How transparent are our pollution control boards?

CSE’s new rating report finds most are not 

Odisha, Telangana, Tamil Nadu and Madhya Pradeshboards/committees rated the most transparent among 35 such organisations studied 

  • Report assesses how actively boards display and disclose keyenvironment and governance-related information in the public domain
  • CSE has rated 35 pollution control boardsand committees based on information furnished in the public domain under 25 parameters-- only 17 have scored grades above 50 percent
  • Report also highlights a lack of uniformity in the display of the available information 

To download a copy of the CSE report Click here

New Delhi, August 12, 2021: A majority of India’s pollution control agencies remain closed entities when it comes to sharing information with the public. A new rating study by Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) has found that a mere handful of India’s pollution control boards and authorities are adequately putting out environmental and governance information intothe public domain. 

TRANSPARENCY INDEX: Rating of pollution control boards on public disclosure – as the study is titled –has assessed the data disclosure performance of 29 state pollution control boards (PCBs) and six pollution control committees from across the country. Of these, only 17 boards and committees scored 50 per cent or above. These 17 are from Odisha, Telangana, Tamil Nadu, Madhya Pradesh, West Bengal, Goa, Karnataka, Haryana, Chhattisgarh, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir, Kerala, Maharashtra, Uttarakhand, Punjab, Andhra Pradesh and Rajasthan. 

Says Nivit Kumar Yadav, programme director, Industrial Pollution Unit, CSE: “State PCBs are entrusted with several functions under the provisions of the Water Act, 1974; Air Act, 1981; Water Cess Act, 1977; and various rules and notifications issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. One of these functions under Section 17(C) of the Air and Water Acts is to collect and disseminate information related to air and water pollution and also about its prevention, control or abatement. The law asks the boards to share the data in public domain. But this is rarely done in practice.” 

Shreya Verma, programme officer, Industrial Pollution Unit, CSE, and author of the study explains the methodology: “For this study, CSE collected data from two sources -- websites of SPCBs/PCCs and their annual reports. The study has evaluated the information shared by SPCBs/PCCs during the last four tofive years (2016-21) and uses 25 indicators that provide a broader assessment on the type and amount of information shared. A few key indicators used in the study include the availability of information on direction/show cause/closure notices issued by boards, information on public hearings and EIA reports, non-attainment cities and polluted river stretches etc.” 

Key findings of the report 

Governance and functioning-related data remains paper-bound: Information on functioning, actions taken by a board against polluting industries, public hearing data on new projectsetcare rarely disclosed or remain difficult to access on the websites.For instance,

  • Only 12 states have shared their latest annual reports on their websites: Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Sikkim, Tripura and West Bengal have shared annual reports of the year 2019-20; the states of Chhattisgarh, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Odisha, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Tamil Nadu have shared annual reports of the year 2018-19 (which could be termed as the latest considering the COVID-19 situation in 2020). No initiative has been taken by 11 SPCBs/PCCs of the following states and Union territories in sharing their annual reports -- Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Bihar, J&K, Jharkhand, Manipur, Andaman & Nicobar, Chandigarh, Daman & Diu, Dadra & Nagar Haveli, Puducherry and Nagaland.
  • SPCB/PCCs have been protective of industries when it comes to non-compliance: Out of 35 SPCBs/PCCs, only five have shared soft copies of directions and show cause/closure notices issued on their websites – these are from J&K, Rajasthan, Telangana, Uttarakhand and West Bengal.
  • Only five boards -Delhi, Goa, Haryana, Tripura and Uttarakhand-have shared minutes of their board meetings on their websites: It is mandatory for SPCBs to meet at least once every three months.Board members in these meetings are supposed to discuss issues related to the functioning of the board, action plans, compliance and monitoring, and devising innovative methods to improve enforcement of laws.
  • Only five SPCBs have shared information on inspection conducted by the boards:The PCBs of Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka, Odisha, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal have shared this information in their annual reports.
  • Only nine SPCBs/PCCs have provided detailed information on public hearings, which includes the executive summary, draft EIA report of the project, and minutes of the meeting. The states represented are Karnataka, Telangana, Delhi, Gujarat, Kerala, Punjab, Rajasthan, Goa and Mizoram. 

Limited data on current pollution levels: Data indicating the current pollution levels – air pollutants, wasteetc– the basic indicators of environment health,is missing. Most boards display inadequate data, indicating no trends. More so, even details on upcoming projects and grievances of the general public of the locality are hardly displayed.

  • Only 19 SPCBs/PCCs are displaying their CEMS data: This, even after a statutory obligationto do it, as per a Supreme Court order (February 22, 2017) and an environment ministry directive (GSR 96(E) January 29, 2018).The states from where these PCBs/PCCs come are Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Delhi, Goa, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, J&K, Jharkhand, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Meghalaya, Odisha, Puducherry, Punjab, Tamil Nadu and Telangana. Of these 19, just five PCBs/PCCs display historical CEMS data.
  • Laxity in sharing information on solid waste: Fourteen SPCBs/PCCs do not share any information on municipal waste generation; 11 on plastic waste generation; 10 on hazardous waste; and nine on e-waste. 

Says Verma: “The study has also found a lack of uniformity in displaying data -- for instance, all the SPCBs/PCCssurveyed have different website formats, which makes accessing information quite difficult. Similarly, there is no format for annual reports: hence,the information available varies from board to board.” 

Nivitadds: “Improving transparency is a ‘must’when it comes to state pollution control boards. Putting in the public domain crucial pollution-related information, data and details of actions taken is critical – it can help policy-makers take the discussions to the next level of pollution management, and it can also reassure the people about efficiencyof these boards and committees.SPCBs and SPCCs,therefore, must focus urgently to become more transparent by putting out data and improving the quality of their outreach for public engagement.” 

For more details or for interviews, please contact Sukanya Nair of The CSE Media Resource Centre, sukanya.nair@cseindia.org, 8816818864

 

Tags:

Report
TRANSPARENCY INDEX: Rating of pollution control boards on public disclosure
Media coverage
CSE assessment of transparency of Indian pollution control boards
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
WBPCB scores high in CSE transparency study
Nagaland Pollution control board among least Transparent: study
Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board second best in country: Study
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
OSPCB Tops Transparency List
How transparent are our pollution control boards
How transparent are our pollution control boards?
Odisha Pollution Control Board Ranked No 1 In Transparency Index In Country
ODISHA STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD RANKED RATED NO-1 IN TRANSPARENCY INDEX
Odisha & Telangana pollution control boards ranked best in transparency index: Study
Odisha State Pollution Control Board Bags Top Rank In Transparency Index
Odisha Pollution Control Board Tops CSE Transparency Index
Tracking India’s Pollution data
Only 9 pollution control bodies share details of public hearings online: CSE transparency index
Transparency Index: Rating of Pollution Control Boards on Public Disclosure
Transparency Index rating: Odisha State Pollution Control Board tops list
CSE assessment of transparency of Indian pollution control boards
प्रदूषण डाटा सार्वजनिक करने में दिल्ली फिसड्डी
Pollution control boards are not transparent: CSE report
CSE study finds Indian pollution boards not very transparent with data, 67% is top score
Most pollution control boards in India are non-transparent: Centre for Science and Environment
Most pollution control boards in India are non-transparent: Centre for Science and Environment
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
Maharashtra among 17 pollution control boards scoring 50% + rating for transparency - Read key findings of study here
Few state pollution control authorities putting out environmental info in public domain: CSE
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
How transparent are India’s pollution control boards? Here is CSE’s ranking
Odisha & Telangana pollution control boards ranked best in transparency index
How Transparent Are Our Pollution Control Boards? CSE’s New Rating Report Finds Most Are Not
Most pollution control boards across India lack transparency, finds study
Pollution control boards are not transparent: CSE report
Few state pollution control authorities putting out environmental info in public domain: CSE
Odisha State Pollution Control Board Ranked Number One in CSE India’s Transparency Index Report
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
OSPCB tops transparency list
KSPCB scores 50+ pc in transparency index
प्रदूषण पर नियंत्रण करने वालों की पारदर्शिता भी हो रही प्रदूषित
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
Few state pollution control authorities putting out environmental info in public domain: CSE
Few state pollution control authorities putting out environmental info in public domain: CSE
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: says CSE study
Few state pollution authorities making environmental information publicly available: CSE
Pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
Most pollution control boards across India absence transparency, finds research
Odisha & Telangana pollution control boards ranked best in transparency index: Study – Gaonconnection
Delhi lags in data sharing on pollution, finds study
Most pollution control boards non-transparent: CSE
Pollution control boards of Odisha and Telagna ranked 1st in trasparency : CSE
Odisha & Telangana pollution control boards ranked best in transparency index: Study
Odisha State Pollution Control Board Ranked Number One in CSE India's Transparency Index Report
KSPCB scores 50+ pc in transparency index
Few state pollution control authorities putting out environmental info in public domain: CSE
KSPCB hailed for giving info on regulated entities
సీఎస్ఈ పారదర్శక సూచీలో తెలంగాణకు మొదటి ర్యాంకు