Oil price spike boosts India's ethanol drive amid Middle East conflict; experts warn of impact on fuel efficiency
India is seeing a push to further increase the amount of ethanol in petrol as oil prices surge due to the conflict in the Middle East, even as the ambitious national biofuel programme may hold back efforts to cut pollutants. Ethanol, made from crops such as sugarcane, rice and maize, is central to India's plan to cut costly oil imports and reduce planet-heating emissions from transport. Under the government programme, state-run oil companies mix 20% ethanol with each litre of petrol before it reaches the fuel pumps. India reached its target of 20% ethanol fuel, known as E20, last year, five years ahead of schedule, despite a backlash from drivers complaining of reduced fuel efficiency and increased engine wear. Prime Minister Narendra Modi said in March that ethanol blending had helped reduce crude import dependence during the U.S. and Israeli war with Iran. Transport Minister Nitin Gadkari has called for even higher blends, such as 85% ethanol, and for vehicles to eventually run entirely on the fuel. India is the world's third largest crude importer with some 85% of its oil needs met through imports. The government's drive to raise blending levels stems from a desire to cut its crude import bill and boost energy security. India currently also has a surplus ethanol production capacity. But experts warn a clear, long-term strategy for decarbonising transport is lacking and could bring trade-offs on efficiency, water use and the climate. Risks of ethanol After rolling out E20 petrol nationwide, the government has set up an inter-ministerial panel to explore ways to use surplus ethanol production capacity, including raising blending levels. Ethanol producers are pushing for higher targets and wider adoption of flex-fuel vehicles, capable of running on high levels of ethanol. Researchers looking at India's transport sector warn the benefits are more constrained as blending levels rise. "Higher blending can cut oil imports, but not as much as often claimed," said Shyamasis Das, a fellow at the Centre for Social and Economic Progress, a public policy think tank. Ethanol has roughly a third less energy per litre than pure gasoline, requiring vehicles to burn more fuel to generate the same power, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. This limits the extent to which blended fuels can reduce the demand for oil, Das said. "Ethanol blending is not the most effective way to reduce emissions or improve fuel efficiency in transport," said Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director at the Centre for Science and Environment, a Delhi-based think tank. The biofuel reduces greenhouse gas emissions, but coughs out other pollutants, said Roychowdhury. "While some pollutants may fall, others like nitrogen oxides can increase, and burning ethanol also produces toxic emissions such as carbonyl compounds," Roychowdhury said. She said that India would need to introduce regulations, like those in Brazil, which also uses high levels of ethanol to power vehicles, but regulates emissions of toxic compounds such as acetaldehyde and formaldehyde.
