Cse In News

India Crosses the Seven Seas to Meet Rising Demand for Timber

India’s demand for sawlog could be at a saturation point, with Uruguay ramping up exports to the booming economy starting next month. That is according to Scott Downs, PF Olsen’s Director of Sales and Marketing, who reported that Uruguay is preparing to supply four vessels into the Kandla, which “when combined with supply from New Zealand and Australia, means the market might reach saturation.” As it stands, Uruguay is India’s top market for sawlog, with India’s Ministry of Commerce and Industry reporting that Uruguyans account for more than 20% of total trade for the first six months of 2024 (487,700 cubic metres) ahead of Australia (14.4% or 347,600 cubic metres), Ecuador (12.1% or 293,300 cubic metres), Argentina (9.1% or 213,700 cubic metres) and the United States (7.6% or 193,000 cubic metres). However, this number does not fully account for the uptake in New Zealand trade (which has picked up since May) after both countries agreed to finally resolve their long-running dispute over Methyl Bromide. Exporters are looking at India as a pivot from a soft China. In February, Wood Central reported that India has emerged as one of the United States’ most important export markets, with 116,000 cubic metres of softwood lumber shipped from the West Coast to India last year alone. Already its fastest-growing hardwood market, the US is capitalising on India’s construction industry and, in the process, making up for a drop in Chinese demand—with total lumber exports almost tripling for the first six months of 2024 over last year. Last year, Wood Central reported that Indian demand for Roundwood will grow 70%, from 57 million cubic metres in 2020 to 98 million cubic metres in 2030, driven by a surge in construction activity. According to the Indian Centre for Science and Environment, the country’s 2022 demand for timber was 63 million cubic metres—30 million cubic metres for domestic production and 33 million cubic metres from imported sources. While import volumes remain lower in 2024 compared to 2023, India is competing with China to become the world’s largest consumer market for structural timbers. The Modi Government is grappling with a 19 million-unit housing shortage, which will double over the next five years. Fuelling India’s demand for roundwood is a decision made in 2020 to reverse a 27-year ban on using timber in public buildings. Last year, Wood Central reported that India’s Ministry of Environment, Forestry and Climate Change (MoEFCC) drove the 2020 decision to lift the ban, citing “a boost for the economy, opportunities to generate jobs and encourage farmers to plant more trees” to make up for a timber and forest deficit. In the long run, India is also investing in a new streamlined transit system for timber and bamboo products. This system, along with a new government-backed national standard, is a vital part of Modi’s “Wood is Good: Grow More, Use More” policy.

NGT notice to Centre, CPCB over ozone pollution

The tribunal took up a suo motu case based on a report by the Centre for Science and Environment which said that ground-level ozone exceeded the permissible limits of 100 microgram per cubic metre per eight hours in 10 metropolitan cities of India.

NGT takes suo motu action on alarming rise in ground-level ozone pollution in major cities

The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has taken suo motu cognizance of rising ground level ozone pollution across India’s major cities. The petition is registered suo-motu on the basis of a news item dated 06.08.2024. News item relates to the rising ground level ozone pollution across India’s major cities. As per the news item, this invisible gas, unlike the more familiar fine particulate matter, also known as PM2.5, poses a serious health threat, particularly to those with respiratory problems. The news item states that as per a report by the Centre for Science and Environment titled “Air Quality Tracker: An invisible threat” metropolitan areas of Bengaluru (Karnataka), Chennai (Tamil Nadu), Kolkata (West Bengal), Mumbai and Pune (Maharashtra), Delhi-National Capital Region, Greater Ahmedabad (Gujarat), Greater Hyderabad (Telangana), Greater Jaipur (Rajasthan) and Greater Lucknow (Uttar Pradesh) were analysed and all 10 areas studied witnessed exceeded national ozone standard, with Delhi NCR being the most affected. Ahmedabad and Pune were also found to be experiencing a particularly rapid increase in ozone pollution. As per the news item, ground level ozone is not directly emitted from any source. It is produced from complex interaction between Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that are emitted from vehicles, power plants, factories and other combustion sources and undergo cyclic reactions in the presence of sunlight to generate ground level ozone. VOCs can also be emitted from natural sources, such as plants. The news item further highlights that between April and July this year, Delhi-NCR recorded 176 days of ground-level ozone exceedances, the highest among the ten metropolitan areas studied. Mumbai and Pune both had 138 days, followed by Jaipur with 126 days and Hyderabad with 86 days. Kolkata had 63 exceedance days, Bengaluru 59, Lucknow 49 and Ahmedabad 41. Chennai had the fewest exceedances, with just nine days. Furthermore, ozone levels were elevated even at night, with Mumbai recording the most instances of night-time exceedances. News item also stated that the duration of ozone exposure lasted an average of 12-15 hours across most cities. Moreover, it alleges that while summer is the peak season for ozone, the problem persists year round in many areas, particularly in sunnier southern cities. The news item also pointed out that as particulate pollution is reduced, issues with nitrogen oxides (NOx) and ground-level ozone increase. This necessitates significant tightening of regulatory benchmarks for ozone to address toxic emissions from industry, vehicles, households and open burning. The news item asserts that ground-level ozone is a highly reactive gas and has serious health consequences. Those with respiratory conditions, asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease as well as children with premature lungs and older adults are at serious risk. This can inflame and damage airways, make lungs susceptible to infection, aggravate asthma, emphysema and chronic bronchitis and increase the frequency of asthma attacks leading to increased hospitalization. The news item raises substantial issue relating to compliance of provisions of Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981; The Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 and the Environment Protection Act, 1986. “Power of the Tribunal to take up the matter in suo-motu exercise of power has been recognized by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of “Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai vs. Ankita Sinha & Ors.” reported in 2021 SCC Online SC 897.” Hence, Principal Bench of Justice Prakash Shrivastava, Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi and Dr. A. Senthil Vel impleaded the following as respondents in the matter: 1) Central Pollution Control Board, through its Member Secretary. 2) Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, through its Secretary. The Bench issued notice to the Respondents and listed the matter on 28.11.2024.

Environmental experts, govt officials to meet on Thursday to craft Delhi’s Winter Action Plan

Delhi Environment Minister Gopal Rai has said the government will convene a conference on Thursday, which will be attended by environmental experts from 36 institutions along with officials from 42 government departments, to craft an effective Winter Action Plan to combat the city’s air pollution. In a bid to curb the deteriorating air quality in the national capital in the winter months, the minister said on Wednesday, “This year, our primary goal is to control pollution through public participation.” He added that the conference would see participation from key agencies, such as the Commission for Air Quality Management in National Capital Region and Adjoining Areas (CAQM) and the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB). Other participants will include the Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC), India Meteorological Department (IMD) and Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA). Premier institutions like the IIT, the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) and the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), among others, will also be involved. PauseUnmute Fullscreen Rai emphasised the importance of this collaborative effort. “The opinions and suggestions of the environmental experts from 36 institutions, alongside the officials from 42 government departments, will be instrumental in crafting an effective Winter Action Plan,” he said. The minister outlined the government’s strategic focus areas, including dust pollution, vehicular emissions, stubble and garbage burning, industrial pollution and expanding green spaces. The action plan will also address the enforcement of firecracker bans, use of the Green Delhi app and operations of the Green War Room, which monitors real-time pollution levels and hotspots across the city. Rai further highlighted the significance of the conference in fostering cooperation between the Delhi government, the Centre and the neighbouring states. “The suggestions from this roundtable conference will guide our efforts in reducing air pollution and ensuring a healthier environment for Delhi’s residents,” he said. PTI NSM RC

Delhi dwellers losing 7.8 years to PM2.5 pollution: Report

Delhi residents are losing 7.8 years of their life expectancy to increased PM2.5 concentration, according to a report published by a US-based research institute, which said the loss can be mitigated by reducing the level of the pollutant to the World Health Organization (WHO) standard of 5 micrograms per cubic metre (µg/m3) The report, on Air Quality Life Index (AQLI) published by the Energy Policy Institute at the University of Chicago (EPIC) on Wednesday is based on analysis of 2022 pollution data. It said that even containing the level of PM2.5 — particulate matter having diameter less than 2.5 microns, a major pollutant in Delhi — to the national standard ormore lenient level of 40µg/m3 can increase life expectancy of 18.7 millionDelhi residents by 4.3 years. The AQLI is a pollution index that quantifies the causal relationship between long-term human exposure to air pollution and life expectancy. The life expectancy calculations made by AQLI are based on a pair of peer-reviewed studies. By comparing two subgroups of the population that experienced prolonged exposure to different levels of particulate air pollution, the studies were able to plausibly isolate the effect of particulate air pollution from other factors that affect health. To be sure, Delhi’s average PM2.5 concentration in 2022 was 84.3µg/m3. This made Delhi the most-polluted state or Union territory in the country, the report said. According to WHO, life expectancy at birth in India was 67.3 years in 2021. This is up by nearly five years from the average life expectancy of 62.1 years in 2000. “If all of India were to reduce particulate pollution to meet the WHO guideline, residents in Delhi—India’s capital and most populous city—would see the maximum benefits, with its residents gaining 7.8 years of life expectancy. In North 24 Parganas – a district in West Bengal and the country’s second most populous district, residents would gain 3.6 years of life expectancy,” said report on Tuesday. Delhi consistently ranks among the world’s most polluted cities each year, impacted by a cocktail of pollutants that are at their peak in the winter months from November till January. Pollution in Delhi spikes following the harvesting of crop in the northern plains, which often clashes with Diwali, leading to a mixture of smoke from residue burning and firecrackers hanging over the capital’s air for weeks. Other than these, Delhi is also impacted by localised sources such as industries, vehicles and burning of waste, keeping levels of pollutants well above permissible standards. The report found that after Delhi, Uttar Pradesh was the most polluted, with an annual average PM2.5 level of 65.5µg/m3, with residents of the state expected to gain 5.9 years if the WHO standard is met and 2.5 years if the national standard is met. For Haryana, the corresponding figures were 5.2 years and 1.8 years, respectively. The report, despite showing Delhi residents losing considerable years in terms of life expectancy, nevertheless posits an improvement from a previous study done on 2021 PM2.5 level. Last year’s EPIC report, based on 2021 data, revealed Delhi’s PM 2.5 level was 126.51µg/m3 — up from the level of 111.6µg/m3 recorded in 2020. The previous report posited an increase of 11.9 years in life expectancy if WHO standards were met and 8.5 years if national standard of 40µg/m3was met. The report found that not just Delhi, but other states and UTs also showed an improvement in 2022. The average PM2.5 concentration for India reduced from 49µg/m3 in 2021 to 41.4µg/m3 in 2022, which is still over eight times the WHO standard, but close to the national standard. “If these reductions are sustained, an average Indian is likely to live nine months longer compared to what they would have if they were exposed to levels similar to the last decade. Further, if pollution in India met the WHO guideline, Indian citizens could gain an additional 3.6 years onto their life expectancy,” the report said. Tanushree Ganguly, director of AQLI, said that over the years, Delhi’s PM2.5 concentration has largely remained over 100 µg/m3, barring 2020, when Covid-19 curbs kept levels low. “In 2022, PM2.5 levels in Delhi were 17% lower than 2021 and the average of 2016 to 2021. While it is difficult to conclusively separate the effects of weather from policy implementation in explaining this decline — especially since the entire South Asian region, including Bangladesh, Nepal, and Pakistan, reported reduced particulate concentrations — sustaining these reductions in Delhi could increase average life expectancy in the city by 1.6 years,” she said. Environmental activist Bhavreen Kandhari said even if there is an improvement in relation to 2021, 7.8 years was a significant sum of years being lost to bad air. “It is important the national standards are also brought down, as the WHO standards are closer to clean air. We still need to work hard to bring down the years being lost and that can only be done if both state and the Centre acknowledge the health risk associated with air pollution,” she said. Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director, research and advocacy at the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), said Delhi still has a long way to go to bring down its PM2.5 level, but an aggressive and stringent approach towards electrification, integrated public transport and low-emission zones with cycling or walking facilities could help in this regard. “We also need to improve our waste management, which means 100% waste collection, segregation and processing. This eliminates burning of waste and landfills. We also need to replace dirty fuels for cooking with cleaner fuels and implement clean energy across all sectors,” she said.

Delhi govt to hold expert conference on control of air pollution in winter

In a bid to combat the rising levels of air pollution during the winter season, the Kejriwal government has announced a comprehensive “Round Table Conference” to be held on Thursday at the Delhi Secretariat. The initiative aims to bring together a diverse group of experts and representatives from various governmental and non-governmental institutions to formulate an effective winter action plan. Environment Minister Gopal Rai revealed that the conference will include participants from an array of prestigious organisations and institutions. These include the Commission for Air Quality Management in National Capital Region and Adjoining Areas (CAQM), the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC), and the Environment Department, among others. Additionally, representatives from the India Meteorological Department (IMD), Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), and several other prominent bodies will also take part. Minister Rai emphasised the collaborative nature of the conference, stating, “This year the main objective of our government will be to control pollution through public participation.” He elaborated that the winter action plan will be crafted based on the insights and recommendations provided by these experts. “The future plan will be developed around dust pollution, pollution caused by vehicles, problem of stubble and garbage burning, industrial pollution, green war room and Green Delhi App, hotspots, real-time apportionment study, e-waste eco park, increasing green areas, promoting public awareness and public participation, ban on firecrackers and other focus points, establishing dialogue with the central government and neighbouring states,” Rai explained. The conference will be attended by officials from approximately 42 departments and experts from around 36 institutions. This broad-based engagement underscores the government’s commitment to addressing the multifaceted issue of air pollution in Delhi. “A Winter Action Plan will be prepared based on the suggestions from all environmental experts,” Rai assured. He further stated that the primary goal of the Round Table Conference is to create a robust and actionable strategy to tackle pollution. “On the suggestions of experts of the Round Table Conference, the Delhi Government will be able to take necessary steps to control the sources of pollution,” he added.

Despite heavy rain this monsoon, ‘good’ air day remains elusive

Though Gurgaon recorded a ‘good' air day on Tuesday, Delhi hadn't logged any such day this year, even after recording over 100mm of rainfall in a single day in the monsoon season. A ‘good' air day is one in which the Air Quality Index is between 0 and 50. So far this year, the lowest AQI was 53 in the ‘satisfactory' category on Aug 8. From Jan 1 to Aug 27, Delhi recorded 45 days when AQI was in the ‘satisfactory' category against 50 in 2023 during the same period. Monsoon months are often the cleanest because the rain helps wash out the pollutants. Delhi recorded 228.1mm of rainfall on June 28 and 107.6mm on Aug 1. The fact that so much rain wasn't able to give the city a ‘good' air day spurred Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director (research and advocacy), Centre for Science and Environment, to note, "This brings out the challenge of curbing the high level of emissions from concentrated pollution sources in this region. The scale of action is not matching up to the magnitude of the problem." Dipankar Saha, former head of CPCB's laboratory, added, "After the monsoon is over, winter conditions start setting in, so the immediate focus should be on reducing pollution at the source level." Data since CPCB started maintaining AQI records in 2015 shows that ‘good' air days occurred after intense spells of rain or during the Covid lockdown or when polluting activities were restricted. For instance, 2023 recorded just one ‘good' air day on Sept 10 with an AQI of 45 following rain and the restrictions imposed due to the G20 Summit. No ‘good' air days were recorded in 2015, 2016 and 2018, but Delhi enjoyed two such days in 2017 during the monsoon months on July 30 and 31. Similarly, two ‘good' air days were logged in 2019 when AQI touched 49 on two consecutive days: Aug 18 and 19. In 2020, Delhi saw five ‘good' air days, one in March during the Covid lockdown and four in Aug in the rainy season. The capital saw only one ‘good' air day in 2021 on Oct 18 when AQI dipped to 46 due to incessant rain in the city and neighbouring districts. Three such days were reported in 2022 in the months of Sept and Oct with rain again playing a crucial role in cleaning the air. Meanwhile, some parts of Delhi recorded light rain on Wednesday and IMD has issued a ‘yellow' alert for light to moderate showers on Thursday. Safdarjung, which is the city's base weather station, logged 2.4mm of rainfall from 8.30am to 5.30pm. The maximum temperature was 34 degrees Celsius. The minimum temperature stood at 23.4 degrees Celsius, three below normal.

Will clean Ganga flow in near future?

It is a top priority for the government and its national agenda, and is driven by none other than Prime Minister Modi’s missionary zeal. The Ganga would be clean by 2020, the government had said Almost 10 years since Prime Minister Modi promised a clean Ganga, the river continues to run polluted and people living in cities along the river might be drinking what is at best partially treated sewage, not Gangajal: says an assessment of the state of India’s most celebrated and revered river. The government has claimed that Ganga will be clean in 2019 (the deadline has now been extended to 2020). The assessment, done by Down To Earth, a “fortnightly on the politics of development, environment and health” which Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) helps publish, emphatically states that the river will continue to run as – and even more – polluted as ever. Why the Ganga will continue to flow polluted

Gurgaon records 'Good' air day after nearly 2 years!

GURGAON: The wait for a clean air day is a long one in NCR. But not usually this long. Tuesday was a spot of deep green in the pollution index - in other words, a 'good' air day, when AQI is below 50 - for the first time in 23 months. The 24-hour average AQI was 35 on Tuesday. The last time residents of Gurgaon woke up to a day when the AQI was 'good' was on Oct 10, 2022, when the day's average settled at 29. But was the air quality really 'good'? With data available from just one of the four stations in the city to calculate a 24-hour average for Tuesday, this is no telling if this is an accurate assessment of the pollution level. But it's the official data. Asked about just the Teri Gram station functioning, Haryana State Pollution Control Board (HSPCB) chairperson P Raghavendra Rao told TOI that the problems will be investigated.Nirmal Kashyap, HSPCB regional officer for Gurgaon, said a 12-hour power failure knocked out the station's readings in Vikas Sadan. The one at Gwal Pahari is maintained by central govt, and the Sector 51 station is down because of technical faults. Nonetheless, officials said, weather conditions and rain helped wash away pollutants from the air. The city logged 20.2mm of rainfall on Tuesday and wind speeds went up to a high of 20kmph, data by IMD showed. Noida too recorded a 'good' air day - with AQI 50 - on Tuesday. The last time Noida recorded a 'good' air day was Aug 13, when AQI was 46 and before that, on August 9, when it was at 48. Delhi recorded a 'satisfactory' air day, with AQI at 64. The last time the capital had a 'good' air day was almost a year ago, on Sept 10, 2023, when its AQI was 45. HSPCB officials said that other than most commonly found pollutants - particulate matter and toxic gases that are released from vehicles or industries - dust plays a significant role in deteriorating air quality in NCR, specifically during summer months and humid weather conditions. "Loose soil and wind directions in the Indo-Gangetic plain are natural sources of dust in the region, and this is compounded by vehicular traffic that suspends road dust and construction activities," said Vijay Chaudhary, HSPCB regional officer (Gurgaon south). Data showed that 2023 did not record any 'good' air days, even during monsoon. The lowest AQI recorded for a day last year was 62 on July 30. And 2022 recorded four 'good' air days. On Tuesday, experts said this data underscored the necessity of adopting long-term measures to mitigate air pollution over the year, and not just in the winter pollution season. "Cities with millions of inhabitants should not have to rely on weather conditions to breathe clean air. Urban areas need forest sinks to control pollution, green walling is needed against desertification, and ingress of dust and cleansing of toxic gases," said Shubhansh Tiwari, a research associate at the Centre for Science and Environment. A 2021 study by the Energy Policy Institute of the University of Chicago (EPIC) had said that residents of Gurgaon lose 9.9 years of their lives due to high exposure to pollution. The report also ranked Haryana fourth in the all-India list and said air pollution diminishes average life expectancy in the state by 8.4 years.

ABP LIVE To Host India Infrastructure Conclave 2024, Showcasing India’s Infrastructure Revolution

ABP LIVE, India’s leading digital news powerhouse, is all set to host the prestigious ABP LIVE India Infrastructure Conclave 2024, Honouring Excellence, on August 28 in New Delhi. The event will be a gathering of the most influential voices in India’s infrastructure sector, from government bodies and PSUs to private sector giants, all coming together to celebrate India’s groundbreaking achievements and chart the future of the nation’s infrastructure landscape. The event will be graced by the presence of Union Minister Nitin Gadkari as the Guest of Honour, alongside an impressive line-up of industry stalwarts. The speakers will include Harbhajan Singh E.T.O., Minister of Public Works and Power, Govt of Punjab, Lt. Gen. Raghu Srinivasan (VSM), Director General of Border Roads Organisation; Dr. Vibha Dhawan, Director General of TERI; Anumita Roychowdhury, Executive Director of the Centre for Science and Environment; Dr. Mohammed Rihan, Director General of the National Institute of Solar Energy; Dr. Sudeshna Chatterjee, Program Director (Research), WRI-India Ross Centre; and Prof. (Dr.) S P Gon Chaudhuri, Visiting Professor, IIEST and Eminent Scientist, and Dr. Shrivallabh Goyal, Director & Business Head, Reliance MET, among others. These thought leaders along with other distinguished experts from the field will engage in powerful panel discussions that promise to inspire and inform.

Traffic Jams in Indian Cities Are Slowly Becoming a Deadly Threat to Public Health. How Many More Lives Will Be Lost Before India’s Urban Congestion Crisis is Taken Seriously?

On August 21, 2024, in the morning, Rajender Singh was on his way to Ambala for a business meeting. A routine drive ended up being his end when Singh got stuck in what seemed to be a hotel after a flyover-building mess near Bilaspur on the Delhi-Jaipur highway. He added the drizzle to his already dissatisfying life that morning. Singh suffered a heart attack and was subsequently discovered dead behind the wheel of his car. The police, among whom was Sub-Inspector Om Prakash, confirmed that Singh had died of a heart attack that may have been induced or compounded by prolonged stress and physical inactivity within the traffic jam. Tragic incident: many questions are often raised about the safety and well-being of this increasing number of people getting entangled in the ever-worsening traffic conditions of Indian cities. It cannot be looked upon as an isolated event but part of a larger pattern in which the health impacts of traffic congestion are more and more witnessed. It has been found that people who are stuck in traffic for long hours at a stretch are prone to acute stress, developing high blood pressure and becoming susceptible to heart attacks. A 2021 ICMR report disclosed that people who have had exposure to over two hours a day in traffic had a 60% higher chance of getting cardiovascular diseases. Continuous jerking, coupled with breathing in vehicular pollution, disperses hazardous ambient conditions, drastically affecting the health conditions of those already suffering from some related problem. The burdensome experience of coming across heavy congestion, blaring horns, and generally unpredictable traffic can generate sudden stress reactions that lead to lost lives, as in the case of Rajender Singh. The Cause of Trouble Rapid urbanization in India has moved ahead with this country’s infrastructure, leading to bottlenecks in managing the traffic. Inadequacy in the transportation infrastructure of cities like Gurugram, which has rapid growth in population and vehicle ownership, is still using outdated road networks that are incapable of handling the tremendous volume of traffic. With no alternative transport system in place, like the most efficient public transit systems that exist in large numbers, people are forced to rely a lot on personal vehicles, further clogging the roads. The Delhi-Jaipur highway, the site of the Singh killing, is an important arterial road that is congested throughout the day. Though it is a national highway, traffic congestion prevails, especially at industrial points similar to Bilaspur, where the incident occurred. This has been succeeded by ongoing road work, with the whole place engulfed in traffic mismanagement, which has converted this national highway into a commuter’s nightmare. Urban Congestion Urban traffic congestion is one of the prolific contributors to many forms of pollution, already documented, like air and noise. However, the health implications related to cardiovascular diseases never get counted much. The TomTom Traffic Index 2022 ranks Indian cities atop its list of the most congested urban traffic, with Bangalore being the second most traffic-captured city worldwide. To drive only 5 kilometers during peak hours takes about 18 minutes and 40 seconds. This is not an inconvenience; it is a potential health hazard. Prolonged exposure to this vehicle emission due to traffic congestion contributes to respiratory and cardiac stress. Noise levels from continuous hooting and engine noise further increase the stress for people caught up in traffic, leading to hypertension and even heart attacks, as in the case of Rajender Singh. Traffic in India is no longer a convenience issue but an epidemic public health issue. To illustrate, vehicular emissions were identified as the single largest source of air pollution in Delhi, accounting for 51% of the city’s pollution, according to a Centre for Science and Environment study conducted in 2022. That figure doesn’t even consider the dust generated by roads and construction, both tied to the extensive use of motor vehicles. Noise pollution, another byproduct of this vehicular chaos, has reached unbearable levels. According to the United Nations Environment Programme, the cities of India are among the noisiest cities in the world; Muradabad in Uttar Pradesh is the second noisiest city in the world. Not only is this torture to the ears but also a severe health hazard, as excessive noise is stressful to the mind and body. It can also cause sleep disorientation and even raise blood pressure. This oversimplifies a storyline that could only be solved using electric vehicles. Electric vehicles do nothing to solve the problem of tire and brake wear pollution, identified by a UK report in 2023 as the chief source of pollution caused by road transport. Just 15% of vehicular air pollution is from the tailpipe; the rest is from the wear and tear the vehicle causes to tires, brakes, and the road surface. The situation becomes all the more different when the space cars occupy and take the city lane or parking space into consideration. According to the National Family Health Survey, NFHS-5, only 8% of Indian households own cars. And yet, that small percentage is choking our cities with their congestion. What chaos will be enacted if that number significantly grows? A car-centric attitude takes much more space per person than public transport, bicycles, or pedestrians, overfilling roads and almost pushing out from essential infrastructure places like parks and public spaces. Furthermore, car dependency amplifies another urban problem: flooding. The increasing concretization of urban spaces, which is driven by the growing need for parking more and more vehicles, does not allow rain to permeate into the ground, which results in flooding in the urban areas, especially during the monsoon. The most sobering aspect of India’s car culture is its deadly impact on road safety. According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), the daily average of road accident deaths in India is 422 per day—which is more than five times the daily murder rate. Because of the easy availability and affordability of private vehicles, this is a problem where the last segment, over-speeding, driving while being distracted, destructively blinking the lights and blowing horns, all play their part along with destructively lousy road conditions. Vehicular Emissions and Health It was estimated that vehicular emissions contributed to 51% of air pollution in Delhi, according to a study by the Centre for Science and Environment in 2022. The contribution of road dust and construction activity, which are directly related to vehicular traffic, further complicates the scenario. The same trends are observable in other major cities such as Mumbai, Bangalore, and Kolkata, where the problem of stubble burning is not there. Hence, vehicular emissions become the prime villain. Air pollution may relate to respiratory tract infections, lung cancer, and even heart diseases due to the delicate particulate matter suspended in the air (PM2.5). Prolonged exposure to such pollutants trapped in congestion may elevate these risks from developed conditions, making this simple commute life-threatening. Noise Pollution: The Invisible One. The United Nations Environment Programme report on the world’s noisiest cities identifies the South Asian cities, including those of Pakistan, India, Nepal, and Bangladesh, as standing at the top of the list. The noise of motor vehicles is the primary factor contributing to this noise pollution, causing the loss of hearing, depriving even the soulful of their sleep, and heightening stress among individuals. Chronic exposure to high noise levels can lead to long-term health issues, including cardiovascular diseases and mental health disorders. In the case of Rajender Singh, the combination of air and noise pollution, coupled with the stress of being trapped in a traffic jam, he likely created a lethal environment that precipitated his heart attack. Traffic Jams: A Silent Killer Traffic jams are no more irritating nuisances; they are silent killers. The physical and psychological stresses from being strapped in traffic jams for hours often result in a significant outcome of ill health. Observably, individuals who stay in traffic for long periods are likely to get different disorders, including stress-related ones, such as anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder, PTSD. The National Family Health Survey 5 (2019-2021) revealed that only 8% of Indian households owned cars, yet the traffic congestion is brutal. So, if that rises, imagine the scenario. There will be far more congestion in cities that might be more hazardous for mass health than usual. The tragic death of Rajender Singh should come as a much-needed wake-up call for the people responsible for policy decisions. The present pattern of urban development, with its ever-greater emphasis on constructing roads and vehicle-centric infrastructure, is unsustainable and dangerous to public health. Most developed countries have recognized the perils of urban congestion and have taken measures to keep a lid on the number of cars out there. Take the example of the Dutch cities, which, according to the lists, are now leading the most significant drop in traffic congestion globally and adding a stimulus to cycling and walking. Roads once jammed with parked cars are now open to pedestrians, reducing noise and air pollution — with all the following health benefits. These policies can also be implemented in India, which will, in turn, help reduce the burden of traffic congestion. For example, some places like market areas could ban the use of cars, as these are highly prone to congestion; instead, there would be public means and encourage it, as this could considerably reduce the congestion. In addition, enhanced metro networks with improved bus services could offer car owners viable alternatives to private car usage to reduce the number of vehicles on the road. The Role of Improved Public Awareness and Behavior Change Even though policy reform is critical, it is essential to couple this with public awareness and behavioral change. The general public should be empowered with knowledge of the health risks of traffic congestion and other benefits of using different modes of transport. Awareness and public attitude transformation campaigns can be undertaken to persuade the public to change their behavioral patterns. Similarly, the government could encourage electric vehicles and carpool and taxi-sharing systems, reducing the number of cars on the road. All such measures, together with improved programs of urban development and new infrastructure development, considerably contribute to reducing the impacts of this congestion. The death of Rajender Singh on the Gurugram highway is an ominous reminder that anything which in other circumstances would have just been a private tragedy hits roads, and it is a disaster for public health. This is quite huge given the threats to the physical and psychological health posed by traffic jams. In one sense, it green-flags policymakers to take immediate action to avoid not only the coming tragedies of the future but also as an imperative to settle life in cities. The demand for sustainable urban development, which will lessen the number of vehicles on the road and develop various alternative modes of transport, cannot be overemphasized. Traffic congestion threats need to be attenuated for a healthier and more livable city; this can only be done through policy changes, better awareness in the public sector, and people’s behavioral changes. This event is such a graphic demonstration that time, emissions, or even the actual price of traffic jams are not measured when considering it. It’s time for society to take a long, hard look at our urban infrastructure and make the necessary changes so that another tragedy does not occur. india

ABP LIVE To Host India Infrastructure Conclave 2024, Showcasing India’s Infrastructure Revolution

New Delhi: ABP LIVE, India’s leading digital news powerhouse, is all set to host the prestigious ABP LIVE India Infrastructure Conclave 2024, Honouring Excellence, on August 28 in New Delhi. The event will be a gathering of the most influential voices in India’s infrastructure sector, from government bodies and PSUs to private sector giants, all coming together to celebrate India’s groundbreaking achievements and chart the future of the nation’s infrastructure landscape. The event will be graced by the presence of Union Minister Nitin Gadkari as the Guest of Honour, alongside an impressive line-up of industry stalwarts. The speakers will include Harbhajan Singh E.T.O., Minister of Public Works and Power, Govt of Punjab, Lt. Gen. Raghu Srinivasan (VSM), Director General of Border Roads Organisation; Dr. Vibha Dhawan, Director General of TERI; Anumita Roychowdhury, Executive Director of the Centre for Science and Environment; Dr. Mohammed Rihan, Director General of the National Institute of Solar Energy; Dr. Sudeshna Chatterjee, Program Director (Research), WRI-India Ross Centre; and Prof. (Dr.) S P Gon Chaudhuri, Visiting Professor, IIEST and Eminent Scientist, and Dr.Shrivallabh Goyal, Director & Business Head, Reliance MET, among others. These thought leaders along with other distinguished experts from the field will engage in powerful panel discussions that promise to inspire and inform.

What is the role of Article 2.1c in advancing climate action?

By invitation only The Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) and ODI are pleased to co-host an online consultation, ‘What is the role of Article 2.1c in advancing climate action?’ This half-day virtual-only event is aimed at bringing together a range of relevant stakeholders to deliberate on what it means for financial flows to be consistent with low-emission, climate resilient development pathways in accordance with Article 2.1c of the Paris Agreement. It aims to foster honest dialogue on how the world’s financial systems and global capital can truly be aligned with climate goals, whilst upholding the principle of equity, and fostering a fair green transition for all, especially in the Global South. Description The Sharm el-Sheikh (SeS) dialogue on Article 2.1c and its complementarity with Article 9 has provided the much-needed space to deconstruct and assess some of the interpretations of this long-term finance goal and its interlinkages with other agenda items or multilateral institutions and processes. There is an urgent need to start to explore how to take Article 2.1c forward in the multilateral process, however, beyond dialogues. Through this consultation, CSE and ODI are keen to provide space to foster nuanced discussions, precipitate key challenges and opportunities of climate-consistency of finance flows. It is hoped that participants may build on the consultation discourse at the second workshop of 2024 of the UNFCCC Sharm el-Sheikh Dialogue on Article 2.1c to be held on October 6-7, 2024. The online consultation will deliberate on questions such as: ● What are the key actions and actors in scope of Article 2.1c according to your understanding of operationalising the Article? ● What guardrails are needed to ensure that all countries take equitable action towards Article 2.1c and adverse consequences, strain on administrative capacities and undue conditionalities are not felt by States, particularly those in the Global South? ● What immediate next steps can be taken by actors, or early-agreements made between actors, in order to ensure the Article 2.1c agenda advances in the multilateral agenda? By bringing together climate finance negotiators, representatives of Ministries of Finance and Central Banks, regulators, private finance experts, academia and civil society organisations, the co-hosts hope to ensure that the discourse going forward is balanced, and accounts for the concerns and aspirations of a wide variety of stakeholders. Article 2.1c The Paris Agreement outlines three major long term goals for addressing the climate challenge. It emphasises the need to ensure planetary warming does not exceed 1.5°C, and that global temperature rise remains well below 2°C; it highlights the need to enhance global adaptation capacity for low emissions development without threatening food security; and, lastly, it provides what is called informally by some as the long-term finance goal, i.e., Article 2.1c of the Paris Agreement that aims at enhancing the implementation of the UNFCCC and respond to the global climate crisis, in the context of sustainable development, by “(c) Making finance flows consistent with a pathway towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate-resilient development.” While the UNFCCC and the Paris Agreement both call upon developed countries to provide financial resources to developing countries for climate action, Article 2.1c is seen by some as the broader goal for making a shift in finance flows at a global and more systemic level. This is important given finance is a key enabler of climate action. For countries to implement ambitious climate pledges, access to finance from all actors needs to be improved greatly and this is facilitated (or hindered) by actors of the global financial system and international financial architecture and their actions, via rules, regulations, policies and more. As the provision of climate finance for developing countries so far has been inadequate, unevenly distributed and not necessarily reflective of the financing needs of vulnerable countries, complementary and more systems level action on financing could further facilitate the scaling and impact of climate finance provision. However, the interpretation of climate-consistent finance flows within the climate negotiations are fraught. Positions of developed countries and developing countries can have stark divergences as to what is in scope in these discussions. Most significantly, the latter fear the use of Article 2.1c as a means to shirk responsibility of obligations of providing climate finance, even if the premise of making all finance climate-consistent is considered a worthy pursuit. Even in the real-world implementation of Article 2.1c by financial stakeholders such as pension funds, institutional investors, development aid agencies, asset managers and central banks, clarity and consensus on objective and equitable progress is not yet within reach. The UNFCCC itself does not provide any guardrails either, for what may not be considered climate-consistent financial flows or how various actors in the financial system may cooperate to see benefits. About CSE The Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), is a public interest, not-for-profit, research and advocacy organisation based in New Delhi, India. It has been well known for influencing the design of international climate policy since well before such policy was enshrined in formal institutions - whether it is the landmark paper released in 1991 by Sunita Narain and Anil Agarwal, calling for a decolonisation of carbon budget accounting, or CSE’s commentary on every UN climate meeting since 1992. CSE has led the discourse in climate policy for over three decades advocating for equity, the principle of Common but Differentiated Responsibilities, and investing in resilient economies for the poor. CSE's Climate Change Programme is committed to championing the study of the most pressing climate issues relevant for the Global South. Our publications on climate-critical topics, our presence at UNFCCC proceedings such as COP summits and Subsidiary Body meetings, public outreach and advocacy, media engagement, and training programmes are designed to create multipliers in society for climate action. About ODI ODI is a global affairs think tank. We focus on research, convening and influencing, to generate ideas that matter for people and planet. For queries, please contact Avantika Goswami, Programme Manager, Climate Change, CSE avantika.goswami@cseindia.org Charlene Watson, Senior Research Associate, Climate and Sustainability, ODI c.watson@odi.org.uk

A City Undone: Joining the Dots of Delhi’s Drainage Debacle

The 2024 monsoon in India has resulted in widespread death, damage, and loss of property, intensifying a trend seen over the past 2-3 years where urban flooding has almost become endemic in many regions. Landslides have taken a heavy toll, leaving once pristinely beautiful landscapes scarred. When things begin to happen that are far removed from what is considered normal – destroying lives, including those of animals and birds native to an area, as well as decimate hard won properties and desecrate landscapes – some might take it as fate’s vagaries, but worried citizens should begin to join the dots. Some of the more mundane causes – such as the failure to desilt urban drains, excessive paving over of our cities, unchecked urban sprawl with unauthorised constructions on former farmlands or lake beds – or even major causes like gouging the fragile Himalayas to build pilgrimage-oriented highways, irresponsible development in the equally fragile Western Ghats in Kerala, with mining activities alongside heavy tourism-oriented constructions, and unthinking riverfront concretising “developments” in many riverside towns or cities – are all very easy for an informed layperson to spot. However, there may be other, unobvious causes that may be escaping us that worsen matters. Some of these could be assumed as the root causes of the Delhi floods this year that not only led to loss of possessions but also claimed lives. The imputed cost in man-hours of time lost in stalled traffic, or street-side next to one’s car with a flooded engine, is yet to be calculated and would possibly yield a mind-boggling figure. The advent of monsoon, once an eagerly anticipated event in this city and country – with a whole sub-sections of semi-classical music devoted to extolling its virtues – has now become a dreaded season of loss and woe. However, when we consider our own local areas within Delhi, the relative lack of change in many parts of the city might not seem to provide a sufficient explanation for the increasing local flooding year after year. Maintenance and repair have never been the strong suit of our authorities, and urban sprawl has continued unchecked for decades. Taking the example of Vasant Kunj and its surroundings, which I have known for about 30 years, relatively little has changed here. If anything, there have been marked improvements – citizen bodies have led greening drives, removed paving around many trees to allow rainwater percolation, and preserved all parks and open spaces, with which this locality and its environs are richly endowed by the master planners. In fact, these spaces have been enhanced over the last few decades, as seen in the development of Sanjay Van, with its large new interconnected natural water filtration and percolation bodies, the Aravalli Biodiversity Park established a couple of decades ago, and the more recent Neela Hauz project. Other than being built on the water-absorbing and conserving Aravalli Ridge, Vasant Kunj’s natural elevation lies well above areas to the north towards the Yamuna and should naturally drain. Yet, flooding in Vasant Kunj and its environs seems to have increased over the past few years. Geological map of Delhi. Photo: Chatteerjee et al 2009 Delhi, over the last few years, has seen unprecedented flooding of Rajpath and its very green, water-absorbing environs – which lie a mere 2 kms upslope from the river – the floods this year even reached Lutyens’ Delhi, impacting homes set in large gardens housing senior legislators. This year’s record rains led to water ingress and significant damage to personal belongings in homes across diverse localities, sparing no one – from the tony, verdant Golf Links and park-endowed Defence Colony (also just a few kms upslope from the river) to the dense, congested areas of Dakshinpuri and Yamuna paar. Ingress of this magnitude has never occurred in the worst of monsoons since these localities were inhabited more than five to seven decades ago. Additionally, very low-density upscale localities like Friends Colony West, a stone’s throw from the river, now experience damaging floods. Considering that all these areas in larger central Delhi, east of the ridge, lie on a riverine drainage plain that naturally slopes towards the river, the events of this year seem to defy all logic. Additionally, each and every road in Delhi seems to get flooded even during moderately heavy rains, ruining car engines, stalling traffic and causing at least a stray death or three in flooded under-passes or illegal basement libraries. Flooding destroyed government officials’ cars parked in the basements of their new flats at New Kidwai Nagar. The old, low-scale government housing in the same location never saw such a thing. Additionally, the frequent flooding of the new Pragati Maidan underpass – which connects to the New Bharat Mandapam’s massive 40 acre underground parking basement – throws the massive flow of Delhi to Noida traffic that has taken to using it, out of kilter for miles around. It may be time Delhi’s residents began to join the dots, especially if they aren’t among those who can escape to live elsewhere when this city’s infrastructure totally collapses, like its air quality already has. A list of additions to our cityscape over the last few decades – The metro: whose arrival we all welcomed, and that undoubtedly saves many hours of commuting time while reducing carbon emissions and polluting fumes of thus avoided road traffic. But in many stretches, the metro runs deep underground while in others it has led to the hard asphalt paving over of previously water absorbing open space to provide for parking lots and pedestrian approach. – The rampant densification of relatively inner city lands as part of the G.P.R.A. (Government Pool Residential Accommodation) redevelopment, which encompasses vast tracts of south-central Delhi, including Kidwai Nagar, Naoroji Nagar, Netaji Nagar, and Sarojini Nagar, among others. These areas once featured rainwater-absorbing open spaces with slightly shabby, low-density government housing, where a few thousand now-dead trees used to flourish but now have massive buildings with double and triple basements. – The ill-conceived Central Vista project, which attempts to aggregate nearly 60,000 government employees into the heart of this beleaguered capital, has not only broken rules and shattered precedents but also caused 1,838 magnificent water sequestering trees to be removed in just the first phase. These trees, on the erstwhile I.G.N.C.A. campus, that now houses three of 10 proposed office buildings, were part of an inviolable deemed forest. What is worse, a third of the erstwhile Rajpath’s water percolating lawns have been paved to make way for parking space after the removal of another 70 trees. We have just seen the tragicomic spectacle of flooding within our venerated parliament premises, possibly thanks to the extensive hard paving around a huge new parliament building that replaces the green areas of what was once an inviolable park in the master plan of Delhi, from which we have lost 404 venerable trees. – The equally ill-conceived Bharat Mandapam on Pragati Maidan, which could have come up anywhere on the city’s outskirts and possibly rejuvenated some neglected peri-urban area, needlessly replaced what was already an exposition centre in use. The project not only resulted in the demolitions of the Hall of Nations, one of India’s most significant and internationally acclaimed modern heritage buildings, but also led to massive paving over of a once relatively verdant soft scape. To make matters worse, the city’s bureaucrats and planners, while rushing through the afore-mentioned adjacent and allied Pragati Maidan underpass, forgot to plan adequate drainage for it. The result: an annually flooded, and thus useless, underpass which connects to the Mandapam’s flooded 40-acre basement which, coupled with the increased paving, effectively stops all rain water percolation over that vast area. One only has to examine the site on Google Earth to know this. Google Earth view of Bharat Mandapam campus. Photo: Author provided. – The newly proliferating traffic underpasses, such as the massive and long-delayed Ashram underpass, constructed in areas with high water tables. If we consider that traffic underpasses, like the one at Minto Bridge, used to flood every year, it seems we are only adding to the problem by building half a dozen more each year. It is happening most likely because no other expedient solution presents itself to the city’s planners for accommodating the increasing car and two-wheeler traffic, which is driven by growing population pressure. This population increase is itself a result of the utter neglect of the hinterlands and rural areas, causing the poor to swarm into the city in search of a living—no matter how miserable. Additionally, young educated people in need of jobs crowd into the city because few second-tier cities offer adequate or well-compensated employment, while this one still might. – The recent planning permissions, given with poorly concealed avarice to make money off developers, in hitherto open farmlands, to be developed as hotels and elaborately constructed wedding venue complexes. Now complete with acres of hard-paved parking along all roads radiating out of Delhi to neighbouring towns, these lands once served as a sponge for rain water. The same planning bodies now envisage one-acre “farms” – a misnomer for lavish, paved suburban homes that replace real farmlands – and are also busy rezoning the Green Belt of agricultural land, that once surrounded this city as a buffer, into high-rise residential areas. This Green Belt was originally designed by our first master planners, who adopted the best practices of the vilified Angrez in their London master plan. Instead of creating a vast, continuous paved urban sprawl, they could have developed new areas in more distant hinterlands within and outside the NCR, seeding new sub-cities and employment opportunities, separated from the inner city by open percolation spaces and connected by high-speed commuter lines, as seen in cities like Hong Kong with similar vast open hinterlands. Delhi’s drainage patterns Let us now segue into the hydrology and drainage patterns of the New Delhi region West of the Yamuna. As visible in the map above, the Delhi Ridge arcs around the central and southern parts of the city – from the Northern Ridge near Delhi University to Rashtrapati Bhavan and the diplomatic area in the West, through Vasant Kunj in the Southwest, and all the way to Asola Bhatti and Tughlakabad in the East. This curve contains almost all of the affected areas mentioned above and is a large riverine alluvial basin plain, hemmed in by the elevated ridge from almost three sides, and sloping towards the river. It is not stretching imagination to believe that, as with surface water, there is possibly massive subterranean flow throughout this region towards the Yamuna. And now one begins to connect the dots: could it be that the many underground interventions over the last two decades are acting as underground dams, blocking the flow from the Ridge to the Yamuna, exacerbating what the gradual increase in paved, hard-scape areas have already done? New Delhi metro routes. First the underground metro lines crossing the central NDMC area, aka Lutyens’ Delhi, albeit West of India Gate. Have the Pragati Maidan underpass and Bharat Mandapam’s huge basement effectively encircled the area restricting the flow, with the pedestrian underpasses of the Central Vista under Rajpath adding to it? This may explain the floods on Rajpath, the New Parliament, the Mandapam basement, the underpass itself, Bhairon Marg etc, but probably with effects stretching till recently flooded Golf Links which is anyway hemmed in by the metro on its East? The residents of Greater Kailash Part II, otherwise on the water soaking ridge, can easily correlate the construction of Delhi metro’s underground Magenta Line to the unprecedented flooding of basements of their homes. That the new King’s Court apartment complex in this locality – built squarely over an ancient drainage channel as per an informed source – recently had the thick concrete of its basement raft slab bulging remarkably, shows the sheer power of the restricted subterranean water, as does the similarly bulging concrete in the underground parking lot of one of Aerocity’s hotels. The flooded basements of the New Kidwai Nagar government housing towers, overlooking one of Delhi’s major junctions at AIIMS, are more easily explained now. They probably act as a dam for subterranean water flow from the the Ridge at the Diplomatic Enclave to the Yamuna, and shoddy National Buildings Construction Corporation (NBCC) supervised construction has done the rest to allow in the deluge. The residents of Friends Colony West and Defence Colony, for the first time this year, saw rainwater enter the ground floors of their homes, destroying heirloom furniture and prized old carpets. While the Defence Colony residents blame the covering of the central Kushak nahar, now popularly called a nallah for obvious reasons, which is a major tributary of the drainage channel of Delhi, the Barapullah nahar. The former now probably lies choked in its invisibility and rendered inaccessible. Shockingly, no environmental clearance was ever received for covering it. Could the Ashram flyover this year have compounded the issues caused by the nahar’s choking by providing yeat another easterly dam? Is it possible that neither the current administration – in its numerous infrastructure and land monetisation projects over the last decade – nor the previous administration, before initiating projects like the underground metro, ever commissioned a study to understand the city’s overall hydrology and geology? Such a study would have identified what could be done within the city, what should be avoided, and, if necessary, alternative methods to address critical issues. The last decade alone has seen major infrastructure and construction carried out by a government that prides itself on “getting work done” to achieve “world class” infrastructure. The metro is supposed to have taken good care, at least on paper, running deep enough to at least not impede immediate subsurface flow, with inspection wells around at least each station to be able to study sub-soil water levels, according to the very informed domain expert source. Although, he wryly agreed that since we, as a nation, are not known for construction quality prowess or adherence to the written rule book, it is anyone’s guess whether everything actually works as originally conceptualised. What system of checks and balances did the system have to ensure the citizen’s interests could be protected from the vagaries of politicians and their ever-willing bureaucrats who neither dare nor care to state possibly better informed perspectives? Could this have been prevented? It so happens that India has a system to prevent such ‘development’ which may have a negative impact on the environment and ecology in the long run. Since 1994, environmental impact assessments (EIAs) have been mandated under the Environmental (Protection) Act of 1986 –updated in 2006 and 2020 – which covers every large-scale developmental intervention, including the infrastructure projects in question here. This much-acclaimed legislation was designed to protect our environment, both urban and rural, from the shortsightedness and venality exhibited by our planners, bureaucrats and politicians, and to prevent potential disasters. The policy calls for multidisciplinary impact assessment studies to be carried out by domain experts in fields as varied as geology, hydrology and seismic studies to social impact, traffic impact, pollution related factors and innumerable other factors that could result from every ill-conceived infrastructure project. It also requires the government to hold public hearings, allowing potentially affected citizens to voice their concerns. These hearings are intended to give project proponents the opportunity to address these concerns with hard facts or to modify the proposal based on highly localised, experience-based knowledge. Implicit in the requirement for these EIAs is the need for ground-truthing of available maps, which should be updated to reflect current circumstances using geospatial mapping tools that have supposedly been available for nearly two decades as part of the National GIS Mission. “The Indian experience with Environmental Impact Assessment began…in 1976-77 when the Planning Commission asked the Department of Science and Technology to examine the river-valley projects from an environmental angle. This was subsequently extended to cover those projects, which required the approval of the Public Investment Board. Till 1994, environmental clearance from the Central Government was an administrative decision and lacked legislative support. On 27 January 1994, the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests (MEF), Government of India, under the Environmental (Protection) Act 1986, promulgated an EIA notification making Environmental Clearance (EC) mandatory for expansion or modernisation of any activity or for setting up new projects listed in Schedule 1 of the notification,” writes the Centre for Science and Environment. By this logic, every one of the projects in discussion here should have been subjected to rigorous, multidisciplinary and in-depth studies studying its impact both in the short and long term. Studies and analyses of topography, geology, hydrology and local ecology, other than surrounding habitation patterns, traffic impacts and many other such things affected by any large project should have been conducted. However, the dangers posed by the political establishment are evident. For example, the Rajasthan Wildlife Board went as far as allowing mining in a protected sanctuary to further sandstone supplies for the Ayodhya Ram Mandir, while the Union government moved to allow commercial mining of all kinds within reserve forests without even consulting local communities – a policy currently under reconsideration. How reliable are EIAs? Citizens would therefore place their trust on the EIA’s efficacy alone and believe that the independent experts who comprise the EIA committee would watch out for them. However, like most things in India, well-framed norms are largely observed in breach, including when it comes to the quality of data given to agencies preparing EIAs or even other government reports. Nearly 10 years ago, scientists at IIT-Delhi were commissioned by the Delhi government to prepare a Drainage Master Plan for the Union territory. However, it was discovered that no actual comprehensive, cogent and coordinated maps of the terrain of Delhi are available with either the Union or Delhi government. Moreover, the government was not willing to spare funds to enable actual ground-truthing of maps which, currently, show natural drainage channels flowing from lower elevations to higher ones and depict drainage channels as disconnected lines instead of tributaries that join together and flow into the Yamuna through well known drain channels like the Barapullah Nahar. Any geospatial mapping done or available is exclusively the one that maps private properties to levy property tax. And thus the Drainage Report submitted by IIT-D is full of caveats to state that these are their best discernible findings, adding that the data they received was incomplete. “It is important to convey that under some situations, recourse to interpolation, engineering judgement, etc. was taken to make the data worthy of simulation,” the report says. The report goes on to add, “It is possible that many of the data elements, that have not been independently validated by the respective departments, may be different on ground than the digital reality captured and used in the model”. And noting that “the administrative authority of the capital’s drainage system is quixotically distributed amongst numerous civic bodies and various constituent departments of Government of NCT of Delhi as well as Government of India…It is indeed noteworthy that while water logging is a frequent occurrence in the NCT of Delhi, the various agencies responsible for management of the storm water drainage neither follow the practice nor are they mandated by legislation to prepare formal records of the extent of inundation reported from various parts of the capital territory. ” From this, the common citizen can easily discern that no one truly knows, or cares, how this city actually drains now, especially after the proliferation of unauthorised constructions over vast areas. As a result, instead of relying on Indian agencies and our best educational institutions – who may tell the truth about the data they receive, as well as the speciousness of the project proposal – the government prefers to pay eight-digit US dollar fee to multinational agencies to prepare highly dubious EIA Reports based on inadequate data. These reports are designed to please the government that commissions them. No bureaucrat dares to contradict their political masters, and the resultant assessment, on the basis of which the project is passed. An example of this is the report concerning Sarojini Nagar Redevelopment, which shockingly described the locality as situated on the Punjab and Haryana border. The “drainage map” shows disjointed channels lying around at odd angles all over Delhi, none connecting to the Yamuna, and little dots representing habitations make the city seem just a little more populated than the Thar desert. The reports lists “villages around the site” cited to be faraway parliament street and Connaught Place. The report claims that “there will be no change in land use,” despite the project envisioning around 600 shops in a mall and large commercial buildings among the housing high-rises. While 11,000 trees have been cut or transplanted for this single GPRA scheme, the EIA report casually mentions that there will be “some clearing of vegetation in order to prepare the site for construction.” This is a synonym for slow killing trees in Delhi as barely 20-30% of transplanted trees survive, according to the government’s own admission. This clearly shows that these compliant agencies are not just ‘yes men’ but thoroughly incompetent as well. At a time when there is growing awareness of changing climate and the likelihood of even more extreme weather events in the future, it seems time that we need to urge governments to pause and course correct their expedient endeavours, that we too may have unthinkingly applauded. However, there is a section of our society today that views any criticism of governmental “development” plans as being of “leftist” persuasion and “anti-development.” The debate between conservation on the one hand, and expedient “development” or resource extraction on the other, is indeed a contested area. However, while it is in the nature of modern humans to be extractive, a wise person would look to the future. Such a person would forsake methods that yield only 1% of their gold in a mine while the rest is washed away as sludge, and would instead explore more efficient extraction methods that not only keep themselves and their immediate kin in luxury for their lifetime but also leave enough for their proverbial “next seven generations.” It may be time for us, as citizens, to connect the dots of current events and do what we can as it is our own lives and property at stake. Narayan Moorthy is an architect and principal at Kumar Moorthy & Associates based in New Delhi.

टारगेट से पीछे चल रही पीएम कुसुम योजना पर मेहरबान हुई सरकार, सोलर प्लांट लगाने के लिए फंडिंग की दिक्कत नहीं होगी

पीएम कुसुम योजना के जरिए ग्रामीण इलाकों में सोलर प्लांट लगाकर बिजली और सिंचाई की व्यवस्था की जा रही है. यह योजना 2025 में पूरी होनी है, लेकिन अभी तक 100 फीसदी टारगेट का केवल 30 फीसदी ही हासिल किया जा सकता है. वह भी सिंचाई के लिए किसानों ने तो सोलर प्लांट लगाए हैं, लेकिन बिजली की बिक्री करने के लिए ग्रिड लगाने में रुचि कम देखी जा रही है. केंद्र सरकार ने इसकी वजह को टटोलकर आज बुधवार को बड़ी घोषणा करते हुए पीएम कुसुम योजना को एग्रीकल्चर इंफ्रा फंड (AIF) में शामिल कर दिया है. इससे किसानों को सोलर प्लांट लगाने के लिए अब फंडिंग की किल्लत का सामना नहीं करना पड़ेगा. आईटी व संसदीय मामलों के मंत्री अश्‍विनी वैष्‍णव ने बुधवार को नई दिल्ली में केंद्रीय कैबिनेट की बैठक के फैसलों की जानकारी दी. उन्होंने बताया कि पीएम मोदी के किसान की आर्थिकि रूप में मजबूत बनाने की दिशा में पीएम कुसुम योजना को एग्रीकल्चर इंफ्रास्ट्रक्चर फंड (AIF) में शामिल किया है. एग्रीकल्चर इंफ्रास्ट्रक्चर फंड का कॉर्पस 1 लाख करोड़ रुपये का है, जिससे योजना के लाभार्थियों को प्लांट लगाने के लिए फंडिंग की व्यवस्था की जा सकेगी. पीएम कुसुम के लिए एग्री इंफ्रा फंड से पैसा देने की घोषणा केंद्रीय मंत्री अश्‍विनी वैष्‍णव ने कहा कि पीएम किसान योजना के तहत किसान अपने खेत पर सोलर प्लांट लगाकर जो बिजली पैदा होगी उसे ग्रिड में बेच सकते हैं. इस योजना के लाभार्थियों को कंपोनेट ए के तहत निवेश को लेकर दिक्कत आ रही थी. इस दिक्कत को दूर करने के लिए इस योजना को एग्री इंफ्रा फंड में शामिल कर लिया गया है. उन्होंने कहा कि पीएम कुसुम योजना के तहत सोलर प्लांट लगाने के लिए अब फंडिंग की समस्या दूर होगी, क्योंकि इसे एग्रीकल्चर इंफ्रा फंड (AIF) में शामिल कर लिया गया है. यानी अब सोलर प्लांट लगाने के लिए किसान को पैसे की किल्लत नहीं झेलनी पड़ेगी. पीएम कुसुम की 2 कैटेगरी पर किसानों की रुचि नहीं केंद्र सरकार ने पीएम कुसुम योजना को 3 कैटेगरी में बांटा है. पहली कैटेगरी के तहत बंजर जमीन पर मिनी ग्रिड लगाना. दूसरी कैटेगरी के तहत डीजल सिंचाई पंपों को ऑफग्रिड सौर पंपों से बदलना. तीसरी कैटेगरी के तहत बिजली से चलने वाले सिंचाई पंपों को ऑनग्रिड सौर पंपों से बदलना और एग्रीकल्चर सोलर के लिए मिनीग्रिड लगाना. इसमें से दूसरी कैटेगरी का लाभ किसान ले रहे हैं. लेकिन, बाकी 2 कैटेगरी को लेकर रुचि कम देखी गई है. इसके चलते अब तक केवल 30 फीसदी टारगेट ही हासिल किया जा सका है. डीजल पंप किसान सोलर प्लांट में स्विच हुए सेंटर फॉर साइंस एंड एनवायरनमेंट (CSE) की इसी महीने अगस्त में आई रिपोर्ट में बताया गया कि पीएम कुसुम योजना के जरिए जिन किसानों ने सौर सिंचाई पंपों पर स्विच किया है वे खुश हैं. डीजल से सोलर पंप पर स्विच करने वाले किसान काफी बचत करते हैं. हरियाणा के कुछ किसान सालाना 55,000 रुपये तक की बचत करते हैं. लेकिन, पीएम कुसुम योजना की दूसरी कैटेगरी और तीसरी कैटेगरी के तहत प्लांट को लगाने में फंडिंग दिक्कतों के चलते किसान रुचि नहीं दिखा पा रहे थे. अब एग्री इंफ्रा फंड से पैसे की किल्लत दूर होने का रास्ता खुला है. ऐसे में उम्मीद की जा रही है कि योजना को रफ्तार मिल सकती है.