किया गया, जो 'गंभीर' श्रेणी में आता है। बढ़ते प्रदूषण के चलते दिल्ली दुनिया में दूसरा सबसे प्रदूषित शहर हो गया है। प्रतिबंध किन-किन चीजों पर रहेगा प्रतिबंध? GRAP-3 में BS-III वाले पेट्रोल वाहनों और BS-IV के डीजल वाहनों को दिल्ली और राष्ट्रीय राजधानी क्षेत्र (NCR) में प्रवेश पर प्रतिबंध रहेगा। पूरे NCR में निर्माण और तोड़फोड़ गतिविधियों पर प्रतिबंध और खनन से जुड़ी गतिविधियों पर रोक रहेगी। रोजाना प्रमुख सड़कों पर पानी का छिड़काव किया जाएगा। बता दें कि AQI 401 से 450 के बीच होने पर GRAP के तीसरे चरण की पाबंदियां लागू की जाती हैं। गतिविधियां इन गतिविधियों पर भी रहेगी रोक गैर-इलेक्ट्रिक, CNG और BS-VI डीजल अंतरराज्यीय बसों पर प्रतिबंध रहेगा। दिल्ली-NCR की कच्ची सड़कों पर गाड़ियां नहीं चलेंगी। मलबे का एक जगह से दूसरी जगह ले जाना बंद रहेगा। ईंट-भट्ठे भी बंद कर दिए जाएंगे। दिल्ली-NCR में सभी स्टोन क्रशर बंद रहेंगे। आपातकालीन उद्देश्यों में भी डीजल जनरेटर के इस्तेमाल पर रोक। औद्योगिक स्तर के वेल्डिंग और गैस-कटिंग कार्य पर भी रोक रहेगी। घरेलू स्तर पर सीमेंटिंग, प्लास्टर और मरम्मत/रखरखाव को छोड़कर इससे संबंधित बड़ी गतिविधियों पर रोक। आपने 50% पढ़ लिया है मौसम आज कैसा था दिल्ली की हवा का हाल? केंद्रीय प्रदूषण नियंत्रण बोर्ड (CPCB) द्वारा जारी सुबह 7 बजे के आंकड़ों के अनुसार, दिल्ली के कई इलाकों में AQI "गंभीर" श्रेणी में पहुंच गया है। आनंद विहार का AQI 473, द्वारका का 458, आरके पुरम का 454, मुंडका का 460 और चांदनी चौक का 407 दर्ज किया गया। 39 मॉनिटरिंग स्टेशनों में से 32 ने AQI का स्तर 400 से ज्यादा दर्ज किया है। इसके अलावा एयरपोर्ट और पटपड़गंज में भी AQI 'गंभीर' श्रेणी में रहा। वजह दिल्ली में प्रदूषण की क्या है वजह? सेंटर फॉर साइंस एंड एनवायरनमेंट (CSE) के सर्वे के मुताबिक, दिल्ली के वायु प्रदूषण में स्थानीय स्रोतों का योगदान लगभग 30 प्रतिशत है। इनमें सड़क की धूल, निर्माण गतिविधियों से प्रदूषण या दिवाली उत्सव के दौरान जलाए गए पटाखों की तुलना में वाहन से निकलने वाले उत्सर्जन की हिस्सेदारी सबसे बड़ी है। इसके अलावा पड़ोसी राज्यों में फैलने वाले प्रदूषण की हिस्सेदारी लगभग 35 प्रतिशत है। पंजाब और हरियाणा में पराली जलाना प्रदूषण में 8.19 प्रतिशत का योगदान देता है।

Carbon market deal done? Experts wary

The United National Climate Conference (COP29) presidency has claimed early success with the adoption of standards for carbon credits, referred to as Article 6.4 of the Paris Agreement, a long-debated framework designed to help nations collaborate on reducing carbon emissions. But, critics say it was pushed without adequate scrutiny and would lead to greenwashing as there are not enough safeguards. Yalchin Rafiyev, COP29 lead negotiator, told the media, “This will be a game-changing tool to direct resources to the developing world and help us save up to $250 billion a year when implementing our climate plans.” Harjeet Singh, Global Engagement Director for the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative, said, “Fast-tracking carbon market rules at the start of COP29 sets a troubling precedent.” Greenwashing worry via the carbon market deal “Unlike COP28’s positive example of operationalising the Loss and Damage Fund, which had the support and approval of all countries, this approach sidesteps comprehensive consultation with nations and civil society. These rushed rules open the door to weak, false ‘solutions’ that will only delay real climate action,” Harjeet Singh told this newspaper. Article 6, offers two options for trading: countries can enter into bilateral agreements and set their own rules, or they can participate in a United Nations-supervised market open to all. This UN supervised carbon market, in which the credit price will be fixed by the market players but embedded with third party accreditation, has several loopholes which can be easily exploited. Critics argue that the benefits of Article 6 are far from guaranteed. Climate activists and experts highlight significant risks, such as potential human rights abuses and ‘greenwashing’, in which polluters can claim environmental progress without genuinely reducing emissions. Some carbon credit projects, like large-scale reforestation, risk displacing Indigenous communities if not carefully managed. Aarti Gupta, environmental policy group, Department of Social Sciences in Wageningen University, says Article 6 could prioritise carbon trading over direct climate finance, which is dangerous and undermines the Paris Agreement’s goals. However, Martin Hession, Vice-Chair of the Article 6.4 of the Supervisory Body, told this newspaper, “there are enough safeguards to thwart greenwashing in the carbon crediting mechanism. Third party verification is integral. But, individual countries must also ensure the quality of credits. We are setting high-quality standards. We have many provisions to ensure local communities are consulted.” Endorsement rushed through, says expert “If the negotiating parties requested recommendations from the supervisory body and have reviewed them for two years, the recommendations were significant enough to warrant discussion before adoption as standards. The revised recommendation has issues, like the lack of a definition for the durability of carbon removals,” said Trishant Dev, from the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE)

Trump Is President Again, and It’s Bad News For the Climate

On November 6, Donald Trump was elected the 47th US president. This will be Trump’s second term as president. US stock markets soared after Trump’s victory. Even India’s market rallied, boosting investor wealth by Rs 7.75 trillion by one estimate. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, among the first leaders to congratulate Trump, said that he was “looking forward to working closely” with Trump once again “to further strengthen India-US relations across technology, defence, energy, space and several other sectors”. But many are unhappy. Scientists, environmentalists and activists have noted Trump’s win in the US elections with much concern, for Trump, a climate denier and sceptic, has been very clear about his thoughts about climate change and climate action: he has called global warming a “hoax”. Even during his campaign for the just-concluded US elections, he said that people were talking about ‘oceans rising’ (he meant sea levels rising), but “who the hell cares?”. One of the guarantees his campaign this year rode on was that with Trump at the helm, the US would tap into new reserves of fossil fuels. Some called Trump’s victory in the US elections on Wednesday a “black day” for climate; a former environment minister of Brazil called it “the planet’s biggest civilisational and climatic step backwards”. There are ways that Trump’s ascent to the presidency could also affect India, especially with regard to exports, because some of India’s clean energy technology is exported to the US. But when it comes to climate action, many are clear: Trump’s re-emergence as US president may, at the most, stall – not deter – the US’s and the world’s transition to clean energy. The climate background The past week has been momentous with news that has been coming in regarding climate change and its impacts, with regions experiencing different types of extreme weather events that are claiming lives and causing huge economic, environmental and social losses and damages. Spain is still struggling in the aftermath of one of the deadliest flash floods that the country has ever witnessed. Intense rains on October 29 aggravated by climate change killed more than 200, and more than 70 are still missing. On November 8, parts of northeast Spain witnessed new flash floods. On November 7, the Copernicus Climate Change Service – which is part of the European Union’s space programme and releases monthly climate bulletins – released data that shows that it was “virtually certain” the year 2024 would be the warmest year and that the first year when global warming has breached the 1.5°C mark above pre-industrial levels. October 2024 was the second-warmest October globally, after October 2023, in terms of surface air temperatures. “After ten months of 2024 it is now virtually certain that 2024 will be the warmest year on record and the first year of more than 1.5ºC above pre-industrial levels according to the ERA5 dataset,” commented Samantha Burgess, deputy director of Copernicus, in a press release. “This marks a new milestone in global temperature records and should serve as a catalyst to raise ambition for the upcoming Climate Change Conference, COP29.” article image ALSO READ Deaths, Destruction on the Rise Due to Extreme Weather Events: Grim Statistics in India Climate Report 2024 View More On the same day that the Copernicus report was released, the United Nations Environment Programme’s Adaptation Gap Report found that there is still a huge gap in adaptation finance. Basically, it found that developed countries – many of them, including the US, have been historical emitters of greenhouse gases and thus have an obligation to invest more in climate action – need to drastically increase their funding to developing nations to implement measures to adapt to the impacts of climate change. On November 8, data compiled by the Centre for Science and Environment and its publication Down to Earth showed that extreme weather events are consistently on the rise in India. In the first nine months of the year, extreme events occurred on 255 out of a total 274 days across the country. These events – ranging from lightning and storms to heavy rain, floods, landslides and heat waves – claimed the lives of 3,238 people, affected 3.2 million hectares of crops, destroyed 2,35,862 houses and buildings, and killed 9,457 livestock across the country. Meanwhile, all eyes are now on Baku, Azerbaijan. Here, at the 29th United Nations Conference of the Parties (COP29) which kicked off on Monday (November 11), representatives of governments, world leaders and others are sitting down together to discuss, negotiate and implement actions towards tackling climate change. The first day of the COP has already witnessed countries agreeing to a UN-backed carbon credit standard, which will permit carbon offsets to be traded across nations. A denier and sceptic to the core It is in this backdrop that Trump is preparing for a second term as US president. Director general of the Centre for Science and Environment and editor of Down to Earth Sunita Narain alluded to the Trump factor as she launched the India Climate Report virtually on November 8. The report was being launched at a time when Trump, a “climate sceptic”, has come back to power, she said. “He has openly said that climate change does not happen, is not happening,” Narain said, of Trump coming back to power in the US. “He has openly said that he will revive energy drilling in his country. As part of his plan, the cost of energy will fall and there will be more drilling … he has said very clearly that the green deal of Biden is history as far as he is concerned. This is important not because of the global leadership role that the US has played, but because it continues to be a country with a very high emission load.” Trump’s climate denial is well-known. “We should be focused on magnificently clean and healthy air and not distracted by the expensive hoax that is global warming!,” he tweeted in 2013. In 2015, he said in an interview: “I believe in clean air. Immaculate air. But I don’t believe in climate change.” His attitude to the issue of global warming and climate change has since not changed. On November 2 this year, as part of his election campaign, he said that “nuclear warming”, not global warming, was the biggest threat. “So they talk all the time about the ocean will rise in 500 years, one-eighth of an inch, who the hell cares?” he said. (Of course, he got the numbers wrong, too.) And over the course of his campaign, “drill, baby, drill” has been a common refrain on his lips; he promised to open up new gas reserves if he came back to power. “We are going to – I used this expression, now everyone else is using it so I hate to use it, but – ‘drill, baby, drill’,” he said. On the day he was elected president for the second time, Trump said: “We have more liquid gold than any country in the world. More than Saudi Arabia. We have more than Russia.” This matters because even with the US’s current levels of fossil fuel consumption – which would be low when compared to what Trump hopes to unleash in the years to come – the US is one of the largest emitters of greenhouse gases. “The US is the world’s single largest historical emitter of greenhouse gas emissions … This matters because we know that the lifetime of carbon dioxide is 150-170 years,” Narain said at the virtual launch of the India Climate Report 2024 on November 8. “So we cannot deny the historical contributions of a country because those emissions have not disappeared.” These emissions are part of the stock of emissions in the atmosphere that is causing the climate to change, she said. The US is also the second largest annual emitter, and the largest on a per capita basis, she added. Between 2000 and 2023, the US produced the highest total carbon emissions per capita by region (which factors in population) as per the International Energy Agency.

Air gets a tad better, but remains ‘poor’

Gurgaon: Brisk winds up to 10kmph helped wash away pollutants in the air, but the city's air quality remained ‘poor' on Tuesday. The average 24-hour air quality index was 219 on Tuesday, down from Monday's 294. Experts warned that pollution levels will rise as the weather gets colder. "Throughout the year, the region has been witnessing poor to very poor air, and it will aggravate in the coming days because we are yet to enter the peak winter phase. As the temperature goes down, the dispersion of pollutants will be slower, which is likely to lead to more accumulation of pollutants suspended in the air," said Shubhansh Tiwari, a research associate at the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE). Data by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) showed that particulate matter levels were higher than safe standards. The monitoring station in Sector 51 recorded PM2.5 concentration at 305 µg/m³, the highest for the city on Tuesday. It was followed by Gwalpahari, at 195 µg/m³, Teri Gram at 156 µg/m³ and Vikas Sadan at 113 µg/m³. PM10 readings were also far beyond safe limits. At Sector 51 station, it was 301 µg/m³. Gwalpahari station recorded 167 µg/m³ and Teri Gram saw PM10 touch 189 µg/m³. The average permissible limit for PM2.5 is 60 µg/m³ and for PM10, it is 100 µg/m³. Doctors said that patients with existing respiratory or medical conditions were at higher risk of developing complications from breathing in pollutants. "We are seeing about a 30–40% increase in OPD patients with symptoms like cough, viral infections, flu and asthma. People with asthma or respiratory problems should use their inhalers regularly, avoid going outdoors when pollution levels are high, and wear masks in crowded areas," said Dr Nevin Kishore, head of bronchology and senior consultant for respiratory medicine and pulmonology at Max Hospital in Gurgaon. Meanwhile, Delhi has been suffering from ‘very poor' air quality for the past two weeks. Despite winds up to 10 km/h improving the air quality on Tuesday, the AQI at 4pm was 334 against 354 at 11am. It, however, improved further due to consistent winds to 315 by 8pm.

G77, China reject framework for draft text on new climate finance goal

G77AND China,the largest bloc representing around 130 countries atthe UN climate talks, has rejectedtheframeworkforadraft negotiating text on a new climate finance goal -- the central issue at this year’s climate summit in Baku, Azerbaijan. Thesubstantiveframeworkfor adraftnegotiatingtext,prepared by the co-chairs of the Ad Hoc Work Programme on the New Collective Quantified Goal (NCQG) and published in October,isthefirstitemforcountries to deliberate on. However, on Tuesday, G77 and China rejectedthe framework, arguing it does not accurately reflect the suggestions that developing countrieshave madeforthenew climate finance goal. Other groups of developing countries, including the LikeMinded Developing Countries (LMDCs),AllianceofSmallIsland DevelopingStates(AOSIS),Least Developed Countries (LDCs), andthe IndependentAllianceof LatinAmericaandtheCaribbean (AILAC), backed G77 and China in this rejection. According to the Loss and DamageCollaboration,aninternational coalition of climate researchers and activists, G77 and China have requested that theco-chairsprepareanewdraft text before the next negotiating session.G77andChinademanded that the new climate finance packagemeettheirneedsandpriorities, with a minimum quantum of USD 1.3 trillion. The group said that this amount shouldsupportmitigation,adaptation, and loss and damage initiatives, and should be exclusively allocated to developing countries. Developing countries also insist that the new climate finance goal, or NCQG, should prioritize public, grant-based, and concessional finance, as these types of funding are less burdensome fornations already facing financial challenges. Public finance provides a stable support source, while grants and concessional loans (with verylow or zero interest)are easier for developing countries to manage. According to the Delhi-based think tank Centre for Science and Environment, developing countries are also calling for developed countries to provide arrears for the USD 100 billion climate finance goal agreed to in 2009. At COP15 in 2009, developed countries pledged to mobilise USD 100 billion per year to help developingnationsadapttoand combat climate changeby 2020. However, this target was only metin2022,withloansaccounting for around 70 percent of the total climate finance provided. Developing countries are also asking that the NCQG impose no conditions on access to climatefinance.Theysayresources provided under the new goal must be predictable, new and additional, adequate, grantbased, and concessional, and mustnotcreatefiscalconstraints or debt burdens.

Experts flag climate concerns as PM, top leaders skip COP29

Top leaders of major global polluters India and China, along with those from prominent economies such as the US, European Union, France, Japan, Israel and Brazil, will skip the ongoing session of the Conference of the Parties (COP29) climate summit in Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan. While Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav had attended the COP28 in Dubai last year, the Indian delegation this time will be led by Minister of State Kirti Vardhan Singh. He will address the COP29 on November 18 and 19. The PM had earlier attended the COP21 in Paris and the COP26 in Glasgow. Officials who are part of the delegation said the past COP events had been used by India for key bilateral meetings, but the absence of major world leaders at COP29, being held from November 11 to 22, would not have required the PM’s presence. Environment Minister Yadav’s non-availability for the conference is being attributed to his being the BJP in charge for the November 20 Maharashtra Assembly elections. Advertisement “Prime Minister Modi had met Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy on the margins of the COP26 in Glasgow in November 2021. In Paris, Chinese President Xi Jinping and other major global leaders were present. In Dubai last year, PM Modi had met Brazilian and Israeli Presidents,” an official said. The “World Leaders Climate Action Summit” at the UN Climate Conference is a forum for the heads of states and governments to air their perspective on climate action and articulate national policies on dealing with the crisis, the official said. Experts flag climate concerns as PM, top leaders skip COP29 India to be represented by MoS Kirti Vardhan article_Author Aksheev Thakur Tribune News Service New Delhi, Updated At : 06:24 AM Nov 13, 2024 IST fb twitter whatsapp Follow us Follow us Connect with us Connect with us featured-imgfeatured-img Advertisement Top leaders of major global polluters India and China, along with those from prominent economies such as the US, European Union, France, Japan, Israel and Brazil, will skip the ongoing session of the Conference of the Parties (COP29) climate summit in Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan. While Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav had attended the COP28 in Dubai last year, the Indian delegation this time will be led by Minister of State Kirti Vardhan Singh. He will address the COP29 on November 18 and 19. The PM had earlier attended the COP21 in Paris and the COP26 in Glasgow. Officials who are part of the delegation said the past COP events had been used by India for key bilateral meetings, but the absence of major world leaders at COP29, being held from November 11 to 22, would not have required the PM’s presence. Environment Minister Yadav’s non-availability for the conference is being attributed to his being the BJP in charge for the November 20 Maharashtra Assembly elections. Advertisement “Prime Minister Modi had met Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy on the margins of the COP26 in Glasgow in November 2021. In Paris, Chinese President Xi Jinping and other major global leaders were present. In Dubai last year, PM Modi had met Brazilian and Israeli Presidents,” an official said. The “World Leaders Climate Action Summit” at the UN Climate Conference is a forum for the heads of states and governments to air their perspective on climate action and articulate national policies on dealing with the crisis, the official said. Read More Flowers India Illegal infiltration: ED arrests 2 Bangladeshi nationals, 1 Indian' View More right-arrow Advertisement Nivedita Bansal, who is part of the 2024 cohort of the “Women Climate Collective”, claimed that world leaders skipping the COP29 “sent a worrying message to the participating countries and undermined the importance of the negotiations”. “It creates a perception that the negotiations are optional. This can impact the participation of countries in future COPs and derail the progress on climate action. However, this may create a unique opportunity for the parties present to take the lead in creating meaningful climate outcomes globally. The absence of important players can give least developed countries and BRICS nations more visibility and power in leveraging negotiations towards favouring the needs of the Global South,” she said. Programme manager at the Centre for Science and Environment, Avantika Goswami, said the absence of global leaders would not make the summit insignificant. “Geopolitics is really difficult right now. There are a lot of different conflicting priorities. Multiple wars and tensions are taking place around the world. That does not make the COP29 any less important because without agreeing on an ambitious finance target for climate action in Baku, it will be impossible for developing countries to achieve their climate goals in the remaining part of the decade,” she said. British PM Keir Starmer, UN Secretary General António Guterres, Barbados PM Mia Mottley, World Bank president Ajay Banga and Brazilian Environment Minister Marina Silva are among those who would address the summit.

Modi Gov Doubles Stubble Burning Penalties for Neigbouring States; Check the New Rates

The fines for stubble burning have been increased by the Union Ministry of Environment, Forests, and Climate Change in response to the Supreme Court's criticism of the "toothless" sanctions under the Environment Protection Act (EPA) of 1986. In addition to addressing the deteriorating air quality in Delhi and the surrounding areas, this action attempts to reduce stubble burning. Increased Penalty Rates for Stubble Burning The central government has nearly doubled the fines for stubble burning for farmers in states near the national capital. Check the new rates in the table given below: Which States Farmers Come Under the Penalty? The Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) Act of 2021 enforces penalties to control pollution across Delhi, Punjab, Haryana, and parts of the NCR in Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh. These regulations aim to improve air quality by setting strict rules and consequences for violations in these regions. How will the Fine be Collected? Fines collected through challans must be paid within 30 days. If not paid, an authorized officer will recover the unpaid amount as a land revenue arrear. For farmers involved in stubble burning, a “red entry” will be recorded against their land as a mark of violation. Collected fines go directly to the accounts of the respective State Pollution Control Boards or Committees. Delhi Air Pollution: Source-wise Contribution Data from the Centre for Science and Environment shows that pollution sources break down as follows: 30.34% comes from within Delhi, with transportation making up 50.1% of that share. Neighboring NCR areas contribute 34.97%, while other regions add 27.94%. Stubble burning contributes a smaller portion, at just 8.19%, to Delhi's pollution levels. According to the Indian Agricultural Research Institute, cases of stubble burning decreased from 71,829 in 2020 to 12,514 between September 16 and November 6 this year.

Women’s representation at UN climate conferences has barely improved in 30 years, particularly women from South Asia

As the 29th UN climate conference opens in Baku, Azerbaijan on Nov. 11, one thing remains the same: men will occupy most seats at the climate talks. Much has changed since the UN’s first Conference of the Parties (COP) to the Framework Convention on Climate Change in 1995. But the proportion of women representatives has remained stalled, at about a third of participants. According to data from the Women’s Environment and Development Organization, women represented only 34% of party delegates and 19% of heads of delegation at COP28 last year. In comparison, 16 years ago at COP14, women comprised 31% of party delegates. This minimal progress is despite increasing calls for gender mainstreaming in climate action. Why are women delegates missing at COPs? In January this year, the organising committee for COP29 appointed 28 men and no women. After facing significant criticism, 12 women were added (and one more man). She Changes Climate, an organisation founded in 2020 that advocates for equal gender representation at climate negotiations, called the initial decision “a regressive step”. It asked for equal representation in the committee: “Climate change affects the whole world, not half of it.” Afia Salam, a journalist and media development specialist focusing on climate change, environment and gender-sensitive reporting, tells Dialogue Earth that ensuring the voices of women are included often requires drastic measures, such as “gatecrashing committee meetings” in Pakistan. “It is a man’s world,” says Salam. “You see far more men than women in international climate negotiations. This has a lot to do with the historical baggage, where women are often missing from places of prominence and decision-making [in the countries that representatives come from].” This global gender imbalance in leadership translates directly to climate negotiations, where national representatives mirror the gender disparities of their governments. In South Asia, only 16.6% of parliamentarians are women. Globally, only 23.3% of cabinet ministers are women. Worse, the portfolios they manage are often limited to gender, family and children affairs, social inclusion and development, as well as Indigenous and minority affairs. As important as these portfolios are, they do not set the agenda in the way that finance and energy do. One barrier is social constraints related to gendered roles and responsibilities. Bharati Chaturvedi, founder and director of Chintan Environmental Research and Action Group in New Delhi, explains: “Women are not a homogenous lot [and] different women have different circumstances and contexts; work responsibilities; domestic responsibilities.” She adds: “Negotiators may not necessarily be women from prestigious government services and therefore they might be required to put in several nights preparing and being away for a fortnight, which takes them away from domestic responsibilities for several weeks.” What can women bring to the climate discourse? In the South Asian context, women are central to domestic and caregiving responsibilities, while also playing a crucial role in agriculture. They make up 43% of the agricultural workforce in developing countries, a sector that contributes 18% to South Asia’s GDP. Due to gender inequalities in the political, social and economic realms, women face higher risks from the impacts of climate change. This strengthens the case for their inclusion in climate action. Salam highlights pervasive gender blindness in climate change policies and adaptation measures. “During disasters, something as basic as putting a relief kit together does not take into account the needs of the women; this nuance is being brought by women.” Salam says they “typically fail to include basic hygiene essentials, such as sanitary napkins, underwear, cloth towels, cotton pads, soap, along with special nutrition and dignity kits for pregnant and new mothers. In the absence of inclusive relief kits, people have stepped in to fill that gap.” Salam notes that having more women involved in climate discussions would lead to a more inclusive approach for other marginalised groups: “Since they have been at the centre of caregiving, they are also thinking about children and elders. When women craft solutions, they are more likely to be inclusive.” When women participate in climate change negotiations, it can potentially provide them access to technical spaces where key decisions on issues like mitigation strategies, adaptation measures and the financing of initiatives are made. This would allow them to play an important diplomatic role in decision-making, says Chaturvedi. Among top examples of women negotiators influencing international climate talks is Sherry Rehman, the former climate minister of Pakistan. As the G77 chair at COP27 in Sharm El-Sheikh, she led the negotiations on loss and damage for the G77, where a commitment to set up a dedicated Loss and Damage Fund was made. Meanwhile, Sunita Narain, an environmental policy researcher from India, served on COP28 President Sultan Al Jaber’s advisory panel. As director general of the Centre for Science and Environment in Delhi, Narain is a prominent advocate for recognising historical responsibility when considering greenhouse gas emissions. Not everything lies in the numbers The mere presence of women in climate negotiations does not guarantee influence or systemic change, however. Chaturvedi is cautious about assuming that more women at COPs would create significant impact, as strategic decision-making often happens centrally, within ministries. “A better outcome is that gender interests are incorporated into negotiations,” she says. Salam agrees, and suggests the power and clout women hold at the table are more important than the numbers alone. “We have had powerful women with strong leadership capabilities in the past, but these were only exceptions, not the norm.” Broader issues lie in the nature of COPs themselves. Many question the efficacy of COPs in driving meaningful climate action, especially when civil society groups face restrictions. Chaturvedi notes: “When you shut down protests, you are also shutting down a lot of women’s voices, because there are a lot of women in the justice conversation.” Key to women’s solidarity is South Asian cooperation Political crises compound the climate crisis in the absence of regional cooperation. Salam highlights the urgent need for cross-border cooperation between India and Pakistan: “We are independent countries, but we have shared problems. We have transboundary rivers and hence we share similar water problems. Delhi and Lahore share the same air pollution issues.” While such collaboration is challenging due to complex intergovernmental relationships, Chaturvedi argues that more investment in female solidarity- and confidence-building is essential. “The power of civil society is rooted in solidarity, and this solidarity would come from panels and conversations.” There are small glimmers of hope, though. Last year, the COP28 presidency urged parties to bring gender-balanced delegations. Parties also agreed that the final review of the implementation of the enhanced Lima Work Programme on Gender (LWPG) will be concluded this month. Established in 2014 at COP20 in Peru, the LWPG aims to advance gender balance and ensure women’s equal and meaningful participation. Through an open letter, the Women and Gender Constituency has urged negotiators at COP29 to include gender-responsive measures in climate policies and address the barriers preventing women’s full participation in climate negotiations. Time will tell if gender equality truly gains ground in climate change decision-making.