The tale of 21st century’s dinosaurs | Centre for Science and Environment


Sunita Narain

Director General of CSE and publisher of Down To Earth, an environmentalist pushing for changes in policies and  practices and mindsets. More>>

The tale of 21st century’s dinosaurs

Have you noticed how the mighty automobile industry in the US is beginning to sound like the now infamous tobacco industry at the time of its collapse, taking cover behind the people it employed to whitewash its inefficiency and perhaps its sheer inappropriateness? The tobacco industry, in its last days of conviction, when it became clear that the science of toxicity of this leaf was real, hid behind farmers who grew it. It argued (as it still does in India) that if cigarettes went out of favour, it would destroy the livelihood of thousands who toiled in the fields, as also its workers and ancillary infrastructure. Of course, nothing like that happened. The farmers switched to another crop.

Today, Detroit’s three big guys—General Motors (GM), Ford, Chrysler—are wrangling before the US Congress for a US $30 billion bailout. And even though they face tough going to explain why they deserve this massive injection of funds, when they missed all the signs to reinvent their business towards fuel efficiency, influential senators have made it clear, “bankruptcy is not an option.” The reason is the scare of unemployed workers in the plants, car dealer networks and all others enjoined to this business of mobility, which lost sight of its purpose somewhere down the road.

Not so long ago, cigarette manufacturers of the US were creating desirable symbols of macho growth. Then the car took over. Just compare the image of the Marlboro man, astride his horse, the monarch of all the rugged land he surveyed, with the General Motors man—this time, riding in his massive sports utility vehicle, mowing through the wilds. We forgot that the vehicle was only a machine that needed to get us from one place to another.

Now the companies are in trouble. GM of Buick and Cadillac fame has even told the US Congress that it is on the verge of insolvency and will not be able to pay its suppliers beginning next month. This car trouble is not confined to the US alone. European automakers have called for a US $50 billion aid package of their own; Australia has already passed a US $2.3 billion aid package and even Chinese carmakers are now begging Beijing for help. Remember, we are talking of different worlds, but more or less the same companies. In 2005, five multinational car companies—GM, Ford, Toyota, Volkswagen and Daimler Chrysler—produced about half of all motor vehicles in the world.

There are many issues that plague these companies, but two are most important. One, it is widely agreed (even in auto circles) that there is massive production over-capacity; this means companies are making something that is not needed. It is no surprise then, with recession at people’s door, they have shut out this non-essential purchase. Already sales are down—in October this year, auto sales plunged 32 per cent in the US and 15 per cent in Europe compared with October of 2007. Business analysts now expect US sales to drop another 30 per cent in 2009 as banks foreclose on the credit that people have taken to buy their new dream machines. In this situation of glut-capacity, surplus is predicted to hit 30 per cent—or a staggering 29 million vehicles in 2009.

Two, they completely ignored the writing on the wall that fuel efficiency was the business of the future. In fact, US car manufacturers continue to produce, what can easily be called, the world’s most fuel-guzzling machines on the road. They have been so out of touch that even after the price of fuel increased, the auto companies responded with lollipops for buyers—free fuel coupons for limited periods (this was also done by their variants in India). That the three company heads took three company jets to fly to the Congress hearing from the same city only shows how out of sync they are with the times. No wonder American public opinion has turned against its superheroes.

And be clear that our Indian heroes are in the same super league. Two years ago, under pressure from environmental organizations, the government agreed to set up a committee to mandate fuel efficiency. But the automobile companies ganged up, refused to give data on their current fuel efficiency and asked for a long-term research to establish the baseline. Then when the Bureau of Energy Efficiency, mandated to set standards for energy conservation, finalized the norms, the companies launched a new attack. They said the vehicle was not an ‘appliance’—and so the Bureau could not set standards for them. At a meeting two months ago, in a move that spoke clearly of the tremendous clout of the industry, the Prime Minister’s Office gave in and passed on the job to the ministry of surface transport. This ‘promoter’ ministry has done its master proud. It has revised and weakened the fuel efficiency standards set by the Bureau but said status quo should continue till 2015 at the very least. Ridiculous.

What amazes me is they never seem to learn, even as our industry gets ready like its mighty US counterparts to go out with a begging bowl to the government for a bailout. This is possibly because they never listen. Today, even with the credit-tsunami, industry leaders and their sycophants in the finance world are all saying, “we never saw this coming”. The reason is simple. The Davos-glitterati has no space for opinions from outside its gilded doors. They have no space for opinions they do not agree with—certainly, no time for discordant or inconvenient voices; the most elitist of elite clubs.

But is this not why dinosaurs too lost the battle against change? Are we now looking at 21st century’s greatest extinction stories—the death of the modern dino?

—Sunita Narain

Follow us on 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
gobar times